Jobs Report: Bad, but Not All Bad

by Bob Stein

Improvement in the labor market slowed noticeably in May. Including downward revisions for prior months, payrolls — both overall and for the private sector — expanded by only 20,000 jobs.

In addition, the total number of hours worked declined 0.2 percent in May, while average hourly earnings increased only 0.1 percent. Total cash wages are still up a hardy 3.5 percent from a year ago, but they’ve been essentially unchanged over the past three months. In addition, the average duration of unemployment increased, and the share of the unemployed who had quit their prior job dropped for the second straight month.

However, not all the data in today’s report was negative; in fact, some of it was actually quite strong. Civilian employment, an alternative measure of jobs that includes small-business start-ups, increased 422,000 in May. In the past year, civilian employment is up at a 190,000 monthly rate, versus a 149,000 pace for nonfarm payrolls. Although the unemployment rate ticked up to 8.2 percent in May, this was due to a 642,000-person increase in the labor force. In the past year, the labor force is up 1.1 million, while the unemployment rate has dropped 0.8 percentage points. Another piece of good news was that the diffusion index, the share of private companies that are adding jobs versus cutting jobs, increased to 59.4 percent in May.

One plausible explanation for the relative weakness of recent payroll numbers is the unusually mild winter. In the past six months (December through May), nonfarm payrolls are up an average of 174,000. December through February was above average, and now we’ve had three months below. Supporting the case for a weather effect, construction jobs were up an average of 14,000 in December to February, but down an average of 16,000 the past three months. Another possibility is that some firms are waiting for the outcome of the health-care ruling and election to see whether the coast is clear for more hiring. At this point, there is no clear sign that problems in Europe are the source of slower job creation in the U.S.

The Corner

The one and only.