Why the Secrecy?

by Ramesh Ponnuru

Andy, I’d be interested in getting your thoughts on this question: Why did this surveillance have to be kept secret? If so much information is being gathered about almost everyone to figure out patterns, then it’s not as though you’d be tipping off a particular target that we were on to him. Would publicizing the order that this information be collected have given away technical secrets to our enemies (or rather, at this point, has publicizing it done so)? I don’t see how. I can see why the government might want to keep this data-mining program secret to avoid a political backlash, but that is of course not a good reason for concealing it. Is there a better one?

The Corner

The one and only.