Our Generation’s Roe

by Maggie Gallagher

The combined result of these two decisions is profoundly lawless: Plaintiffs in DOMA have standing because, well, the Court wants to decide it. Proposition 8 plaintiffs representing 7 million California voters and determined by the California Supreme Court to have standing to defend the law in court if state officials refuse – denied justice, denied a hearing.

Kennedy’s decision substantively refuses to engage the argument for marriage, as Scalia notes, dubbing it all animus, desire to degrade, humiliate, disrespect. An awful, awful thing for a Supreme Court justice to do to people he disagrees with. Lawless, as well, because he declared a form of heightened scrutiny for laws that deviate from custom — a rule never applied to all the new liberal laws that deviate from custom.

In this respect, Kennedy has issued the Roe v. Wade of our generation.

The Corner

The one and only.