The Corner

The one and only.

Aid to The Stricken


At the risk of waking up tomorrow morning to find recruiters from the Ayn
Rand Institute camped on my front lawn, I’m having trouble convincing myself
that the US govt. should give *any* of our public monies to the stricken of
South Asia.

The call for “government aid” is, after all, just an anthropomorphizing of
government; and that leads to innumerable evils.

It is, in any case, as someone (Oakeshott?) has pointed out, a kind of
category error. We should not wish for our govt to be as we wish our
friends to be. I want my friends to be trusting and generous; but I’d
prefer my govt chronically suspicious, and when govt is generous, it’s
generous with OUR MONEY.

As private persons moved by this ghastly event, we should of course be free
to, and be ENCOURAGED to, do all we can to help. But “government aid”?


Sign up for free NR e-mails today:

Subscribe to National Review