Obamacare Takes a Shellacking

by Grace-Marie Turner

President Obama clearly doesn’t get it. His post-election news conference shows that he believes his health-policy agenda was correct and may only need a bit of “tweaking.”

Despite his acknowledgement that Democratic incumbents took a “shellacking,” he did not back down from the policies that caused dozens of them to lose their seats.

The president clearly is in denial. Health-care reform was very much a key part of Tuesday’s elections: New poll results out Wednesday from Bill McInturff and Public Opinion Strategies (POS) show that a vote for the president’s signature health-care law was a death knell for candidates.

McInturff found that 52 percent of independents said their vote was a message opposing President Obama’s health-care plan; only 18 percent said their vote was a message of support. Those numbers were crucial in bringing down Democratic candidates in dozens of swing House districts.

All five of the House Democrats who flipped to support final passage of the law in March lost. Two others retired, and Republicans took their seats. Sen. Russ Feingold (D., Wis.) and Rep. Earl Pomeroy (D., N.D.) were two rare Democrats who actively defended their votes for Obamacare. Both lost.

Voters who were basically told to shut up after last year’s tumultuous town-hall meetings about Obamacare patiently held their fire and flocked to the polls yesterday. Seniors in particular said they were opposed to the health overhaul by almost two to one, and they voted in greater numbers on Tuesday than they did in 2008.

POS found that nearly seven in ten voters (69 percent) had seen ads about “the changes to the health care system that have been enacted by Congress and the Obama Administration.” This is up significantly from the 42 percent recall in the POS October pre-election survey. And 70 percent said the ads they’d seen were critical of the Obama plan, 8 percent said the ads were supportive, and 20 percent said they recalled advertising on both sides of the issue.

Many House Democrats in swing districts who voted against the law survived basically by saying they know the law has serious problems and needs to be fixed.

But the president is not backing down. While he said he is willing to work with Republicans to refine the law, he said it would be “misreading the election if we thought that the American people want to see us for the next two years relitigate arguments that we had over the last two years.”

So what does he plan to do? Based upon his news conference today, not much. He said that the outcome of the law was good, but that the process of passing it was messy, and the deals made to pass it turned people off.

While the president said he would be open to considering changes to the massively unpopular requirement that businesses file 1099 forms with the IRS for purchases over $600, he just doesn’t hear how deeply Americans despise this law.

In his news conference, the president said while “we can tweak and make improvements on the progress that we’ve made,” he doesn’t think Americans want to repeal popular provisions like barring insurers from refusing to cover people with preexisting conditions or dropping people when they get sick. “I don’t think that you’d have a strong vote for people saying, you know, ‘Those are provisions I want to eliminate,’” he said.

This is the slicing and dicing that the administration has been doing all along in its health care messaging, focusing on a few small provisions of the law while the regulatory machinery is being built for a massive federal takeover of one-sixth of our economy.

The job of the next Congress will be to craft policies that will forestall the wreckage of Obamacare in hopes they can buy time for a repeal of the whole bill in 2013. The American people know it needs a lot more than “tweaking.” The law is fundamentally and structurally counter to the American values of freedom, limited government, and individual control over our lives and destiny.

Critical Condition

NRO’s health-care blog.