Boiling Pot
The immigration issue heats up.

By Ramesh Ponnuru
March 13, 2002 8:40 a.m.

 

ast night, the House voted 275-137 to let illegal immigrants become legalized upon payment of a $1,000 fine and identification of a sponsor. The vote was a victory of sorts for President Bush, who can tell Mexican president Vicente Fox that he's making progress toward legalizing illegals at their meeting next week. But it was only barely a victory.

Bush needed two-thirds of the votes because of the procedure under which the bill was brought up — a procedure normally used for uncontroversial measures. He got that majority, but only by one vote. And he had to rely on Democrats to do it. House Republicans voted against him, and their leadership, by a 123-92 margin. Democratic National Committee chairman Terry McAuliffe, referring to the leader of the anti-amnesty Republicans in the House, snarled that the GOP was a "Tom Tancredo Republican party," not a Bush party. There's considerable justice to his claim.

There were only 43 votes against the legalization proposal last year. This time around, it was attached to a popular measure to tighten security measures concerning people here on visas. But opposition jumped by 94 votes nonetheless. House Judiciary chairman Jim Sensenbrenner expressed his displeasure to some of the switchers. At least one of them told him that September 11 had changed his mind about the seriousness of border security.

The proposal now goes to the Senate, where Democrat Robert Byrd promises to hold it up.

The vote has to be taken as a warning to President Bush that any further movement on illegal immigrants is going to be difficult to achieve. That's the message House leaders will be giving him. Even one of Bush's major allies in the House, Roy Blunt, voted against him.

House Republicans who are considering seeking higher office this year were particularly likely to vote against Bush. Senate candidate John Thune of South Dakota voted against the proposal. So did Ed Bryant, who's running for Senate in Tennessee (and Democrats Bob Clement and Bart Gordon, who are said to be considering the race). Other Republican Senate candidates who voted against Bush were Saxby Chambliss of Georgia, John Cooksey of Louisiana, and Greg Ganske of Iowa.

Voting with the president was Rep. John Sununu of New Hampshire, who is also running for Senate.

 
If you would like to receive this or other NRO features via e-mail, please enter your e-mail address here:
 

BACK TO NRO


 
 
shim
shim