
 |
|
Updated 9/27/99
8:30 AM
GUN NUTS
Based on their votes earlier this year, Democrats have quite a record to
defend: for gun control, against tough and popular juvenile-justice
reforms, against enforcing gun laws on the books. But Speaker Denny
Hastert is still convinced that Republicans need to pass a gun bill, and
Henry Hyde is negotiating with John Conyers to get one out of the
Judiciary Committee. To get Conyers to go along, however, the bill will
have to be to the left of congressional sentiment. That sentiment is
clearly pro-gun, as revealed by 1) the 218-211 vote for the pro-gun
Dingell amendment in June; 2) the contemporaneous 235-193 rejection of the
McCarthy amendment the administration still wants; and 3) this week's 337
votes for John Doolittle's declaration that the second amendment protects
an individual right to bear arms. Keep in mind as well that 30 members of
Congress were reluctant to vote for the Dingell amendment because they
thought it wasn't pro-gun enough, and were only persuaded to do so by the
strategic arguments of Republican leaders and the NRA.
If a bill passes, it will do so with Democratic votes-which means that
Hastert will not have achieved the inoculation he wants and will also have
lost control of his conference. The more likely outcome is that nothing
will pass and the leadership will be embarrassed, as well it should be. In
either case, Republicans such as Tom Tancredo (whose district includes
Columbine) will be forced to cast tough votes, and pro-gun activists
across the country will have another reason to distrust Republican
leaders.
Meanwhile, Senate Judiciary Committee chairman Orrin Hatch is doing his
part to get the gun/crime bill passed. He has told Republicans that the
provision allowing state and local governments to let public schools post
the Ten Commandments on their walls should be removed. Otherwise, Pat
Leahy, his Democratic counterpart on the Judiciary Committee, will
filibuster. The provision is important to social conservatives, not just
because of its content but because it establishes the principle that
Congress has a right, and a responsibility, to interpret the Constitution
independent of the judiciary.
SAFETY FIRST
We've heard over and over again that Republicans have lost the crime issue
partly because of gun control. If that's the case, why aren't liberals
willing to use the words "gun control"? They always talk about "gun
safety" these days, which folds in accidental discharges-a dinky but scary
issue-and even gun-safety training of the kind the NRA itself provides.
The fact is, even most people who tell pollsters they support gun control
don't think of it as a major item on a crime-control agenda.
For a selection of recent Washington Bulletins
click here
If you would like to receive the Washington Bulletin via e-mail, please
send an e-mail message to majordomo@us.net. The first line in the body
of the message should read: "subscribe washingtonbulletin".
In order to ensure that you are not accidentally subscribed, you will
receive a reply message with a confirmation number, to which you must
reply to complete the subscription process.
To unsubscribe leave the subject line blank and have the first line in the body of the message read: "unsubscribe washingtonbulletin".
Updated By:
Ramesh Ponnuru - Senior Editor
John J. Miller - National Political Reporter
Kate Dwyer - Editorial Associate
Washington Bulletin | For the Record Online | Outrage du Jour The Goldberg File | Soapbox | Current Issue | Subscribe to NR Movie Reviews | Book Reviews | Garbage In, Garbage Out The Vibe | NR Extra | Bill Buckley's Word of the Day | Bookstore NR Archive | Mission Statement | Contact Us | The Legal Stuff
National Review 215 Lexington Avenue New York, New York 10016 (212) 679 7330
National Review is a
Member Organization
|