Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

June 11 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew

Close

New on NRO . . .

The Home Front

Politics, culture, and American life — from the family perspective.


Print   |  Text
 

The Parents Are Not All Right

Joel Bakan, a law professor at the University of British Columbia, has two teenagers who sometimes ignore him.  I know this because his recent New York Times op-ed called “The Kids Are Not All Right” begins this way:

When I sit with my two teenagers, and they are a million miles away, absorbed by the titillating roil of online social life, the addictive pull of video games and virtual worlds, as they stare endlessly at video clips and digital pictures of themselves and their friends, it feels like something is wrong.

Most parents have been on the outskirts of their kids’ awareness when they are too absorbed in one thing (a video game, their appearance, other people’s approval) and not absorbed enough in another (homework, church, the conversation at the dinner table).  But Bakan takes a normal parenting moment and extrapolates it into a full-fledged battle between children and…  wait for it… wait for it… corporations.

Yes, the “bad guy” in his example is some sort of corporate giant waiting to drive his kids’ minds to distraction.  He writes about the history of child abuse in mines, mills and factories in the 19th century, and the eventual child-labor laws.  And then, he makes a giant leap from the dusty coal shafts to an excess of Twitter or World of Warcraft:

A recent Kaiser Family Foundation study reports that children spend more hours engaging with various electronic media — TV, games, videos and other online entertainments — than they spend in school. Much of what children watch involves violent, sexual imagery, and yet children’s media remain largely unregulated. Attempts to curb excesses — like California’s ban on the sale or rental of violent video games to minors — have been struck down by courts as free speech violations.

However, Bakan concludes on a hopeful note.  He writes that “our current failure to provide stronger protection of children in the face of corporate-caused harm reveals a sickness in our societal soul. The good news is that we can — and should — work as citizens, through democratic channels and institutions, to bring about change.”

Guess what, professor? There’s even better news than you think!

You can control your own kids’ addiction to their iPhones and iPads by using a simple function called the “on/off” switch.  You can limit their ability to “stare endlessly” at video clips by giving them a pre-set daily amount of internet time.  You can even — gasp! — ask them to do a “Facebook fast” for a week to reignite the relationship with dear old dad.

Instead of looking to government regulation to assist you in protecting your kids’ childhoods, you can look directly at your kids, smile, and say, “Okay, guys.  I love you, and things are going to change.”

If they resist, you don’t have a “corporation” problem, you have a family problem.

New on The Home Front. . .


COMMENTS   6

EXPAND  

   08/25/11 12:20

I have 3 teenage sons and they do enjoy World of Warcraft. I wonder if Mr. Bakan investigated the percentage of accounts that use the Parental Controls option that assists a parent in regulating number of hours, times of day, and level of interaction. It does make this part of a Dad's job a bit easier.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   08/25/11 12:37

He's wrong, of course, and sadly he seems wrong mostly because he can't accept that HE is responsible for how his kids relate to him. It's his fault, not anyone else's and especially not any corporation.

All three of my sons play video games - including World of Warcraft - and are as involved in social media as any teen (or young adult as two of them are now), but since I made it a practice to be involved WITH them - I play WoW too because I want to be involved in their lives - I don't have any issues with them ignoring me, past normal teen stuff that has been going on for generations.

You lead your kids or they go their own way. Corporations aren't the problem and government isn't the answer.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   JRapp
   08/25/11 13:38

I’ve played MMOs for years and there’s nothing wrong with World of Warcraft, Blizzard, or any other gaming corporation. As others have stated, it comes down to parenting. MMOs CAN be very addicting for certain personality types and it’s the parents’ job to make sure that their kids have a balanced approach to WoW, or any other hobby. Have your kids finish their homework and chores before they log on, and sign them up for other real world activities. I for one very much look forward to playing the Star Wars MMO with my Daughter and Wife, turning a frivolous game into a family bonding activity.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   08/25/11 15:07

[Cranky old man voice]
In my day, we played our RPGs with Dice, pencils and papers! And We LIKED it![/Cranky old man voice]

More seriously, yes, games can be a way to bond, but like everything, in moderation. You make good points, as does Mrs. French. It is the failure of the parent when they can't tell their child 'no'.

(Hoping to play some Battltech with the godkids next weekend, and then teach them Pathfinder when the basic set comes out.)

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   08/27/11 09:06

It is so sad that people are more willing to buy the idea that a company is to blame for their disconnection with their kids, rather than take a hard look at their own choices.
I'm guessing these kids don't pay for their own phones or internet connectivity, so what is the big deal?
Limit. Done.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   08/29/11 17:42

"a sickness in our societal soul"

Wait, somebody actually wrote that with a straight face?

Bravo!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.




* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact