Google+
Close

Media Blog

NRO’s MSM watchdog.

Esquire Story on OBL Raid ‘Complete B-S’



Text  



Oh my. First the story of the SEAL not having insurance fell apart, and now the rest of Phil Bronstein’s story is in question? CNN’s Peter Bergen writes:

 

In February, Esquire magazine published a lengthy profile of “The Man Who Killed Osama bin Laden.” The story did not identify the killer by his real name, referring to him only as ”the Shooter.”

The Shooter told Esquire that the night bin Laden was killed he had encountered al Qaeda’s leader face-to-face in the top-floor bedroom of the compound in Abbottabad, Pakistan, where bin Laden had been hiding for more than five years.

The Shooter explained that when he found bin Laden in his bedroom the al Qaeda leader was standing up and had a gun “within reach” and it was only then that the Shooter fired the two shots into bin Laden’s forehead that killed him. That account was in conflict with the account from another raid participant in a wildly successful book “No Easy Day.”

 

Now, another member of the secretive SEAL Team 6, which executed the bin Laden raid, tells CNN the story of the Shooter as presented in Esquire is false. According to this serving SEAL Team 6 operator, the story is “complete B-S.”

SEAL Team 6 operators are now in “serious lockdown” when it comes to “talking to anybody” about the bin Laden raid and say they have been frustrated to see what they consider to be the inaccurate story in Esquire receive considerable play without a response. Phil Bronstein, who wrote the 15,000-word piece about the Shooter for Esquire, was booked on CNN, Fox and many other TV networks after his story came out.

The rest from Bergen here.

And from the archives in February when the milblog site “Blackfive” called the Bronstein piece “fiction.” 

But don’t feel bad for Phil Bronstein. If his career as an investigative reporter doesn’t pan out, he can always go to plan B: Komodo dragon whisperer.

 



Text  


Subscribe to National Review