RE: It’s the Charging Stations, Stupid
Greg, similar challenges exist for creating the infrastructure for CNG vehicles:
Natural gas is delivered across the country to millions of homes. But what would seem to be the ideal distribution network is actually the biggest headache of natural gas vehicles. Home natural gas is delivered at about 0.5 psi, but natural gas in vehicles needs to be pressurized to 3600 psi. So if you want to use CNG in your car, you’ll need a compressor. A National Fire Protection Association safety standard bans compressed gas storage in homes, so a stand-alone multistage compressor pump in the garage must be hooked up to the vehicle’s fuel tank, filling it directly. This leads to fueling times of up to 22 hours (even longer than equivalent home charging times for electric vehicles). Honda’s Civic Natural Gas is paired with a home compressor system called Phill ($4500), the only commercially available product of its kind. NatGasCar is developing a compressor system capable of 8-hour fill-ups; the current target price is $3500. Some states have incentivized the installation of high-speed filling systems at gas stations, where fill times are as brief as 4 to 5 minutes, much like gasoline’s. But these systems cost $750,000 per station to install, and low demand means there are only 941 high-pressure CNG filling stations scattered across the country, mostly in New York, California, Utah, and Texas.
If were’re looking for transportation fuels of the future, I believe CNG is the way to go. Even so, there are hurdles to overcome.