HELP
Archive
E-mail Comments
Send to a Friend
<% printurl = Request.ServerVariables("URL")%>Print Version
Saturday, March 01, 2003

WTC REBUILDING [John Derbyshire]
Another angle on this, from a reader with an excellent point to make:
One thing that surprises me is there has been no criticism for selecting a non-American firm. Especially since the firm is German. This country is standing in the way of our war on terrorism and, ironically, the staging country for most of the 9-11 hijackers!!! I work in the building design industry and, like many it is in bad shape right now. Most design firms are desperately seeking work. If ever there were a project that should be conceived, inspired, designed and executed by Americans, wouldn't it be this project to rebuild the Manhattan skyline. The heart and soul (and money) of the country is involved in this project but the plans and engineering will be executed on drawing tables in Berlin, Germany. I don't get it and I don't understand the lack of others questioning this selection.

Posted at 07:51 PM

FORGET TURKEY [Dave Kopel]
Now that we don't have to spend six billion dollars bribing Turkey to help us, let's take the money and build another aircraft carrier ($4.5 billion) and save the rest to pay for maintainance and personnel for the carrier.

Posted at 07:46 PM

COMING HERE [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
The Pakistanis are giving us the arrested sheikh.

Posted at 07:23 PM

TIMING IS EVERYTHING [John J. Miller]
Jonah: Perhaps the New Republic should label President Bush "The 9/10 President" more often--given the spectacular success in Pakistan today, just two days after TNR's new issue is out.

Posted at 06:14 PM

BORAT, NOW AND FOREVER [Rod Dreher]
The unofficial UK website for the pride of Kazakh broadcast journalism.

Posted at 05:24 PM

AKHMATOVA [Andrew Stuttaford]

Some people, at least, knew how to remember the Stalin years. Writing in 1957, the poetess Anna Akhmatova recalled an encounter from the time she was trying to visit her son, who had been jailed by the secret police:

“In the fearful years of the…terror I spent seventeen months in prison queues in Leningrad. One day someone ‘identified’ me. Besides me, in the queue, there was a woman with blue lips. She had, of course, never heard of me; but she suddenly came out of that trance so common to us all and whispered in my ear (everybody spoke in whispers there): “Can you describe this?” And I said: “Yes I can.” And then something like the shadow of a smile crossed what had once been her face.”

And describe it, Akhmatova did:

“In those years only the dead smiled,

Glad to be at rest:

And Leningrad city swayed like

A needless appendix to its prisons.

It was then that the railway-yards

Were asylums of the mad:

Short were the locomotives’

Farewell songs.

Stars of death stood

Above us, and innocent Russia

Writhed under bloodstained boots, and

Under the tires of Black Marias”

From Requiem (1957)


Posted at 04:42 PM

CALLED TO ACCOUNT? [Andrew Stuttaford]

Edvard Radzinsky’s Stalin has a good account of Stalin’s last days. This short passage caught my attention today:

“After February 17 no visitors to Stalin’s office are recorded. In fact he never returned to Moscow after that date. Someone has drawn a red line in the margins of the register as though closing the account.”

Except, of course, that this is an account that can never be closed.


Posted at 04:28 PM

A BIG DEAL [Jonah Goldberg]
The capture of Khalid Shaikh Mohammed is fantastic news. But somehow I suspect that the Democrats will continue to claim that the war on al Quaeda is being neglected. Considering the fact there hasn't been a single successful attack on US soil since 9/11 while there have been numerous arrests of terrorist cells, I've never understood this argument. But that can wait 'til Monday. This great news.

Posted at 04:25 PM

FIFTY YEARS ON [Andrew Stuttaford]

This weekend’s Financial Times features a number of articles to mark the fiftieth anniversary of Stalin’s death (the old tyrant died on March, 5th 1953). There’s a lot that's worth reading, but the highlights include an interview with Robert Conquest, the greatest western historian of Soviet terror. Amongst the stories he tells is the response of French communists when Stalin lowered the age for the death penalty for children to 12:

"It was acceptable, they claimed, “because in Russia, they said, people mature so much quicker.""


Posted at 04:24 PM

BLOK BLOCK BLOCKED [Andrew Stuttaford]

Contrary to some of the bad press it has received recently, Belgium is, in its melancholy and rain-sodden way, a strangely alluring country (listen to Jacques Brel’s Le Plat Pays if you doubt me), but the ways of the appalling Belgian establishment make it all too appropriate that the country should be the epicenter of the EU, a body that is increasingly intolerant of dissent.

Here's a story from the London Guardian on Belgium's attempts to deal with the challenge posed by the Vlaams Blok, a Flemish nationalist party on the far right. The Blok is very far from being a likeable organization, to put it mildly, but the way to deal with such parties is through debate, argument and the ballot box. That's how democracy works.

Not all Belgians agree, apparently. Some of them tried another tack – they took the Blok to court.

And now it’s backfired. Idiots.


Posted at 04:10 PM

ARREST [Andrew Stuttaford]
This looks like good news.

Posted at 03:43 PM

DOOMSDAY RECIPE [Andrew Stuttaford]

Another reader seems to think that one way that Aage could get round his legal difficulties is to prepare ‘special’ pizzas just for French and Germans. They could, he suggests, be topped with “all the weird crap they eat over there”.

Well, maybe, but let’s face it – a lot of that “weird crap” (the reader’s list includes liverwurst, sauerkraut and snails) is quite delicious. If Aage really wants to discourage French and German customers, why not offer them something American. Doctor Pepper should do the trick.

Of course, that will scare off the Brits, the Vilnius Ten and everyone else too.


Posted at 03:39 PM

AAGE'S PIZZA [Andrew Stuttaford]
A number of people have written to ask where Aage can be found. Well, there are some e-mail contact details here

Posted at 03:33 PM

BOOYAKASHA! [Rod Dreher]

Have you seen HBO's "Da Ali G. Show"? Oh, man, you gotta! "Ali G." is the creation of a British comedian named Sacha Baron Cohen. Ali G. is a Cockney "wigger," a hip-hop white gangsta clod who has his own interview show. In the taped episodes now running, Ali G. gets interviews with serious figures like Boutros-Boutros Ghali, Gen. Brent Scowcroft, ex-Atty Gen. Dick Thornburgh, et al. He straight-facedly asks them outrageously stupid questions (e.g., he asks ex-CIA director James Woolsey to return to the grassy knoll in Dallas to explain who really shot J.R.). What's so great is that these poor interview subjects don't realize they're being put on, and answer his questions with respect. It's a great send-up of what's happened to political journalism since Bill Clinton went on MTV and answered some yo-yo's question about his underwear.

Cohen has two other characters: Bruno, an outrageously gay Austrian fashion reporter; and Borat, a comically naive, sex-mad TV reporter from Kazakhstan, who travels the U.S. exposing himself, so to speak, to American culture. This show is ribald comic genius. Click here and here for videoclips and other info. New half-hour episodes come on every Friday night (Saturday morning) at 12:30 a.m. EDT, but they repeat throughout the week (see the schedule here).


Posted at 03:24 PM

THIN SKINS [John Derbyshire]
Rod: You want thin-skin stories? I got thin-skin stories. Friday I had a jokey exchange with Andrew in The Corner, concerning my train wreck of an adolescence. I had mentioned that I spent a lot of time constructing mathematical model out of card, but that this period of my life was a social failure. Andrew suggested the two things might be connected. I replied by observing that "very, very few attractive young women are interested in the 59 stellations of the icosahedron." Not an hour passed before this popped up in my Inbox:

Mr. Derbyshire: The perpetuation of the stereotype that attractive women cannot also be smart is irresponsible, no matter how well-intended. While I understand that you are poking fun at yourself, try to leave us out of your self-effacing humor. ... I'm trying to impress upon you the need to recognize that your comments, when coupled with Kathy's Barbie note (a real sore point when I was in college), are setting the wrong tone in the Corner today. Sorry to knee-jerk on you on this one, but it's tough enough to fight this preconception without its mention in such a public forum.

Now, this reader is polite, well-intentioned, and obviously a thoroughly civilized person. She makes a friendly remark about my forthcoming book. I therefore hate myself for what I am about to say--not just for the lost book sale, but for reasons to do with ordinary human sympathy--but I'm going to say it anyway: Lady, GET YOURSELF A LIFE!

(And if this lady really _is_ interested in the stellations of the icosahedron, I'd also like to ask her: WHERE WERE YOU WHEN I NEEDED YOU?)

Posted at 02:18 PM

"THE HORRORS OF PEACE" [Rod Dreher]
Stephen Hayes of the Weekly Standard has a terrific piece out based on a visit and interviews with Iraqi exiles in the United States, who talk in detail about the ghoulish misery the tyrant of Baghdad has inflicted upon his people. Buried deep in the story is an anecdote about how during the Gulf War, when the first Bush administration was busy betraying the same Iraqis it had successfully urged to rise up against Saddam, Paul Wolfowitz personally intervened with Dick Cheney, then the Secretary of Defense, to save 30,000 Iraqi patriots set for massacre by Saddam.

Posted at 12:18 PM

MAN BITES DOG [Rod Dreher]
I nearly spilled my coffee this morning when I saw that Dr. Ted Green of Harvard, the medical anthropologist who has been trying for years to alert the scientists and others fighting AIDS as to the success the Ugandans have had by promoting abstinence and fidelity, has published this heretical common sense on the op-ed page of today's New York Times. NRODT subscribers will remember Dr. Green as a prime source for my recent story on AIDS in Africa. He's one of the good guys, and it means something that the Times, the voice of the liberal establishment, is taking his views seriously now.

Posted at 12:13 PM

PUBLIUS FELLOWSHIPS [John J. Miller]
The Claremont Institute is seeking applicants for three-week-long Publius Fellowships. The program "is dedicated to preserving the tradition of American political writing of which Publius was the noblest exemplar. It aims to foster constructive commentary on the important issues of our time, informed and moderated by an understanding of the philosophic and historical roots of American democracy." I know from personal experience that they don't let ordinary riffraff into the program--my own application was rejected about a decade ago. So check it out, and good luck!

Posted at 10:50 AM

HOW TO WRITE [John J. Miller]
One of my best teachers at the University of Michigan was a guy named John Rubadeau, who taught a class on argumentative writing. On my way to becoming a professional writer, I've had a few turning-point experiences--and taking his class as a sophomore was one of them. Here's his short article on how to write interesting essays. Click on the link if only to see the picture of a man with a beard bigger than his own head. Also, don't forgot to look at his footnotes.

Posted at 10:40 AM

CORRECTION [Jonah Goldberg]

A reader points out that I mistakenly and inadvertanly mischaracterized Scott Ritter's position on the existence of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. Ritter's position is not that they never existed, but that they are no longer there and that, therefor, there's no evidence of them still being there. I'll flesh that out in a future column, but I just wanted to be on record.


Posted at 09:26 AM

SENATOR MIGUEL ESTRADA (R., NY) [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
A revenge scenario, if needed.

Posted at 07:00 AM

TOO COLD TO GO OUTSIDE....I GOTTA IDEA! [NRO Staff]

GET 4 FREE ISSUES OF NATIONAL REVIEW!
That's right: We'll send you 4 FREE issues of National Review at absolutely no risk to you. If you're impressed by National Review's superior writing style, analysis, and wit, we'll send you the next 12 issues — for a total of 16 in all! — for only $19.95. Click here for details.


Posted at 06:52 AM

NIFTY IDEA!!! [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
We're going to start checking everyone who comes into the U.S. for radioactive material. That doesn't count the miles unprotected border, of course, but it's a start this March 1, 2003....

Posted at 06:49 AM

OH FOR PETE'S SAKE [Rod Dreher]
For some reason, a few readers think my piece today talking about Islamic eschatology, and pointing out similarities between it and the End Times scenario espoused by some Evangelicals was meant to disparage Evangelicals. I cannot account for thin skins, but for the record, I don't think there's anything but the most superficial similarities between infidel-killin' Wahoobis and American Evangelical Christians. I did the piece because I found it interesting that Islam has an eschatology that derives some elements from Christianity, and that there have been Hal Lindsey-type figures in Islam who have put forth the idea that things taking place right now in the Middle East are part of the Last Days events.

Posted at 12:23 AM

Friday, February 28, 2003

OR ELSE [John Derbyshire]
Jonah: It's tangential, but I used to hang out with Germans a lot, and noticed that they end an awful lot of sentences with the fragment: "Oder was?" Means: "Or what?" and presumably is where our own "Or what?" comes from (very likely via Yiddish). Perhaps there is some similar trail with "Or else."

Posted at 04:57 PM

OR ELSE -- FROM AN ENGLISH PROF [Jonah Goldberg]

Jonah:

The phrase "or else" is much older than your previous correspondent suggested. The phrase definitely existed in Middle English. Chaucer, who died at the end of the 14th century, used it often, most famously in his "Complaint to His Purse," which you can check out [here]


In the poem--a satiric love-ode to his empty purse and intended to make the new king laugh and send him some cash--Chaucer implores his money-sack, "Beth hevy agen, or elles moot I dye!" ("Be heavy again, or else I might die!"--delightfully pronounced, in Middle English, "or ellis motey dey-uh!")

The word "else" ("elles") is even older, from Old English, and crops up in _Beowulf_ and other Anglo-Saxon poems and prose works from the 10th century or earlier. I couldn't find any *specific* examples in the small corpus of surviving Old English texts to suggest that it was used to mean "or else," but it may have been, because even back them it had most of the other current meanings and usages (such as "otherwise").

Such questions are fine pasttimes for drowsy medievalists on cold, snowswept Fridays.

UPDATE: He sent me this follow-up email:
Cancel that last email! Just re-read and saw you were looking exclusively for "trailing" or-elses. My apologies--please ignore previous e-mail!


Posted at 04:38 PM

ONE MORE THING ON MCCARTHYISM [Jonah Goldberg]

By a rough count, I've had two dozen people call me fascist. One person wrote to AOL to tell them that I am "Hitler incarnate." I began my McCarthy column referring to the erosion of meaning words suffer on the liberal side of the aisle. If I am Hitler incarnate, what words are left to describe genocidal murderers? If I am a fascist, what words are left for people advocating syndicalist economics and thuggish mass movements?


Posted at 04:35 PM

SILENT CONCENTRATION [John Derbyshire]
No, Kathryn, I am sure I have not driven everyone away from The Corner. My guess is, they are all busy with scissors and card, making models of the lesser truncated rhombicosidodecahedron. It is a wonderful feeling, to be able to inspire people like this.

Posted at 04:18 PM

PIP-EMMA [John Derbyshire]
Several readers want me to explain what "pip-emma" means. Glad to oblige. It is British army Signals Corps slang for "p.m." Okay?

Posted at 03:34 PM

HELLO? [John Derbyshire]
Why can't I get through on the phone to anyone at NR? What does Vicki mean by "There's nobody in the office"? There must be somebody in the office. Hello? Next thing I know you'll be cutting me off in the middle of a Corner posting. It seems that

Posted at 02:56 PM

RE: A DIFFICULT EQUATION [John Derbyshire]
Andrew: It is a sad fact about the world that very, very few attractive young women are interested in the 59 stellations of the icosahedron. It's all part of God's plan, I suppose; but one can't help wondering if He didn't have some spells of absent-mindedness when He was putting this whole thing together.

Posted at 02:37 PM

A DIFFICULT EQUATION [Andrew Stuttaford]
Let's see. The Derb reveals that (a) he spent many hours during his adolescence making mathematical models, and (b) discloses that his adolescence was "otherwise an utter failure."
Could these two facts be related, I wonder?

Posted at 02:21 PM

MYSTERY PLANE OVER INDIANA [Rod Dreher]
What they're talking about in Bloomington.

Posted at 02:18 PM

POLYHEDRA [John Derbyshire]
Useful? Useful? This is P-U-R-E M-A-T-H-E-M-A-T-I-C-S, you benighted souls. USEFUL? Ptui! I spit.

Posted at 02:09 PM

OR ELSE A READER ANSWERS THE QUESTION [Jonah Goldberg]
Gentlemen, According to the Oxford English Dictionary, the first uses of "or else" in "trailing" form appear to have occurred in the 19th century, drawing upon the then-centuries'-old use of the phrase with a similar meaning but with the threats explicitly stated. The OED also defines the "trailing" use of the word as aposiopesis: the alternative to be imagined. ;)

Posted at 02:05 PM

MARDI GRAS GOES TO WAR [Rod Dreher]

Steve Teeter from New Orleans sent this encouraging dispatch yesterday, but I've been out of the office all week, and only just now got it:


Rod, you MUST know about this at once. Convey to the Corner as you see
fit.

I live in New Orleans on Napoleon Avenue, just above Magazine Street, which means that just about every uptown Carnival parade goes right in front of my house. (Because of the construction on Canal Street, they're all uptown this year.) Minutes ago I was out watching the Krewe of Chaos parade, Chaos being a three-year-old krewe formed from some of the members of the venerable Momus krewe, and continuing their ancient tradition of satire and mockery of current institutions and events.

Float No. 6 sent me rapidly indoors to my keyboard. In the Momus tradition, it was a moderate sized float with 8 or 10 masked riders throwing beads, and it was titled "The Betrayal." The papier-mache figure on the front was a rather ridiculous looking frog. Along the sides were painted images of determined-looking soldiers carrying American flags through heavy fire, with placards on the float reading "WW-I," "WW-II," "Cold War," "D-Day." At the rear was a sort of blocky superstructure labeled "French Toaster" with the NATO symbol on its side. At the front, just under the frog and facing forward, was the painted image of a rifle and two placards, the first thing all parade goers would see as it comes down the street, reading "French rifles for sale," "Never fired, dropped once."

In the next few hours, this float will roll in front of tens of thousands of parade goers as it wends its way down to Canal Street, and if the reaction of the people I heard around me is any indication, it will be greeted all the way by gales of laughter and loud cheers.


Posted at 01:45 PM

POLYHEDRONS: THIS SEEMS VERY APPROPRIATE [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
An email:
Ma'am, A real world example of what Mr. D. is talking about. Think of all those oddly shaped dice that players of Dungeons and Dragons use. Hope this is useful.

Posted at 01:43 PM

OK, I KNOW YOU WANT IT [John Derbyshire]
The 13 semi-regular convex polyhedra.

Posted at 01:06 PM

HOW DO YOU FIT THE EMPIRE STATE BUILDING INTO A 1-INCH CUBE? [John Derbyshire]
The fact, by the way, that there is a figure equivalent to the cube--i.e. a sort of super-cube--in any number of dimensions, provides the answer to the question in my subject line. A 1-inch square (i.e. every one of its sides is just 1 inch long) has a longest diagonal whose length is the square root of 2. A 1-inch cube (every edge 1 inch long) has a longest diagonal whose length is the square root of 3. A 1-inch 4-dimensional hypercube has a longest diagonal whose length is the square root of 4. And so on. This is a general rule: A 1-inch n-dimensional super-duper-hypercube has a longest diagonal whose length is the square root of n. The Empire State Building is around 15,000 inches high, and that is the square root of 225,000,000. So if you construct a 1-inch cube-equivalent in a space of 225 million dimensions, the ESB will fit into it very nicely.

Posted at 12:39 PM

TRULY AWFUL POP-SONG LYRICS [John Derbyshire]
Lotsa input from readers, thanks to all. It is salutary to be reminded how many truly, truly terrible pop songs have been written. Another favorite of mine: "Tell Laura I Love Her," with the classic lines: "And as they pulled him from the twisted wreck, With his dying breath they heard him say: 'Tell Laura...' etc."

Posted at 12:34 PM

ESTRADA UPDATE [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Byron has the latest; his reporting corrects some other reporting that has been in the news this today (Fox, for one)--that the administration has released those Solicitor General Office memos the Dems have been crowing about (they have not been).

Posted at 12:17 PM

CORNER MATH LESSON [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Do you take credit cards?

Posted at 12:14 PM

POLYHEDRA [John Derbyshire]
It's perfectly simple, Kathryn, and the kind of math anyone can follow. Start with a triangle. There are all sorts of triangles, of course: tall thin ones, short squat ones, no-particular-shape ones. The nicest one is the one whose three sides are all equal length (& so its 3 angles all 60 degrees). That is a regular triangle. Same with 4-sided figures: the square is the regular one--sides & angles all equal. There's also a regular pentagon, a regular hexagon, and so on--along, of course, with lots of irregular ones in each case. So there is an infinite family of regular polygons. Now: what would be the equivalent in 3 dimensions? The 3-D equivalent of "polygon" (2-D figure with straight sides) is "polyhedron" (3-D figure with flat faces). The most regularity you can get is when (A) all the faces are regular polygons, and (B) they are all the SAME regular polygon. The ancient Greeks showed that there are just five convex polyhedra satisfying both (A) and (B), the so-called Five Platonic Solids. They are the top five in the top photograph on Jeff's site. If you drop condition (B)--i.e. the faces must be regular polygons, but need not be all the same--you get the semiregular polyhedra. There are 13 convex possibilities. If you drop the "convexity" condition & allow, e.g., not only pentagons but also pentacles, you are in the world of stellated polyhedra. Oh, in case you are wondering, there are six regular convex figures in 4-D; but in any number of dimensions higher than 4, there are only 3.

Posted at 12:12 PM

OR ELSE [John Derbyshire]
Jonah: I just went through Shakespeare looking for trailing "or elses" & didn't find one. There are 137 occurrences of "or else" in the plays and 3 in the Sonnets, but none of them is trailing. Hey, thanks for wasting a quarter of an hour of my time!

Posted at 12:10 PM

I HAVE A NON-MATH QUESTION [Jonah Goldberg]

For Derb: When did the phrase "or else?" become a threat without need of finishing the sentence? Presumably at some point people would say "...or else we will cut out your tongue!" Or, "...or else, we will sew a ferret into your small intestine." When did the threat become implied? Was it a Shakespearean construction or deconstruction? Alas, unlike your Abbot and Costello question I have no idea what the answer is.


Posted at 11:51 AM

GREAT DANE UPDATE [Andrew Stuttaford]
Is Aage Bjerre in trouble? According to news agency reports Danish police are investigating Aage for his refusal to sell pizzas to French and German customers. Apparently "legal experts in the Copenhagen justice department are checking whether it [is] illegal to discriminate against someone by refusing to sell them pizza on the grounds of their nationality". However, a police spokesman has confirmed that the investigation "would not be pursued with the same intensity as a burglary or violence." That's a relief.

On a cheerier note, it turns out that Aage has received a pizza order from a group of US Marines in Maryland, That's the Marines for you: Semper Pie.

Posted at 11:46 AM

COSTELLO [Jonah Goldberg]

I also once read that he had a dime (or maybe it was a penny, considering inflation) stuck in his ear for nearly 30 years. Don't know where I read it or whether it's true.


Posted at 11:45 AM

WHAT WAS IT THAT THAT BARBIE DOLL SAID? [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
"Math is hard!" I have no clue what you are talking about, Derb. Wow. But, man, you are the renaissance man.

Posted at 11:27 AM

GOT YOUR RHOMBITRUNCATED CUBOCTAHEDRON YET? [John Derbyshire]
I may be going out too far on the math limb here, but I have found a small firm that makes wonderful mathematical models: I spent many happy hours in my adolescence (which was otherwise an utter failure) constructing models like this, with Cundy & Rollett's Mathematical Models as my guide. My pride and joy was five cubes in a dodecahedron, with each cube painted a different color. I just used card, though: this firm does it with high-precision aluminum die-casting. Jeff Tupper, who runs the outfit (they are called Pedagoguery Software Inc.) tells me he hopes in future to produce all the interesting convex (5 regular, 13 semi-regular) polyhedra, possibly the 13 semi-regular duals, too. After that, they may tackle stellated polyhedra, which will be a real challenge... Hello? Are you still reading? Hello?....

Posted at 11:23 AM

HOW ABBOT & COSTELLO SPLIT THE PROCEEDS [John Derbyshire]
Abbot-60, Costello-40. Supply and demand: there were (and are) far fewer good straight men than good funny men. Think how someone gets to be a comic: he wants to tell jokes and make people laugh. Working at this for years and years, he builds up the necessary skills of timing & delivery. Being a straight man is different, the kind of job you wander into accidentally. Nobody starts out in life with the ambition to stand next to another guy who is cracking jokes. Yet the straight-man skill set is just as deep. For example: you must train yourself NOT TO MOVE A MUSCLE while your partner is delivering a line. If you even blink, it distracts the audience's attention to you, and they miss your partner's line. There is a lot about this in Phil Silver's excellent and funny autobiography.

Posted at 11:18 AM

THAT'S TERRIBLE [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Hundreds of high-school seniors who were sent thin rejection envelopes in their snail mail were mistakenly sent an e-mail from the Cornell Admissions Office welcoming them into the Class of 2007, due to a clerical error. A follow-up e-mail explained they were all actually rejected.

Posted at 11:12 AM

SURRENDER MONKEYS SURRENDERING SURRENDER? [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Chirac's party giving him grief over his antiwar position.

Posted at 11:05 AM

STEPHANOPOULOS VS. RUSSERT [Jonah Goldberg]

I have to say I'm surprised "This Week" is doing so badly against "Meet the Press." I think Russert does a good job and all, but he seems so concerned with being the Sunday Show of Record. Meanwhile, "This Week" tends to break news and its panel -- especially when Fareed Zakaria is on -- is far superior to the occasional snore-fest panels on "Meet the Press" with Safire and Doris Kearns Goodwin.


Posted at 09:32 AM

WHO WANTS TO MARRY YASSIR MILLIONAIRE? [Jonah Goldberg]

Great item, via Drudge, about how Yassir Arafat is worth "at least" 300 million dollars. What a servant of his people.


Posted at 09:28 AM

"WHY WE FOUGHT" [Jonah Goldberg]
A review of the Black Book of Communism from National Review though, oddly, not in the pages of National Review Online.

Posted at 07:16 AM

Thursday, February 27, 2003

MORE [Jonah Goldberg]

Here's an email titled, "Under what rock did you crawl out from?"

Jonah,

I applaud your red-baiting ignoramus-rousing article,
"Two Cheers for “McCarthyism.”

http://www.nationalreview.com/goldberg/goldberg022603.asp

You are a true example of why George Bush's Junta should be brought down a soon as possible. As US deficits soar, as false Homeland Security warnings abound, as the stock market continues to sink from the lack of addressing corporate fraud, we have you, Jonah Goldberg, tells us how wonderful it was to have Joe McCarthy falsely accusing thousands of upstanding Americans of being Communists.

Maybe we are better off with Bush's attack on Iraq resulting in having the whole Arab world committed to Jihad against America, rather than re-instituting McCarthyism. Why not? You are rich and can avoid the effects of the global upheaval that will result from your hero's misdirected war.



Posted at 10:30 PM

HERE WE GO [Rod Dreher]
Karl Rove has cancelled plans to speak at a March 12 political engagement in New Hampshire. Hmm... .

Posted at 07:49 PM

RE: BLEG [John Derbyshire]
Many thanks to the numerous readers who responded. There was less to this than meets the eye (than met my ear, I mean). Everyone agrees that "Goo Fay" is just Costello's idea of a Frenchman's pronunciation of "Goofy." This must have been a lot funnier in 1946 than it seems to me now, to judge from the gales of audience laughter. The actual sketch, however, is still one of the all-time best comedy routines, for my money. Just listen to their timing! BTW, does everyone know how A & C split the proceeds from their act? I was surprised when I heard.

Posted at 06:46 PM

BLEG: AMERICANA [John Derbyshire]
Here is a bleg about Americana. I have a tape of an old (1946) radio show with Abbott & Costello doing the "Who's on First?" sketch. In the run-up to the sketch itself, A & C have an exchange along the following lines. I'm transcribing it as I hear it... and that's the point, because I don't understand the joke. Can someone please explain it to me?
A: ... they give these ball players nowadays very peculiar names... C: You mean funny names? A: Strange names, pet names, like Dizzy Dean... C: And his brother Daffy? A: ...Daffy Dean... C: And his French cousin. A: French? C: Goo Fay. A: Goo Fay Dean... Oh, I see... [Lots of audience laughter.]
What am I missing here? Who or what was "Goo Fay Dean"? (Please don't explain the stuff about "Who's on first"---that, I get.)

Posted at 05:47 PM

I WONDER IF THEY WILL TAKE HIS NOBEL AWAY? [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Ellie Wiesel supports the Iraq war.

Posted at 05:42 PM

HERE COME DA JUDGES? [Jonathan H. Adler]
The Senate Judiciary Committee approved three appellate nominees today on bipartisan votes: John Roberts, Deborah Cook, and Jay Bybee. This does not mean all three are in the clear, however. As Robert Novak details here, some Senators are intent on holding up more of President Bush's appellate nominees.

Posted at 05:32 PM

TWO EMAILS CONTRA CAL PUNDIT [Jonah Goldberg]
Jonah: Your "fair enough" response to this position is very congenial and illustrates a significant difference between conservatives and the left. If a conservative speaks or attends a seminar etc. at a place like Bob Jones University he or she will not be characterized as having a "vague association" with a fundamentalist group by the left.That person will be villified as showing their true colors.etc. Almost every person of the left I have known will tell you sooner or later that disagreement with their point of view means you are either stupid or a bigot. No leftist I have ever met would have been as receptive to an alternative point of view as you were to CALPUNDIT.

By the way all your efforts are a delight to read but this McCarthy
piece is a keeper.

AND:

Jonah, I have to admit my first reaction to your column was similar to Cal Pundit's. Shame on me for not reading more carefully. You are correct that there is nothing wrong in hunting communists, McCarthys's problem was that he did it with such paranoia and self-serving dishonesty. And you clearly identified him as a lout. Such a marvelous and infrequently used term is lout. You should do more with this. How about an online poll where readers vote for the "Greatest lout of the past" and "Greatest lout of the present". McCarthy could lead the list of choices from the past and, though my first reaction is to lead the list of the present with Bill Clinton, methinks Chuck Schumer would be far more appropriate (in the vein of McCarthyite dishonesty).

Posted at 05:08 PM

CAL PUNDIT [Jonah Goldberg]

Has some thoughtful criticisms of my column. But I think he's missing the central point. He writes, "It's not McCarthyism to accuse a communist of being a communist. It is McCarthyism to accuse someone of being a communist who has only a vague association with communist friends, groups, or ideas."

Fair enough. And as I said the column and in the Corner, I am no defender of false-accusations and I think McCarthy's tactics set back the cause of anti-Communism. But the Hollywood Ten, for example, were not victims of "McCarthyism" since there was nothing vague about their membership -- not "association"-- with the Communist Party. Moreover, McCarthy had little to nothing to do with Hollywood communists. When Lilian Hellman said that anti-Communists picked communism as a cause with as much cynicism as Hitler picked anti-Semitism, she meant that there was no substance to the search for Communists. But there was. They did help Stalin get the atomic bomb, you know. That's hardly a strategically trivial point. Every effort to find, expose and punish spies and vassals for an enemy power -- which, again was really quite evil -- was ridiculed as McCarthyism. That's why the opponents of the Bush administration use the word so much. They want to suggest there is no point to looking for terrorists in our midst because they don't exist and anyone who claims otherwise is a bigot of some kind.

As for Calpundit's assertion that I spend 1,000 words defending McCarthy the "man," I'm not sure what he's talking about. It seems to me I defended the cause of anti-Communism which liberals routinely label "McCarthyism." As for the man, how many times do I have to call him a "lout" and a "jerk" before Calpundit will see that I'm not defending the man?


Posted at 03:51 PM

RANDIAN BLOGGERS FOR TAILGUNNER JOE [Jonah Goldberg]

Now that's something you don't hear everyday.
Check it out.



Posted at 03:27 PM

FASCINATING [Jonah Goldberg]

I'm not going to post all of these emails. But i find this one really intriguing because of its larger significance:

I am constantly amazed by the views of a conservative mind. I was an Eisenhower Republican when I was young, but the party moved so far to the right after that, at ever increasing speeds, that I am proud to call myself a Democrat now. The Democratic Party moved to the center and replaced the Republican Party's concern for civil rights, the middle class, and sensible economic policies. A conservative, it seems to me, is homophobic in that they see evil in essentially all peoples that they disagree with. How sorrowful to have to live like that.

The first two thirds is boilerplate. But then this guys says that conservatives are "homophobic" because they see evil in essentially all peoples that they disagree with."

Again I say: Fascinating! Already, Fascism means anything undesirable, McCarthyism means anything mean and, now, homophobia means hatred of people who disagree with you. You would think that even this guy would understand that we still need words for people who don't like homosexuals. I confess that I don't like the word homophobia because I think fear is not necessarily the best explanation for anti-gay views. But we're stuck with it.

But here we have someone who believes, in all honesty, that hatred of active, dues paying, spying, Stalinists can best be described as "homophobia." This is the sort of slippery thinking that will give you road rash on your butt if you don't watch out. Are environmentalists homophobes because they hate oil men? Are vegans homophobes because they hate meat-eaters? Are gays homophobes if they hate Christian fundamentalists? By this logic I guess my dog is a homophobe because he loathes squirrels so. Then again, you know what people say about squirrels...


Posted at 03:10 PM

STUDENT WAR SUPPORTERS [Sarah Maserati]
A pro-Bush, pro-war student group has been founded at Harvard Law School to oppose the anti-warriors: Students for Protecting America.

Posted at 03:04 PM

TAILGUNNER JOE [John Derbyshire]
As a footnote to Jonah's splendid essay on McCarthy, here is a piece I did for NRODT 5 yrs ago.

Posted at 02:31 PM

FOR EXAMPLE [Jonah Goldberg]

This guy makes me want to say nah-nah, booby-booby:

what disgusting drivel this one is. I used to think there might be a bottom for you conservatives to hit at some time. Now I think there is no low limit you folks will sink to in trying to justify your hatred of all people who do not agree with your and your self righteous bullshit. If you had lived during the Mcarthy era it might remind you of the lies, destruction and anti American wave of hatred and fear he generated through out our society. He was a liar and a boob and it was not till he was finally outted that we were able to resume life as Americans who could agree to disagree over political ideas. One thing you conservatives seem to always be ready to do is hate someone or something to justify your existence.

Posted at 12:54 PM

AH THAT DID IT [Jonah Goldberg]
Not much hate mail in response to my McCarythism piece. Then Instapundit put up a link and now the civil libertoids of the blogoshphere are annoyed.

Posted at 12:39 PM

RE: MALAYSIAN LEADERSHIP [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
A little less than a year ago, Kevin Cherry noted on NRO a Malaysian qualification to what terrorism is: condemnation not needed when the victims are Israelis.

Posted at 12:21 PM

WHAT'S THE POINT... [Jonah Goldberg]

of a fan site if it's never updated?


Posted at 11:31 AM

DEBATE/BLEGGING [Jonah Goldberg]

I'll be debating Lori Wallach, Director of Public Citizen's Global Trade Watch, on the question "Does Global Free Trade Help Poor Nations?" at Wheaton College (the one in Mass) on March 11. Just an FYI.

And, if you've seen something really, really definitive that I might have missed, please send it to VoteGfile@aol.com.


Posted at 11:12 AM

"TABULA ROSA" [Jonathan H. Adler]
Senator Schumer may not know his Latin, but Star-Ledger columnist Paul Mulshine knows Estrada is no "blank slate" -- and is the subject of disingenuous smears.

Posted at 11:11 AM

BAD STATS [Dave Kopel]
The Center for Consumer Freedom exposes the ridiculous assumptions behind the highly publicized claim that "excessive" drinkers and underage drinkers account for 50% of alcohol consumption. The phony statistic is the product of a neo-prohibitionist research center run by former Carter/Johnson cabinet official Joe Califano. The center is well-known for producing dubious statistics about alcohol.

Posted at 11:09 AM

BIG DAY FOR CLONING [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
House takes it up today. The real ban (Weldon-Stupak) is expected to pass, but a wide margin would help encourage the Senate (especially a wide margin opposing the bad (i.e. half ban) substitute for it, from Rep. Greenwood).

Posted at 11:07 AM

RE: MR. ROGERS [Rod Dreher]

Jonah, I'm with you on Mr. Rogers. I didn't care for his program as a kid, but as an adult -- and especially as a parent -- I really came to value what he stood for. Children's programming these days is so frenetic, artless and stylistically coarse, and as I've complained before, so much of it is one long commercial for toys and related products. I don't recall that Mr. Rogers ever licensed his name for marketing purposes. By happenstance, I spent a half hour last night watching a great videocassette sent to me by WAFB Channel 9 in Baton Rouge (thanks, y'all), a special commemorating Buckskin Bill, the local kiddie show host, who was on Channel 9 for something like 40 years. Of course it was a wonderful nostalgia trip for me (up with the Monday Morning March!), but it was also instructive to me as the father of a small boy.

It's hard to overestimate how much kids from the Baton Rouge area loved Buckskin Bill, and what a big part of our lives he was. How much we trusted him. Yet as is obvious from the old tapes, his program was extremely low-tech, and very gentle. There is no place for a Buckskin Bill in a Spongebob Squarepants world. Yeah, yeah, it's pathetic to listen to older people sit around whining about how they don't make 'em like they used to anymore, but I really do believe it's a huge loss for children that contemporary TV has formatted their brains to require jolts of manic entertainment, such that a Mr. Rogers or a Buckskin Bill comes off not as comforting but dull.


Posted at 10:54 AM

"RESPECTED" THIRD-WORLD JEW-HATER [Rod Dreher]

Malaysian leader Mahathir bin Muhamad has now taken over leadership of the so-called Non-Aligned Movement of nations, and used the occasion to launch a revolting attack on the West in general and Jews in particular. This news inspired David G. Littman, an NGO representative to the United Nations Commission on Human Rights, to observe the following in an e-mail to the Corner:

"The outrageous remarks by the new chairman of the 116-member Non-Aligned  Movement: 'Mahathir -- one of Asia's most respected and outspoken statesman,'  according to an AP report  -- were in his usual fiery rhetoric style. Aside from 'collateral' damages comparisons - with 'the 3,000 who died in New York and the 200 in Bali,' his statement that 'there was no systematic campaign of terror outside Europe until the Europeans and the Jews created a Jewish state out of Palestinian land.' Four examples from the 1980s and 1990s should suffice to show the disgracefully racist flavor of his 'thinking' on 'Jews'!:
 
"1) At the 8th Conference Meeting in 1986 of the then 101-Member Movement of the same 'Non-Aligned' countries, held in Harare, Zimbabwe, he was quoted as saying : 'The expulsion of Jews from the Holy Land some two thousand years ago and the Nazi oppression of Jews have taught them nothing. If at all, it has transformed the Jews into the very monsters that they condemn so roundly in their propaganda material. They have been apt pupils of Dr. Goebbels.' (Int. Herald Tribune, Oct. 8, 1986). This public comment about 'Jews' by  Asia's 'respected and outspoken statesman' was made on Sept. 7, 1986, the day after Abu Nidal's PLO-dissident terrorist squad massacred 23 Jews at worship in the Neve Shalom ('Gates of Peace') synagogue in Istanbul.
 
"2) Three months later, he inaugurated Malaysia's 'Anti-Jewish Day' (New York Times Dec. 7, 1986, p. 6), and on a State Visit to Great Britain in July 1987 (received by the queen), he again repeated the 'Goebbels' calumny publicly, without overt criticism. 
 
"3)  In 1994, 'Schindler's List' was banned in Malaysia on the grounds that it was 'Jewish propaganda.' (IHT, March 24, 1994)
 
"4)  Then came the three months of accusations against American financier George Soros of 'helping trigger the region's currency losses' (the ringgit had lost 30% - 'Malaysian Leader Sees Hidden Jewish 'Agenda','  by Thomas Fuller, IHT, Oct. 11-12, 1996). He also declared: 'We are Muslims, and the Jews are not happy to see Muslims progress.'
 
"I need hardly add that at no time has this 'respected and outspoken statesman' from Asia been criticized at the UN Commission on Human Rights for his ongoing, blatantly racist and hateful remarks that are in contradiction with the International Bill of Human Rights.

"Earlier this week, again, he insisted that religious extremists were only reacting to 'blatant double standards' (Iraq and Palestine!). The real 'double standards' are that no Western democratically elected leader could get away with mouthing such crude garbage."


Posted at 10:29 AM

WE SHOULD JUST MAKE THIS NRO SHOPPING DAY [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Another reader: "Ok, I subscribe to NRODT, and have coffee mugs aplenty (my company makes them) but I don't have an NRO sweatshirt, so I caved and just now ordered one that says 'Voice of the vast right-wing conspiracy.' Gosh, I love that...NRO is one of my favorite websites, btw."

Posted at 10:07 AM

MR. ROGERS [Jonah Goldberg]

John - I must confess I was never a huge fan of Mr. Rogers. When I was a kid I watched him for a little while, but I quickly grew tired of him because he was so "soothing." I wanted more smashing and lasers -- that's just the kind of kid I was. But I have to say I grew to respect the man much more than I liked the show. Just this morning I was listening to him on NPR in an old interview. He had some profoundly conservative ideas about how children are and should be raised. First, he explicitly confirmed that children ape what they see grown-ups do -- one of the chief arguments for censorship. Second, he gave a great explanation of why kids need rules. I'm paraphrasing, but he said that if a kid runs away from you down the street and you don't yell "Stop! Come back!" that kid will reasonably assume that you don't care if he runs off. Children respond to limits on their behavior -- and test those limits -- because it is one of the most concrete ways we have to teach them that we love them.

Thankfully, this sort of thinking may be increasingly popular today, but I grew up among a lot of kids with parents who believed setting rules and limits for kids was a terrible idea. Being told that all of your ideas are brilliant and all your impulses should be acted upon teaches almost precisely the opposite lessons parents intend. Unconditional love is good, but unconditional respect and self-esteem-boosting creates not only dumb people but annoying ones. And, yes, this is a sweeping generalization with all sorts of exceptions.


Posted at 10:05 AM

POPPA GOLDBERG/HOLLYWOOD TEN [Jonah Goldberg]

My father is a font of anti-Communist arcana (what did you think I picked this stuff up from college or my New York City high school?). Here's an email he sent me about the Hollywood Ten, too late for inclusion in the column:


I believe the Hollywood Ten were legally at risk because they violated the Smith Act, which was passed in 1940 and made it a crime to advocate the violent overthrow of the government. The Smith Act was the bete noire of the Communist Party and they fought it tooth and nail. It became in Communist folklore the American Nuremberg Laws - BUT first to uphold the implementation of the Smith Act was none other than the Communist Party, USA, which gleefully turned over the names of Trotskyites to the FBI. I didn't trust my memory on this so I googled it (Smith Act - first entry gives a history - although tendentious in its opposition to it - of the act). Here's the pertinent paragraph:

"An ironic aspect of the convictions, which was not lost among civil libertarians and others, was that the Communist Party had fully supported the use in 1941 of the Smith Act against the leaders of the Socialist Workers Party. Motivated by its hatred of Trotskyist political opponents and its fervent support for the Soviet-American alliance of World War II, the Party had judged the Smith Act perfectly constitutional and the subsequent trials a legitimate government action. Those positions gravely undercut the credibility of the Party's efforts in the 1950s to characterize the Smith Act as unconstitutional and to mobilize a defense on the basis of political free speech and freedom of association."

The convictions referred to were of the leadership of the Communist party - Henry Winston, Eugene Dennis, John Gates, Gus Hall, Ben Davis, five others (all listed in the google story) - in, I believe 1949.) The Ten were convicted of contempt of Congress (HUAC hear ings), and several of them jumped bail and went underground but later were apprehended and imprisoned. Original sentences were for five years. The Commies had to wiggle out of their embarrassment of endorsing the Smith Act to punish the Trotskyites, back in 1940.. The bottom line in all this is that the Communists had no governing morality - they would use a law they detested in order to punish their enemies, just as they will use the word "peace" to disarm their enemies.


Posted at 09:46 AM

FOLLOW THIS LEAD [Jonah Goldberg]
Jonah, you display the wisdom of Solomon! I already have a mug and a NRODT subscription. So, I'd like to offer you free use of my private jet for whenever you and your family need it and the keys to my villa in Tuscony. You deserve it!

Okay, I made that up. But that doesn't mean you shouldn't follow that lead. The rabbit race dogs chase isn't real either.


Posted at 09:36 AM

FOLLOW THIS LEAD [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
A reader emails: "McCarthyism G-File excellent! I already get NRODT so I ordered a mug."

Posted at 08:50 AM

NOT A BEAUTIFUL DAY IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD [John J. Miller]
Mr. Rogers has died. He was a cherished figure when I was a tot, and I wish my own kids had something like him. Children's television today is so frenetic, and Mr. Rogers was so soothing.

Posted at 05:53 AM

ATTACK IMMINENT [Kahryn Jean Lopez]
An Arabic website, possibly al Qaeda warns. MEMRI translates.

Posted at 05:10 AM

Wednesday, February 26, 2003

HUBBARD [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
President's economic adviser leaves Friday.

Posted at 09:56 PM

THIS MAKES IT WORTHWHILE [Jonah Goldberg]

I love this email:

Jonah

I will be 73 in April. I have waited for 50 years to read what you said in the above mentioned column. 'nuff said.


Posted at 09:55 PM

CBS [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Has the transcript, provided by Iraq, online.

Posted at 09:54 PM

GOING THROUGH MY MIND DURING THE AEI SPEECH [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
"Look at Michael Ledeen and talk about Iran."

Posted at 09:34 PM

THIS SADDAM INTERVIEW [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Returns me to the thought I couldn't get out of my head during the AEI speech: we're still talking. We're still listening to Iraq's lies. We waiting on the U.N. "Faster, please." I hope we have better spin on it by tomorrow morning on NRO, but this Rather thing strikes me as bad--just more momentum loss.

Posted at 09:23 PM

NEAT [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Oval Office tour with the Prez.

Posted at 08:16 PM

WEARING DUCT TAPE [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Mike Farrell, formerly from MASH, is on Crossfire wearing DUCT tape on his lapel. I assume, obviously, it is some kind of antiwar statement. But what exactly is it supposed to say?

Posted at 08:01 PM

CHOICE MADE [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
For rebuilding at the WTC site.

Posted at 07:14 PM

DUDE [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
We just knew CBS would cave and run the Bush speech live, so decided to stay home and watch from our couches.

Posted at 07:11 PM

ALAS.... [Jonah Goldberg]
This will be the first AEI annual dinner I've missed in a decade. Staying home with the new baby and my lovely bride. Still, AEI is still sort of home to me and I'm sorry I couldn't make it.

Posted at 07:05 PM

AEI PREVIEW [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Huge night for the influential American Enterprise Institute, with the president speaking at their annual dinner. A preview from the presidential address:
Rebuilding Iraq will require a sustained commitment from many nations, including our own: We will remain in Iraq as long as necessary, and not a day more. America has made and kept this kind of commitment before--in the peace that followed a world war. After defeating enemies, we did not leave behind occupying armies, we left constitutions and parliaments. We established an atmosphere of safety, in which responsible, reform-minded local leaders could build lasting institutions of freedom. In societies that once bred fascism and militarism, liberty found a permanent home.

Posted at 05:42 PM

2004 AS 1972 [Dave Kopel]
National Journal columnist Chuck Todd suggests that the current Democratic Presidential slate resembles the field from 1972. John Kerry is the "seasoned front-runner" (like Maine Senator Ed Muskie); Gephardt is the labor favorite (like Hubert Humphrey); Dean the darling of the anti-war Left (like McGovern); Lieberman is the lone hawk (like Washington Senator Henry Jackson); Mosley-Braun is the purely symbolic female black candidate (like Shirley Chisholm). But the best parallel is Al Charlatan and George Wallace. Todd delicately writes that "No one thought Wallace could win the Democratic nomination, but everyone in the field believed he would be a key factor in certain primary states." I would put the comparison a little more directly: Like Wallace, Sharpton is an excellent orator and race-baiting demagogue who--despite claiming to fight for the little guy--appeals to the most paranoid and racist instincts of poorly-educated Democratic primary voters, especially in the South and Northeast.

The National Journal forgot to come up with a modern parallel for Sam Yorty--the Democratic Mayor of Los Angeles, whose Presidential campaign attracted no visible support (except for an endorsement from the Manchester Union-Leader). I predict that Dennis Kucinich has everything it takes to be the Sam Yorty of 2004.

Posted at 05:27 PM

PC MATH [John Derbyshire]
You really can't make this stuff up. We now have "Critical Math," with that word "critical" understood as in "critical legal theory"--i.e. it means "raving lefty." Just been reviewing some stuff put out by a certain Marilyn Frankenstien [I am not making this up, I swear] at the "Critical Math Educator's Group." Sample:

In "Scenes from the Inferno", Alexander Cockburn (1989) wrote about the reality behind the so-called triumph of capitalism. One of his illustrations is particularly relevant for a critical mathematics education: in Chile, where in some Santiago neighborhoods, "the diet of 77 to 80 percent of the people does not have sufficient calories and proteins… to sustain life", Pinochet’s regime measured malnutrition in relation to a person’s weight and height, in contrast to the usual comparison of weight and age. "So a stunted child is not counted as malnourished, and thus is not eligible for food supplements". (p. 510) This talk will explore the connections between understanding the outrageousness of collecting such statistics, and acting to change the outrageousness of such situations...

Note how desperately the Lefties still cling, 30 years later, to the fantasy of an emerging "progressive" Chile nipped in the bud by the mega-evil Pinochet and his CIA/capitalist enablers. To you and me the great political monsters of the 20c were Lenin, Stalin, Hitler, Pol Pot, Idi Amin, Kim Il Sung, Castro & so on. To Lefties they were Pinochet, Pinochet, Pinochet, Pinochet and Pinochet. Actually my impression of Pinochet's Chile is that it did rather well economically, & was no more politically repressive than the average S. American nation--which is to say, around 0.01 per cent as repressive as Cuba.

Posted at 03:56 PM

I DO NOT EDIT THE NATION [Jonah Goldberg]

Kathryn - egads! Obviously they've labeled my opponent's comments as my own. Heads will roll. The only good thing is that it must bother her more than it bothers me.


Posted at 03:51 PM

MORE MCCARTHYISM [Jonah Goldberg]
One point that I accidentally left on the cutting room floor of today's Goldberg File, is that the substantive problem with McCarthy wasn't that he was a lout, but that he undermined the cause of anti-Communism through his loutishness. I think there is substance to this argument and, as I just said, I meant to include it. But at the same time, I think many anti-McCarthy folks overplay this point. Some of them strike me as Johnny-come-latelies to anti-Communism, trying to justify their enduring anti-anti-Communism with a new spin. And some of them, though sincere, miss the point that the Left would have invented Joe McCarthy if he didn't exist. They certainly invented all sorts of arguments against non-McCarthyite anti-Communists all the time. The notion that anti-Communism would have won the hearts and minds of the liberal anti-anti-Communists if only McCarthy stayed quiet is as laughable as saying that liberals would have supported Clinton's impeachment if only someone other than Ken Starr had served as Indpendent Counsel.

Posted at 03:36 PM

UP WITH BP. NAZIR-ALI [Rod Dreher]
Bishop Michael Nazir-Ali, the Anglican ordinary of Rochester (England), has also come out in favor of war with Iraq. Bp. Nazir-Ali was born in Pakistan. His father was a convert from Islam. There was talk last year that he, not Rowan Williams, would be named Archbishop of Canterbury. I bet Tony Blair wishes he could do that appointment over again.

Posted at 03:25 PM

HOLEY-INKED CONS [Jonah Goldberg]

From a reader:

Jonah,

In stating that dogs can be sexist and racist, you seemed to thoughtlessly link pierced males with anti-war protestors. I know of at least on pierced, tatted ex-skater who subscribes to NRODT and barks even louder than Cosmo at war protestors. I didn't follow the whole crunchy-con debate too closely but was able to pick out that you dislike clouding politics with such abstract relations to personal preferences. Just because you don't plop a name on the abstraction doesn't mean you aren't employing the same style.

Keep up the great writing, as a holey-inked-con I've endured enough stereotypes I can't fault you for having this one.


Posted at 03:13 PM

JONAH'S BEEN SMEARED! [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
A mislabeled transcript has him saying the media is strikingly conservative.

Posted at 03:12 PM

ALL VAPOURING FRANCE [John Derbyshire]
You can hear Lucie Skeaping sing the first 2 verses of THE ROAST BEEF OF OLD ENGLAND on the internet.

Posted at 03:10 PM

LES GRENOUILLES ENCORE [Rick Brookhiser]
There is a hilarious comparison of Florida and the French Caribbean island of St. Bart's in Simon Doonan's column in today's New York Observer. I cannot quote it, because the climactic line would scare the horses.

Posted at 02:53 PM

HOW AMERICA TREATS HER FRIENDS [John Derbyshire]
A nasty little piece from ABC news about the Uighurs of Eastern Turkestan, under Chinese military occupation since the 1940s . Will this be the next Al Qaeda haven? wonders the author of the piece. You have to read all the way to the end to learn that the Uighurs are pro-American and utterly un-interested in radical Islam. They are a Turkic people, and, like the Anatolian Turks, seem to be able to practice Islam without getting fanatical about it. The way China treats them, though--with full U.S. encouragement--this might very well change.

Posted at 02:50 PM

PRIME OBSESSION [John Derbyshire]
My book PRIME OBSESSION is now scheduled to appear in stores April 16, the publisher tells me. We are busily trying to organize events. Lined up so far: ***May 5 at 7:30pm, Tattered Cover Bookstore, 2955 E. First Avenue, Denver, CO. ***May 6 at 7:30 p.m., Boulder Bookstore, 1107 Pearl Street, Boulder, CO. ***May 7 at 7:30 p.m., Cody's Books, 2454 Telegraph Avenue, Berkeley, CA. A major book chain it would be imprudent of me to name has given us a surprisingly big order. Final manuscript goes to printer on Friday. I am more excited than at any time since my kids were born. (An event which book-launching resembles in a lot of ways... though prob. less painful.)

Posted at 02:49 PM

ALAS [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
I was just going to praise CNN for not going live to the Robert Blake preliminary hearing, but they just did. (Fox has on for a long while now.)

Posted at 02:46 PM

G-FILE IS UP [Jonah Goldberg]

Re-reading it now that I've taken a breath.


Posted at 02:34 PM

ROE, FYI [Jonah Goldberg ]

My relatively tame syndicated column on Roe V. Wade etc. Interestingly, I've gotten nasty email from pro-lifers and pro-choicers.


Posted at 02:15 PM

YOU'RE RIGHT, JONAH [Rod Dreher]
You're right, Jonah, that is disgusting. But don't let the extremist berserkers define the issue for you. The other day, I got a foaming-at-the-mouth e-mail from a Confederoid idiot angry at the things I've written about Gods & Generals. The hopped-up knuckle-dragger said that slavery wasn't so bad, and that I'm a shameful example of a yellow-bellied Southerner trying to curry favor with my Yankee employers by saying slavery was evil. Now, in my experience, very, very few Southerners hold this obnoxious and immoral opinion, but I also heard from a number of non-Southerners who are under the impression that the Confederoid's view is normative for Southerners. Therefore, they aren't open to any suggestion that the Old South was anything less than a forerunner of South Africa, or even Nazi Germany. One California reader wrote to say that because the South enslaved blacks, there was and is nothing of cultural worth there (alas, William Faulkner was no Jackie Collins). I think these jerks need each other to justify their own closed-mindedness and ideological preening.

Posted at 02:11 PM

DOG RACISM [Jonah Goldberg]

There's a good piece in Slate about whether or not dogs can be racist. I suspect most dog owners already know the answer. Dogs owned by whites oftern have problems with blacks and vice versa. This has to do with the way dogs learn about "others." There's nothing sinister about it.

Dogs can also be sexist. Cosmo, for example, likes the ladies but has got serious problems with men, especially young men. He'll growl at young black guys and at young white guys while he'll work the magic with women of any race. We've also noticed -- and I'm not making this up -- Cosmo particularly dislikes skeeves, skate rats, and other males with aggressive hair and pierced faces. He just doesn't like them and, truth be told, I'm quite proud of him for it. Whenever my lovely bride and I see anti-war protestors and the like, we'll say "Oh, man Cosmo wouldn't like those guys." (As long-time readers know this is hardly shocking since the Wonderdog is rumored to be a Scoop Jackson Democrat and Straussian). Meanwhile, I have another take on dogs and racism, which was published in Slate -- eek -- four years ago.


Posted at 02:03 PM

THIS IS OUTRAGEOUS [Jonah Goldberg]

I'm increasingly sympathetic to the argument that factory farming needs reforming, but this is the sort of intellectual and moral filth which will turn me off completely. Be warned, the images are grim -- as they compare factory farming to the Holocaust.


Posted at 01:39 PM

HELLO???? [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Why did Ellen Ratner just ask a question at the White House press briefing? I fully expect Paul Begala to be next up.

Posted at 01:38 PM

BTW [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Ari Fleischer shut her up with: "Ladies and gentleman, we now suspend the Q&A portion of this press briefing for an adovacacy minute." (Note: that might be a paraphrase, i wasn't writing it down as he talked.)
Why again does she have a press pass?

Posted at 01:34 PM

"THEY DIDN'T ASK TO BE LIBERATED" [KAthryn Jean Lopez]
Helen Thomas about the Iraqis, to Ari Fleischer just now. DUH!

Posted at 01:32 PM

THE GOOD BISHOP [Rod Dreher]
Turns out that Archbishop Mario Conti, the Roman Catholic primate of Scotland, backs Prime Minister Blair and the war effort on Iraq. Good on him.

Posted at 01:19 PM

PLAYING FOR THE OTHER TEAM [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
...CBS us just showing it's loyalties. Iraqi government says "No, Mr. Rather, you can not use your own crew. No, Mr. Rather, you can not air on Tuesday morning." ETC. White House ASKS, "How about a White House response now that you handed your network over to a tyrant?" Makes perfect sense...you know, the conservative, pro-war CBS, arm of Don Rumsfeld.

Posted at 12:46 PM

COST OF WAR [John Derbyshire]
"COST OF WAR -- $320 PER CITIZEN" shrieks the Washington Post. OK, where do I send my check?

Posted at 12:40 PM

"I THINK THE NEWS MEDIA IS STRIKINGLY CONSERVATIVE" [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Katrina van den Heuvel from The Nation on with Jonah just now on CNN. She's been practicing: She said it with a totally straight face. Not even Eric Alterman does that all the time.

Posted at 12:39 PM

SMOKED OUT [Andrew Stuttaford]
Here's yet another reason to dislike the UN, an organization that is, it seems, soft on Saddam and tough on pot.

Posted at 12:37 PM

CBS' COJONES [Rod Dreher]
According to our spy in the White House press corps, Ari Fleischer just said that CBS--in the person of the executive producer of 60 Minutes II--turned down a White House request to have a senior official on tonight to rebut Saddam. The White House was told that "unless it was the President of the United States, the answer was no."

Posted at 12:17 PM

BIBI'S OUT [Kathryn Jean Lopez]

Posted at 11:35 AM

I'M.... [Jonah Goldberg]

off to CNN (12:30ish EST). G-File -- a real stemwinder -- is in K-Lo's overburdened hands.


Posted at 11:27 AM

MAU-MAUING THE TERRORIST CATCHERS [Rod Dreher]
Steven Emerson on how Sami al-Arian and friends used racial politics as cover for their alleged terrorist activities.

Posted at 10:45 AM

RICO RESTRAINED [Jonathan H. Adler]
This morning the Supreme Court decided that RICO cannot be applied to anti-abortion protesters. The ruling was 8-1. Chief Justice Rehnquist wrote the majority; Justice Stevens dissented.

Posted at 10:33 AM

WHOSE JUDICIAL VACANCIES [Jonathan H. Adler]
TAPped justifies Democratic obstruction of judicial confirmations on the grounds that "the vast majority of current vacancies 'belong' to the Democrats, since by all rights Bill Clinton should have been able to fill them with his own nominees, but was repeatedly stymied by the admittedly well-disciplined Senate Republicans." It's a cute arugment, but if one were to take it seriously, then many of these vacancies actually "belong" to Republicans because Democratic obstructionism delayed or denied confirmation of Bush nominees, including two that were renominated by W -- John Roberts and Terrence Boyle. Indeed, TAPped's argument is precisely that used by Senator Jesse Helms when he decided to blue slip all of Clinton's Fourth Circuit nominees from North Carolina because the Democratic Senate failed to act on Boyle's nomination during President Bush's term.

Posted at 10:30 AM

COPING WITH SOLOMON [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Students and faculty at a prominent law school are upset about the presence of JAG recruiters on campus. A friend (who is far from the knee-jerk-outrage type) there writes:
I had my first in-my-face liberal law school experience yesterday. I've experienced the liberal professors in class, the liberal students etc., but I was fit to be tied when I saw signs posted around school yesterday explaining to the students why JAG recruiters would be allowed on campus. The signs were meant to redirect the obvious indignation and shock we would feel from seeing a uniform-clad member of the armed forces in the very building where we are busily expanding our minds away from the school administration and towards...whom? The sign actually says that "recently enacted federal legislation known as the Solomon Amendments" were to blame….I guess everyone was too flustered with the emotional turmoil they felt seeing these warriors invade campus to take a moment and celebrate progress--the Army JAG recruiter dressed in Class A's whom I was chatting with on the way to class yesterday was pushing a baby carriage!

Posted at 09:05 AM

NICE GIRL GOES BROKE [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Zora, from Joe Millionaire, just told Fox and Friends she is broke (the Millionaire check has not been delivered yet) and considering pawning her jewels. Ah, reality. (By the way, I hear David Frum will be on the FOX morning show tomorrow.)

Posted at 08:53 AM

GREAT DANE [Andrew Stuttaford]

Important news from the Associated Press. After the Vilnius 10 comes the Fanoe one:
"A Danish pizzeria has banned French and Germans from dining there because of their country's stance on a war with Iraq.

Aage Bjerre, who owns Aage's Pizza on the island of Fanoe, said he's tired of French and German attitudes toward the United States.

He's put two homemade drawings on the shop door, one a silhouette of a man coloured red, yellow and black for Germany and another in the red, white and blue for France.

Both silhouettes have a bar across them.
He says Germans will be allowed in if their country joins a war on Iraq, but the French will have to endure a lifetime ban.

Aage said: "Hadn't the United States helped Europe in defeating Germany, there would have been photos of Adolf Hitler hanging on the walls around here."

The ban has yet to effect his business because the tourist season only starts after Easter and peaks during the summer. "I do what my conscience tells me to do," he said.

He added: "Frenchmen have a lifetime ban here. Their attitude toward the United States will never change.""


Posted at 08:50 AM

WTC ANNIVERSARY [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Ten years ago today was the first attack on the World Trade Center.

Posted at 08:24 AM

RE: SCHOOL LUNCHES [John Derbyshire]
Kathryn: When the kids were younger, Rosie did a stint as lunch volunteer at the local elementary school. She still talks about it: "The WASTE! You can't IMAGINE!! Whole trays of food thrown out--the kids barely touch it! Cartons of milk, unopened, thrown out. We threw out more than they ate..." It made a powerful impression on Rosie. (Who grew up in China, in a family that generated one small shopping-bag's worth of garbage per month.)

Posted at 08:21 AM

I WANT MY BLAIR TV [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Tony Blair's going to field questions from young folks on MTV on March 7. I can't think of anyone better for that gig.

Posted at 08:09 AM

SNOW!? [Jonah Goldberg]

I have never been bummed about snow. I join my canine friends in believing that all snow is a joyous occassion. But this is getting ridiculous.


Posted at 07:04 AM

STUD ALERT [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Australia's John Howard in the Journal.

Posted at 06:39 AM

THERE THEY GO AGAIN [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
"Stealing" school lunches from kids' hands.

Posted at 05:41 AM

DAN RATHER, BUTCHER ADVISER [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
Saddam Hussein interviews Rather.

Posted at