Open-borders radicalism means never having to apologize for absurd self-contradiction.
The way illegal-alien students on college campuses across the country tell it, America is a cruel, selfish, and racist nation that has never given them or their families a break. Yet despite their bottomless grievances, they’re not going anywhere.
And despite their gripes about being forced “into the shadows,” they’ve been out in the open protesting at media-driven hunger strikes and flooding the airwaves demanding passage of the so-called DREAM Act. This bailout plan would benefit an estimated 2.1 million illegal aliens at an estimated cost of up to $20 billion.
While votes on various DREAM Act proposals are imminent, the Congressional Budget Office has yet to release any official cost scoring. Viva transparency!
To sow more confusion and obfuscate the debate, Democrats in the Senate have foisted four different versions of the bill on the legislative calendar, which all offer variations on the same amnesty theme: Because they arrived here through “no fault of their own,” illegal-alien children deserve federal education access and benefits, plus a conditional pass from deportation and a special path toward green cards and U.S. citizenship for themselves and unlimited relatives.
In a last-ditch attempt to win over fence-sitters, DREAM Act sponsors have tinkered with eligibility requirements. But supporters know that the words on bills’ pages — which hardly anyone will read before voting — don’t matter. Built into the proposals are broad “public interest” waiver powers for the illegal immigration–friendly secretary of the Department of Homeland Security, Janet Napolitano.
University of Texas–San Antonio student Lucy Martinez embodies the entitlement mentality of the DREAM Act agitators: “We have done lobbying, legislative visits, marches, sit-ins. We are tired of it,” she complained to the San Antonio Express News. The illegal-alien-student hunger strike “is similar to what we go through in our everyday lives — starving without a future.” But neither she nor her peers have been denied their elementary, secondary, or college educations. Neither she nor her peers face arrest for defiantly announcing their illegal status. And for all the hysterical rhetoric about “starving,” the federal government and the federal immigration courts have been overly generous in providing wave after wave of de facto and de jure amnesties allowing tens of millions of illegal border crossers, visa overstayers, and deportation evaders from around the world to live, work, and prosper here in subversion of our laws.
Among the major acts of Congress providing mass pardons and citizenship benefits:
This is in addition to hundreds of “private relief bills” sponsored in Congress every year.
Most recently, Sen. Dianne Feinstein introduced legislation to stay the deportation of illegal-alien DREAM Act activist Steve Li — whose family’s asylum claim was rejected and whom a federal immigration-court judge ordered deported in 2004.
These illegal-alien passes needn’t be approved by Congress for the recipients to gain benefits. Mere introduction of the bills buys the deportable aliens time that ordinary, law-abiding citizens can’t buy in our court system. The DREAM Act schemers pretend this isn’t a zero-sum game. But every time a private illegal-alien-relief bill passes, the number of available visas for that year is reduced by the number of illegal-alien/deportable-immigrant recipients granted legal status/deportation relief through the special legislation.
In Austin, Texas, this week, one illegal-alien DREAM Act activist blithely argued to me that “it’s not like the government would be sending a message that breaking the law is okay.” Reality check: The number of illegal aliens in the U.S. has tripled since President Reagan signed the first amnesty in 1986. The total effect of the amnesties was even larger, because relatives later joined amnesty recipients, and this number was multiplied by an unknown number of children born to amnesty recipients, all of whom acquired automatic U.S. citizenship.
At a time of nearly double-digit unemployment and drastic higher-education cutbacks, a $20 billion special education preference package for up to 2.1 million illegal aliens is not and should not be a priority in Washington. It certainly isn’t in the rest of America. And it certainly shouldn’t be a priority for federal immigration and homeland-security officials, who have enough problems: 400,000 deportation fugitives, a three-year naturalization-application backlog, and borders that remain in chaos.
Grownups need to tell the DREAM Act agitators to get in the back of the line.
— Michelle Malkin is the author of Culture of Corruption: Obama and His Team of Tax Cheats, Crooks & Cronies (Regnery, 2010). © 2010 Creators Syndicate, Inc.