Politics & Policy

Stimulus Jr. Won’t Work, Either

Barack Obama needs Paul Ryan’s vision on jobs and taxes.

President Obama’s $787 billion Stimulus left America sputtering, like a Chevy Volt without its extension cord. Having learned nothing from this failure, Obama recently unveiled Stimulus Jr. — the American Jobs Act. Costing $447 billion, Stimulus Jr. boasts roughly half of its predecessor’s audacity.

Speaking Thursday night at a Democratic National Committee event at a private residence in Washington, D.C., Obama told supporters that Stimulus Jr. would “add as many as 1.9 million jobs.” That equals at least $235,263 each — quadruple the $57,491 cost of an average private-sector position. Even worse, major tax hikes fuel Stimulus Jr. Too bad Obama ignores House Budget Committee chairman Paul Ryan’s loophole-closing, tax-rate-slashing vision.

“Obama spent $800 billion of our money in Stimulus One, and the economy sickened,” says Grover Norquist of Americans for Tax Reform. “Now he is back with another $400 billion in stimulus. Leeches! He gives us more leeches!”

ATR’s Ryan Ellis describes Stimulus Jr. as “a series of permanent tax increases funding temporary tax relief and new spending programs. The overall act is a net tax increase.”

Obama proposes a brand-new tax, literally on thin air. Americans who use cellphones, iPads, and other wireless instruments should brace for Stimulus Jr.’s Section 278: a $4.8 billion spectrum tax.

Stimulus Jr. also would hike 13 existing taxes, including:

• An itemized-deduction ceiling would treat the charitable, mortgage, and state-tax write-offs of Americans in the 39 and 35 percent brackets as if they only paid 28 percent. Non-profits should worry that this will curb the enthusiasm for their causes among affluent taxpayers. And, as the philanthropic sector watches its support wane, where will the needy run? Into the shriveled arms of the debt-addicted state!

• Investment partners’ capital gains would be taxed at 39.6 percent starting in 2013, up from 15 percent today. This will give financial risk-takers one more reason to idle their money, or export it to nations that welcome it.

• Obama’s War on Corporate Jets would invade the entire world of aircraft purchases by business. All such planes would have to be depreciated across twelve years, not seven. This will reduce aircraft demand and kill jobs among aviation-assembly workers, much as Daddy Bush’s 1990 luxury tax on yachts sank the pleasure-craft market and torpedoed some 25,000 boat-making jobs.

• Beyond smacking aircraft, Stimulus Jr. would slam the energy industry by reducing or ending its access to depreciation, deduction, and double-taxation benefits that remain open to every other industry. Obama might as well siphon unleaded from drivers’ gas tanks.

These 14 proposed tax hikes would augment the 21 new or increased taxes that Obama already has signed, which carry a $568.5 billion, 10-year price tag. According to ATR, these include a ten-year, $65.5 billion cigarette tax hike, plus 20 other taxes within Obamacare, costing yet another $503 billion over ten years. Among these enacted confiscations: A $2.7 billion indoor-tanning tax, a $20 billion medical-device tax, a $22.2 billion pharmaceutical tax, a combined $65 billion individual- and employer-mandate tax, and a $123 billion investment-income surtax.

Rep. Paul Ryan (R., Wisc.) couldn’t disagree more. As he explained Wednesday in a dazzling video, “The last thing we need to be doing is to complicate job creation in America with this complicated tax code.” He notes that individuals and companies devote six billion hours and $160 billion annually just to complete their tax paperwork. And taxes are a moving target: Ryan says that the U.S. Tax Code has endured some 4,500 changes in just the last ten years.

Many of these amendments are loopholes that companies purchase through lobbying. “Every dollar that a business spends lobbying for a better tax deal is a dollar it’s not spending to make a better product,” Ryan observes.

Instead, Ryan would trim or toss loopholes by the truckload. This would allow the top individual and corporate tax rates to fall from 39 and 35 percent, respectively, to 25 percent each. The U.S. corporate tax thus would plunge from the industrial world’s second highest (after Japan) to a far more competitive 17th-highest, tied with Austria, Denmark, and Holland.

If President Obama could resist his class-warfare instincts long enough to heed Congressman Ryan, he finally could liberate job creators to create jobs.

— New York commentator Deroy Murdock is a nationally syndicated columnist with the Scripps Howard News Service and a media fellow with the Hoover Institution on War, Revolution and Peace at Stanford University.

Deroy Murdock is a Manhattan-based Fox News contributor and a contributing editor of National Review Online, and a senior fellow with the London Center for Policy Research.


The Latest