โDo you have any ancestors who died in the War?โ a sophisticate asks a naรf in Whit Stillmanโs The Cosmopolitans. Because that nosey question follows the socialiteโs class-based dismissal about โthe Civil War and you all losing so badly,โ itโs quite a zinger. Vagaries of American social history always preoccupy Stillmanโs characters. Background and tradition are subtly meaningful for them, which makes Stillmanโs tales more surprisingly amusing than most other films.
Stillmanโs characters โ described as โdoomed, bourgeois, in loveโ by the waggish filmmaker himself โ appear refreshed in The Cosmopolitans, a short-film pilot for an anticipated Amazon.com web series. But moviegoers should already know them from Stillmanโs four previous features โ Metropolitan, Barcelona, Last Days of Disco, and Damsels in Distress โ and, of course, from life.
How un-American that few American movies portray Stillman types โ unapologetically white middle-class conservative strivers. That โunapologeticallyโ is due to Stillmanโs operating outside the usual filmmaking pretenses โ Hollywoodโs peculiar racial politics, which sentimentalize most other struggling ethnicities but never White Anglo Saxon Protestants. He belongs to the rare tradition of wags including Philip Barry and Preston Sturges, but with a tone and dialogue style all his own.
In The Cosmospolitans, four young American expatriates reside in Paris โ a cultural escape that brings them face-to-face with themselves. Comic, heartfelt entanglements with Continentals (as lusty and avaricious as Americans) show what โdoomed, bourgeois, in loveโ really means.
Each cosmopolitan is amusingly self-complicated: Best friends Jimmy (Adrian Brody) and Hal (Jordan Rountree) dub themselves โParisians,โ which describes their yearning to burrow โdeeply within the French beast and infiltrate French society at its most resistantโ โ that is, hooking up with indigenous femmes. Their coterie includes Italian rouรฉ Sandro (Adriano Giannini), local opportunist Fritz (Freddy Asblom), and single girl Aubrey (Carrie MacLemore), newly arrived from Alabama (sheโs the one descended from Civil War veterans). All privileged, all pale and good-looking, they all also have a quaint sense of doom โ a romantic sensitivity and self-pity despite class and race advantages. Stillman recognizes their homegrown petulance. Itโs not racist resistance to changing demographics, as Leftists pretend, but an inbred dread, born of an instinctual, romantic optimism that they fear will never benefit them.
This goes deeper than Philip Barry (Holiday, The Philadelphia Story) โ deeper even than the contemporary TV programs and films that give superficial views of race or class. Damn Sex and the City, Friends, and Woody Allenโs deplorable Midnight in Paris, which all deliberately avoided bourgeois self-awareness and thereby cheated viewers of full social and psychological understanding.
Stillman appropriates Offenbachโs La Vie Parisienne rather than another clichรฉ look at La Vie de Bohรจme. Since he is not a hipster like his American Eccentric contemporaries, his vision of middle-class Americans living poor (that squeezed view of the Seine from Aubreyโs flat) takes up where Wes Anderson left off in his startling short film Hotel Chevalier but then never returned to, retreating instead into the juvenile hijinks of The Grand Budapest Hotel. Stillmanโs Europe is adult enough to observe earnestness and affecting foible within his charactersโ desperation. Hal confesses, โOne aspect of expatriate life never talked about: the loneliness. Itโs something you experience in childhood and never expect to feel again. A feeling of being hollowed-out and a void inside that will ever be filled.โ
Stillmanโs sociological satire sticks out from our increasingly inane, childish commercial cinema (hence the overrated Boyhood and Budapest Hotel). His Amazon.com short might be the best series pilot since formalist master Walter Hillโs Deadwood (which immediately turned to dreck when Hill decamped). Only Stillman could do The Cosmopolitans because heโs the rare American filmmaker with both class-consciousness and self-effacing humor. (That means none of the mean-spirited, social-climbing self-absorption seen in films by hateful Stillman clone Noah Baumbach.)
The polished look of The Cosmopolitans (videographer Antoine Monod shoots Aubreyโs glass of kir as if peering through psychological amber) attests Stillmanโs developed technique. He intercuts Halโs flashback with Aubreyโs wandering along the Seine, combining their backstories and shared emotion. And Gianniniโs older, jaded character (he calls himself โParigiโ) recalls the ancestral UHB (Urban Haute Bourgeois) who frightened the youths in Metropolitan by seeing through their callowness. This rascal, named Sandro, must refer to Gabriele Ferzettiโs spiritually exhausted stud in Antonioniโs LโAvventura, the ne plus ultra of Europeโs doomed, bourgeois, and in love.
Although Stillman had seemed to be falling into dreaded Mumblecore with Damsels in Distress, this short film outstrips Mumblecore in every way. Its cinematic essence can be seen in suspended moments like the entrancing introduction of Clemence (Clementine Beart) and the sneaky presentation of playboy Tom LeTombeur (Thomas Jouannet). These seed scenes are planted to bloom in upcoming episodes or just to exist as fascination. Every character mirrors the others so that flaws and innocence, ambition and folly attain a complicated humane balance.
Their captious dialogue is never merely clever but always telling. My favorite: Aubreyโs remark about fashion editor Vicky (Chloe Sevigny): โYou expect journalists to be ugly because of the anger, but sheโs quite attractive.โ The humanity is in the wordsโ rhythm; speech rhythms release Stillmanโs humor โ as with his fondness for dance, reintroducing โThe Sambolaโ from Damsels in Distress. It relieves his young WASPsโ formal stiffness: Catch Jimmyโs hunched, prayerful stance when desolate on the street after midnight โ he is not praying for a cab (as Jackie Wilsonโs supernal โTo Be Lovedโ lets us know). Stillmanโs musical choices throughout, such as pop-gospel singer Joan Osborneโs English and French versions of Jimmy Ruffinโs โWhat Becomes of the Broken Heartedโ (Jimmyโs a totemic Stillman moniker), lift this brisk delight to Eiffel Tower heights.
***
Using R&B classics in a white folksโ reverie, Stillman achieves an ideal cultural crossover โ a mix that makes you rethink how pop culture represents American class and race differences. Thatโs also the subject of two new films: Thomas Allen Harrisโs documentary Through a Lens Darkly: Black Photographers and the Emergence of a People, and Tim Suttonโs impressionistic blues drama Memphis, which opens Friday in New York and next week in Los Angeles.
Harris, a personal filmmaker like Stillman, lets his own experience influence his form so that brief excursions into the hidden lives of gay people in family portraits are fascinating. Harrisโs political argufying is less so, but by raising the issue of racial representation, he opens up the same fresh perspective on American class and social habits as Stillman.
Sutton works like a painstaking artiste, posing singer Willis Earl Beale wearing an Otis Redding Afro in rambling etudes of the Tennessee town, pondering his church background and musician career. Itโs the old sacred/profane schism kept deliberately obscure. Suttonโs true aim is artsy patronization, like Portugese cineaste Pedro Costaโs detached stereotypes of African immigrants stuck in Lisbon ghettos.
Both these essays on historical and contemporary methods employed to capture black Americans in photographic images are symptomatic of the American filmmaking problem that objectifies race only when blacks are the subject. Harris analyzes his own intimate understanding of how these images affect oneโs sense of self, while Sutton remains an outsider, depicting black American art and religion with beautiful compositions but less insight than early-20th-century music ethnologists. Harris feels exiled by his own art and attempts to do something about it while Sutton, by choice, is expatriated from his own countryโs culture. He uses blues myth to trap his black characters in an art frieze.
These issues stir the heart of The Cosmopolitans โ a story about Americans abroad that avoids rote bromides but keeps a lively, trenchant sense of authentic American character. Stillman reveals aspects of American behavior that Hollywood always misrepresents while cranking out films that condescend to working-class sentimentality even when characters are millionaires.
But Stillmanโs approach (part Jane Austen, part Fitzgerald, part Eric Rohmer and part confessional) restores spiritual yearning to class consciousness. If The Cosmopolitans eventually becomes an Amazon.com series, it will be more than a career lifeline for Stillman, and it should help Americans understand themselves in a truly multicultural sense that most Hollywood and indie filmmakers just donโt get.
โ Armond White, a film critic, writes about movies for National Review Online and received the American Book Awardโs Anti-Censorship prize. He is the author of The Resistance: Ten Years of Pop Culture That Shook the World and the forthcoming What We Donโt Talk about When We Talk about the Movies.






Comments
On โExpats Abroad and at Homeโ