Culture

Note to Left: Four Years Ago, Conservatives Were Just as Depressed

Anti-Trump protesters in Philadelphia, Pa., November 11, 2016. (Reuters photo: Mark Makela)
But we didn’t riot, punch people, block traffic, take a day off school, or go on a fast.

Here’s a news flash for Democrats and other Americans on the left: Four years ago, when Barack Obama was reelected president, conservatives were just as depressed as you are now that Hillary Clinton lost and Donald Trump won.

I describe this as news because this undoubtedly surprises many of you. You probably never gave a moment’s thought to how depressed conservatives were in 2012. (Why would you? Unlike you, we shun hysteria.) But, believe me, we were.

Many of us believed that Barack Obama was doing great damage to America. And now we are convinced that he did more damage than any other two-term president to America domestically, to America’s position the world, and to the world at large. He left office with racial tensions — many of which he exacerbated — greater than at any time since the civil-rights era half a century ago. He left the world’s worst regimes — Iran, China, Russia, North Korea, Islamist terror groups — stronger and more aggressive than they were before he became president. Economic growth never rose above 3 percent, a first for a two-term president. He doubled the national debt, with little or nothing to show for it. Obamacare hurt more people — including physicians — financially than it helped medically. More people than ever are on government aid. And the list is far longer than this.

Moreover, just like most Democrats in 2016, most Republicans in 2012 expected to win.

The depression among conservatives was palpable. To cite only my own example, I turned the television off on election night; it was too painful to watch. Instead I played hearts on the computer and listened to Strauss’s Death and Transfiguration to lighten the mood.

Why then does the level of conservative despair four years ago come as a surprise to Americans on the left?

First, unlike much of the left, most conservatives handle despair like mature adults. Most obviously, we didn’t riot. In fact, in America, rioting — not to mention shutting down highways and airports, taking over college offices, and protesting at people’s homes — is a monopoly of the left.

Nor did we allow our conservative children to take a day off from school to demonstrate.

Nor did conservative teachers preach opposition to Obama in their classrooms.

Nor did we print posters declaring “Not My President.”

Nor did conservative clergy declare fast days.

The second reason is that we know you, but you don’t know us.

You read, listen to, watch, socialize with, and study under leftists. Only if you are stuck with some immediate relatives who aren’t on the left do you encounter a non-leftist (let alone a non-leftist idea). Therefore, there is no way you would know how painful it was for conservatives after the presidential election four years ago. While liberals feel free to express their emotions and opinions to anyone, anywhere, at any time, conservatives, especially those who voted for Donald Trump, live like Marranos.

While liberals feel free to express their emotions and opinions to anyone, anywhere, at any time, conservatives, especially those who voted for Donald Trump, live like Marranos.

The Marranos were Jews in Spain during the Spanish Inquisition in the 1400s who lived like Christians but secretly practiced Judaism. That is how most Trump voters have been forced to live. They live like most people do, but they hide their identity as Trump voters lest they lose their job, their business, their relatives, their friends, or their good name.

A gay professor writing in the Wall Street Journal echoed this analogy recently when he likened being in the closet as a Trump voter to being in the closet as a gay man when he was younger:

I began having gay relationships at 25 but remained closeted. I hated lying to people, but in the 1980s and ’90s I feared that coming out would estrange me from family and damage my career. Similarly, I now find creative ways to avoid answering whether I voted for Donald Trump. This may be hard for some to believe, but watching protesters today call Trump supporters racists and bigots has been nearly as distressing as being told to “die in hell, faggot” 30 years ago.

 . . . I am as afraid about acknowledging that I voted for Mr. Trump today as I was about being gay yesterday. There seems to be as little understanding of my political views as there was about my sexual orientation.

Finally, leftists lack self-awareness. They think they are the apotheosis of tolerance when in fact they are far less tolerant than most conservatives. They think they embody kind-heartedness when in fact the further left you go, the greater the meanness. And they think they suffer uniquely when they lose a national election.

Leftists’ pain is not one whit greater than that of conservatives four year ago. But many of them can’t handle pain nearly as well. If they could, they’d be grown-ups. And no longer on the left.

Recommended

The Latest