Politics & Policy

Tax Reform: Don’t Forget Personal Savings

(Photo: Alexmillos/Dreamstime)
All-purpose savings accounts, with high contribution caps, work well for people of all income levels.

President Trump’s tax plan released last week reaffirmed his goal of slashing tax rates on businesses. The plan also proposed overhauling individual income taxes by simplifying the rate structure, increasing the standard deduction, and eliminating breaks such as the state and local tax deduction.

What was missing from the Trump plan were reforms to the tax treatment of personal savings. The plan would repeal the 3.8 percent investment tax imposed by Obamacare, but it was silent on the underlying dividend and capital-gains tax rates.

Meanwhile, the House Republican leadership plan would reform taxes on personal savings in two ways. First, it would drop the top dividend and capital-gains tax rates to 16.5 percent from the current 20 percent (23.8 percent when including the Obamacare investment tax). Second, it suggests adopting legislation by Senator Jeff Flake (R., Ariz.) and Representative Dave Brat (R., Va.) to create Universal Savings Accounts — USAs.

USAs would be like supercharged Roth Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs). Individuals could contribute up to $5,500 a year in after-tax income into the accounts, and then the earnings would grow, free of any taxes on interest, dividends, or capital gains. At any time for any reason, people could withdraw money from the accounts without paying taxes or penalties, which would make the accounts simple, flexible, and liquid.

Such all-purpose savings accounts have been road-tested in Britain and Canada, as we discuss in a new Cato Institute study. British Individual Savings Accounts (ISAs) and Canadian Tax-Free Savings Accounts (TSFAs) are popular with people at all income levels and all age groups. The accounts encourage people to save as much as they can, knowing that they will have easy access to the funds if needed.

About 20 percent of Americans own Roth IRAs, but 43 percent of the British hold ISAs and 54 percent of Canadians own TFSAs. Also, while one-quarter of Roth IRA holders contribute to their accounts each year, more than half of the British and Canadian account holders do so.

Why the big difference? Roth IRAs and other U.S. savings vehicles — such as Education Savings Accounts (ESAs) — are for single purposes and have many rules on withdrawals. By contrast, USA-style accounts have no rules on withdrawals and can be used for all saving purposes. The high ownership and contribution rates of TFSAs and ISAs show that these factors make a difference.

Our tax code double-taxes saving in general but then gives targeted relief to certain types of saving. Universal savings accounts are the solution to these distortions.

The goal for U.S. tax reform should be to create equal treatment for different economic choices, including the choice between consumption and saving, and between different types of saving. Our tax code double-taxes saving in general but then gives targeted relief to certain types of saving. USAs are the solution to these distortions: They would end double-taxation for all types of saving.

People of all ages would use USAs. A Federal Reserve survey found that “retirement” is the primary reason people say they are saving only after the age of 40. Younger people have other savings needs that USAs would fulfill, such as saving to buy an automobile or start a business. The British and Canadian accounts enjoy high contribution rates by young people.

ISAs and TFSAs also have broad usage across income levels, including people with moderate incomes. Whereas just 7 percent of U.S. households with incomes of less than $50,000 have Roth IRAs, 55 percent of British ISA holders have incomes of less than $25,000, and 55 percent of Canadian TSFA holders have incomes of less than $37,500.

In fleshing out its tax plan, the Trump administration should start with the Flake-Brat legislation but go bigger by lifting the annual contribution cap to $10,000 or more. Such large accounts would cover all the non-retirement savings that most families need. The annual contribution cap on the successful British ISAs is 20,000 pounds, or about $25,000.

What about the politics of USAs? One thing we know is that the base of support would be very broad — a wide range of people would use USAs to meet a diversity of savings needs.

The tax, simplification, and liquidity benefits of ISAs and TFSAs have revolutionized personal savings in Britain and Canada. We think USAs would do the same in the USA.

READ MORE:

Border-Adjustment Taxes Pushed in Congress, Why?

Reagan’s Tax Record & the New York Times

Trump’s Tax-Reform Proposal Needs Work, Congress

Most Popular

The Pollster Who Thinks Trump Is Ahead

The polling aggregator on the website RealClearPolitics shows the margin in polls led by Joe Biden in a blue font and the ones led by Donald Trump in red. For a while, the battleground states have tended to be uniformly blue, except for polls conducted by the Trafalgar Group. If you are a firm believer only in ... Read More

The Pollster Who Thinks Trump Is Ahead

The polling aggregator on the website RealClearPolitics shows the margin in polls led by Joe Biden in a blue font and the ones led by Donald Trump in red. For a while, the battleground states have tended to be uniformly blue, except for polls conducted by the Trafalgar Group. If you are a firm believer only in ... Read More
Media

Jeffrey Toobin and Our Public-Hate Ritual

Oh, Jeffrey Toobin — let him among us with a free hand cast the first stone. Toobin, a writer for The New Yorker and fixture on CNN, was participating in a role-playing exercise on a Zoom call with his magazine colleagues, wargaming election-night scenarios. Toobin was standing in for the courts when he ... Read More
Media

Jeffrey Toobin and Our Public-Hate Ritual

Oh, Jeffrey Toobin — let him among us with a free hand cast the first stone. Toobin, a writer for The New Yorker and fixture on CNN, was participating in a role-playing exercise on a Zoom call with his magazine colleagues, wargaming election-night scenarios. Toobin was standing in for the courts when he ... Read More
Media

The Biden Protection Racket

Joe Biden is the most cosseted presidential candidate in memory. He’s run a minimalist campaign that’s avoided the press as much as possible, while the press hasn’t been braying for more access and answers, but eager to avoid anything that could be discomfiting to the campaign. Never before have the ... Read More
Media

The Biden Protection Racket

Joe Biden is the most cosseted presidential candidate in memory. He’s run a minimalist campaign that’s avoided the press as much as possible, while the press hasn’t been braying for more access and answers, but eager to avoid anything that could be discomfiting to the campaign. Never before have the ... Read More

A Few Cracks in the Progressive Wall

The contemporary progressive agenda — of, say, an Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Kamala Harris, Bernie Sanders, or Elizabeth Warren — has rarely appealed to 51 percent of the American electorate. Most polls show opposition to Court packing and the abolition of the Electoral College. Voters don’t seem to like ... Read More

A Few Cracks in the Progressive Wall

The contemporary progressive agenda — of, say, an Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Kamala Harris, Bernie Sanders, or Elizabeth Warren — has rarely appealed to 51 percent of the American electorate. Most polls show opposition to Court packing and the abolition of the Electoral College. Voters don’t seem to like ... Read More
Elections

Biden Is Still Underperforming Hillary

On October 20, 2016: Hillary Clinton was up 6.8 in the RealClearPolitics average in Pennsylvania. Today, Biden is up 3.8. (that race only tightened to 2.1 in the last week of 2016.) Clinton was up twelve points in Michigan on that day. Biden is up 7.5 right now. Clinton was up 6.5 in Wisconsin. Biden is ... Read More
Elections

Biden Is Still Underperforming Hillary

On October 20, 2016: Hillary Clinton was up 6.8 in the RealClearPolitics average in Pennsylvania. Today, Biden is up 3.8. (that race only tightened to 2.1 in the last week of 2016.) Clinton was up twelve points in Michigan on that day. Biden is up 7.5 right now. Clinton was up 6.5 in Wisconsin. Biden is ... Read More