Law & the Courts

New York’s Assault on the NRA Sets a Dangerous Precedent

New York Governor Andrew Cuomo (Brendan McDermid/Reuters)
One can imagine similar actions targeting Planned Parenthood, tobacco companies, or even rival political campaigns.

The National Rifle Association announced May 11 that it has filed suit against the New York State Department of Financial Services; its superintendent, Maria T. Vullo; and the state’s governor, Andrew Cuomo, alleging the state and its agents violated the NRA’s First Amendment rights in a recent regulatory ruling.

I will leave to constitutional scholars to debate the First Amendment question. But in terms of regulating the business of insurance in an effective, efficient, and nonpoliticized manner — a topic about which I am the author of an annual report — the department’s behavior sets a dangerous precedent that should trouble citizens across the political spectrum.

The lawsuit stems from settlements the DFS reached earlier this month with Kansas City–based insurance broker Lockton Cos. and underwriter Chubb Ltd. The companies were fined $7 million and $1.3 million, respectively, in connection with alleged violations of New York insurance law. The purported wrongdoing stemmed from Lockton’s work as broker for the NRA’s “Carry Guard” insurance program, which provides liability insurance to NRA members for firearm-related accidents and for legal costs in self-defense cases.

The charges against Lockton varied from the technical to the flimsy to the picayune, but they all give the appearance of pretext for what the department was actually seeking, and got: a consent decree in which the broker agrees “not to participate in the Carry Guard Program, any similar programs, or any other NRA-endorsed programs with regard to New York State.”

In fact, Lockton had already cut ties with the NRA, one of a number of corporate partners to do so in the wake of the mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla. But the Department of Financial Services has made clear its willingness to pressure other firms to do the same. In an April letter from Vullo to the state’s banks and insurance companies, she wrote that the department “encourages its chartered and licensed financial institutions to continue evaluating and managing their risks, including reputational risks, that may arise from their dealings with the NRA or similar gun promotion organizations.”

Ironically, we have simultaneously seen recent legislative efforts by some gun-control advocates, including in the general assembly of neighboring Connecticut, to actually require gun owners to maintain liability insurance. The type of coverage usually envisioned by such proposals, which would compensate the victims of offensive uses of firearms, is unlikely ever to come to market, as intentional acts are generally agreed to be uninsurable. But as a result of the New York regulator’s action, one expects a chilling effect that would cause insurers to withdraw from offering even the more limited coverage included in the NRA program, or in many homeowners insurance policies.

The precedent set by these blatantly political regulatory actions undermines not only the insurance market, but the rule of law.

Indeed, Lloyd’s of London, the world’s largest market for hard-to-place risks, has responded by directing its underwriters “to terminate any existing programs of this type and not to enter into any new ones,” with specific reference to concerns about the New York DFS inquiry into “programs offered, marketed, endorsed or otherwise made available through the National Rifle Association of America.” The Lloyd’s decision was a feature, not a bug, of the department’s action. The goal pretty clearly was to use the regulator’s office, which is supposed to apply impartial, technocratic rules to see to it that insurance companies responsibly and competently manage their underwriting and investment risks and that they deal with consumers in good faith, to achieve political ends.

This temptation is not unique to the political Left. In early 2015, Oklahoma insurance commissioner John Doak issued a warning shot to property insurers in the state who might seek to invoke exclusions for “manmade” earthquakes stemming from oil and gas exploration. Despite strong evidence that deep-well injections play a role in the thousands of earthquakes Oklahoma experiences every year, Doak asserted there was “no agreement at a scientific or governmental level concerning any connection between injection wells or fracking and ‘earthquakes.'”

Seeing regulators open this Pandora’s box should be deeply concerning to those on both the right and the left. One easily could imagine similar motivated prosecutions of financial-services firms that do business with Planned Parenthood, tobacco companies, tech firms, the solar industry, or even the political campaigns of rival parties. The precedent set by these blatantly political regulatory actions undermines not only the insurance market, but the rule of law.

NOW WATCH: ‘NRA Donations Surge Amid Gun Control Push’

R. J. Lehmann is director of finance, insurance, and trade policy for the R Street Institute.

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

Hillary Ruins the Plan

Editor’s note: Andrew C. McCarthy’s new book is Ball of Collusion: The Plot to Rig an Election and Destroy a Presidency. This is the first in a series of excerpts.  There really was a collusion plot. It really did target our election system. It absolutely sought to usurp our capacity for ... Read More

An Insider’s Guide to Italian Insults

The tragicomic irony of Chris Cuomo’s pugilistic outburst earlier this week — cursing and physically threatening a man for taunting him with a reference to the movie The Godfather — is that the CNN anchor reinforced the usual tropes about Italian Americans. We are all wise-guys, goons, and Mafiosi, just ... Read More

Another Pop-Culture Christian Loses His Faith

It’s happened again. For the second time in three weeks, a prominent (at least in Evangelical circles) Christian has renounced his faith. In July, it was Josh Harris, a pastor and author of the mega-best-selling purity-culture book I Kissed Dating Goodbye. This month, it’s Hillsong United songwriter and ... Read More

The End of Hong Kong as We Know It

The protests in Hong Kong have been going on for more than four months now, and no matter how the current crisis concludes in the coming days or weeks, it will mark the end of Hong Kong as we know it. The protests started in response to an extradition bill that was proposed by the city’s Beijing-backed ... Read More
Economy & Business

The Great Mystery

Kevin Williamson disputes my characterization of his riposte. He writes: I wrote that people can choose what kind of work they want to do, and what kind of services they want to consume, without any help from Michael. Kevin then accuses me of being a stouthearted defender of the “Real America.” If ... Read More