PC Culture

University of Texas Sued for Ban on ‘Rude Speech’

University of Texas campus in Austin, Texas (Jon Herskovitz/Reuters)
No one should be afraid to express an opinion, especially in a place devoted to the exchange of ideas.

The University of Texas is facing a lawsuit over a campus policy that bans “rude speech.”

Speech First, a nonprofit membership association that advocates for free speech on college campuses, filed the lawsuit late last week.

“By failing to define highly subjective terms such as ‘offensive,’ ‘biased,’ ‘uncivil,’ and ‘rude,’ the University of Texas has given itself broad discretion to determine which speech — and whose speech — violates their policies,” Nicole Neily, the president and founder of Speech First, said in a release. “Unfortunately, this fails to pass Constitutional muster.”

According to the group’s release, “more than 100 reports of alleged ‘expressions of bias’ — through posters, fliers, social media, whiteboards, verbal comments, classroom behavior, etc. — have been investigated by the university’s bias response team since September 2017,” and the existence of that bias-response team has made members of Speech First who are enrolled at the school hesitant to speak about abortion, identity politics, and immigration because they are afraid that “their speech will be anonymously reported as derogatory, hostile, and/or offensive to university authorities through the Campus Climate Response Team.”

The group further explains that the school’s failure “to provide sufficiently narrow definitions for . . . highly subjective terms” such as “rude” or “offensive” creates “a serious risk that these provisions will be enforced in an arbitrary or discriminatory manner, or will be used to target speech based on the viewpoint expressed.”

“As used, these concepts capture staggering amounts of protected speech and expression,” the release states.

“Without a doubt, the University of Texas has failed to appropriately safeguard students’ First Amendment rights,” Neily said. “Students deserve to be able to express themselves and voice their opinions without fear of investigation or punishment — which is why these policies must be reformed.”

Personally, I absolutely agree with all of the concerns that were raised by Speech First. First of all, it absolutely is true that words such as “rude” and “offensive” are completely subjective. What one person might find to be “offensive,” another might find to be innocuous or even hilarious. I also agree with the concerns that “staggering amounts of protected speech and expression” might wind up being punished under this policy. After all, just look at how many things have been declared “offensive” on college campuses over the last few years. (Hating pumpkin-spice lattes, wearing hoop earrings as a white woman, and the phrase “as you know” all come to mind — as does the phrase “long time no see,” certain kinds of eyebrows, and the size of chairs, to name a few.) Given the state of the climate on college campuses, it’s not inconceivable that a student would have to be worried about getting in trouble for saying something that he or she assumed was totally harmless — even when not discussing topics as controversial as immigration or abortion.

College is supposed to be a place where students can go to learn, and part of learning involves being exposed to different ideas. Colleges should have speech policies that encourage this sort of thing, not ones that make people afraid of it. Hopefully, this lawsuit will put some pressure on the school to change its ridiculous policy — not just because of the Constitution, but for the sake of its students’ education as well.

Note: This story was previously covered in an article in the Washington Examiner.

Most Popular

Media

The Attacks on Judge Barrett Have Already Started

Some left-wingers aren’t waiting for Judge Amy Barrett to be nominated to the Supreme Court to start attacking her. The attacks over the last few days have been steeped in anti-Catholicism, other types of bigotry, and lazy error. A headline at the left-wing website Refinery29 called her “the Potential RBG ... Read More
Media

The Attacks on Judge Barrett Have Already Started

Some left-wingers aren’t waiting for Judge Amy Barrett to be nominated to the Supreme Court to start attacking her. The attacks over the last few days have been steeped in anti-Catholicism, other types of bigotry, and lazy error. A headline at the left-wing website Refinery29 called her “the Potential RBG ... Read More

Andrew Cuomo’s Horrific Decisions

Observers of New York politics over the past several years understand that Governor Andrew Cuomo’s fanatical obsession with humiliating and overruling his fellow Democrat Bill de Blasio towers over every other consideration in the Empire State. Sometimes Cuomo’s habits come across as merely silly, as when he ... Read More

Andrew Cuomo’s Horrific Decisions

Observers of New York politics over the past several years understand that Governor Andrew Cuomo’s fanatical obsession with humiliating and overruling his fellow Democrat Bill de Blasio towers over every other consideration in the Empire State. Sometimes Cuomo’s habits come across as merely silly, as when he ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Rules Matter

On the menu today: One of Robert Mueller’s lieutenants now writes that the former FBI director failed to subpoena the president and otherwise “pulled punches for fear of incurring Trump’s wrath”; the importance of rules, and how political figures who refuse to apply a consistent standard make governing ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Rules Matter

On the menu today: One of Robert Mueller’s lieutenants now writes that the former FBI director failed to subpoena the president and otherwise “pulled punches for fear of incurring Trump’s wrath”; the importance of rules, and how political figures who refuse to apply a consistent standard make governing ... Read More
U.S.

Systemic Racism? Make Them Prove It.

I  worked in the criminal-justice system for a quarter century. It is run, day-to-day, by the crème de la crème of graduates from America’s top law schools. Those institutions wear their progressive bona fides on their sleeves and proclaim it for all the world to hear. In their offhand rhetoric — ... Read More
U.S.

Systemic Racism? Make Them Prove It.

I  worked in the criminal-justice system for a quarter century. It is run, day-to-day, by the crème de la crème of graduates from America’s top law schools. Those institutions wear their progressive bona fides on their sleeves and proclaim it for all the world to hear. In their offhand rhetoric — ... Read More
Law & the Courts

The Left Wants Regime Change

Constitutional revolution is going mainstream. After delivering lectures about political norms for the entirety of the Trump era -- often with good cause -- much of the Left is now threatening to kneecap an important institution of American government on a partisan vote in an act of ideological ... Read More
Law & the Courts

The Left Wants Regime Change

Constitutional revolution is going mainstream. After delivering lectures about political norms for the entirety of the Trump era -- often with good cause -- much of the Left is now threatening to kneecap an important institution of American government on a partisan vote in an act of ideological ... Read More