There were only two candidates on stage at Wednesday nightโs Democratic debate who really mattered: Joe Biden, the front-runner, and Kamala Harris, whoโd skewered Biden in the first debate and was polling within striking distance in some early states. No one else on stage was hitting 2 percent in the national polling average. With that in mind, the takeaway is clear: Harris lost, and Biden won.
Harrisโs troubles began with her lackluster opening statement, a recitation of some lines from her stump speech on the theme that โwe are better than this.โ Her worst moments occurred shortly thereafter, during the debate over health care, which revealed her substantive weakness on the policy issue dominating the Democratic primary.
Biden landed some solid blows against Harrisโs health-care plan by pointing out that it doesnโt take effect for ten years, would cost $30 trillion over a decade once implemented, would eventually abolish employer-based insurance, and would require โmiddle-class taxes to go up, not down.โ
โAnytime someone tells you youโre going to get something good in ten years, you should wonder why it takes ten years,โ Biden said. โThis is the single most important issue facing the public. And to be very blunt and to be very straightforward, you canโt beat President Trump with double-talk on this plan.โ
And โdouble-talkโ is what Harris ultimately engaged in when discussing the cost of her plan.
Colorado senator Michael Bennet also pointed out that Harrisโs plan abolishes employer-based insurance and costs $30 trillion, adding that this price tag equals 70 percent of all federal revenues over the next decade. โWe cannot keep with the Republican talking points on this,โ Harris responded.
Biden claimed his own plan establishing a โpublic optionโ would cost $750 billion (one-fortieth the cost of Medicare for All), limit co-pays to $1,000, and cap out-of-pocket health-care expenditures at 8.5 percent of income.
โ$30 trillion has to ultimately be paid,โ Biden said. โI donโt know what math you do in California, but I tell ya, thatโs a lot of money, and there will be a deductible. The deductible will be out of your paycheck, because thatโs what will be required.โ
โLetโs talk about math!โ Harris replied. โLetโs talk about the fact that the pharmaceutical companies and the insurance companies last year alone profited $72 billion, and that is on the backs of American families.โ What Harris didnโt note is that if every dollar of that $72 billion were confiscated, it would pay for about 2.4 percent of one year of her plan. Thatโs probably why she began denouncing Bidenโs plan as โimmoralโ for failing to sufficiently rein in insurance companies, rather than actually talk about math.
Harris deftly attacked Biden on the issue of busing during the first debate, but the issue didnโt work for her on Wednesday.
โVice President Biden says that your current position on busing, youโre opposed to federally mandated busing, that that position is the same as his position. Is he right?โ CNN moderator Jake Tapper asked.
โThat is simply false,โ Harris said. But Harris failed to explain how her position on busing differs from Bidenโs position today โ something she has been struggling to do for the past month โ and instead said that she would have voted differently back in the 1970s.
Biden did something smart during his rebuttal: Rather than relitigate the 1970s, he pivoted to an attack on Harrisโs record in California. He criticized her for failing to bring any cases as California attorney general to desegregate the San Francisco and Los Angeles public schools, and he went after Harris for failing to provide potentially exculpatory evidence to prisoners that ultimately resulted in 1,000 of them being freed. โIf you doubt me, Google 1,000 prisoners freed, Kamala Harris,โ Biden said.
The Sacramento Bee reports: โBiden alluded to a crime lab scandal that involved her office and resulted in more than 1,000 drug cases being dismissed. [Representative Tulsi] Gabbard claimed Harris โblocked evidence that would have freed an innocent man from death row until she was forced to do so.โ Both of these statements are accurate.โ
Biden also appeared, in contrast to his first-debate performance, lucid and sharp when debating Cory Booker on the issue of criminal justice and Juliรกn Castro on the issue of immigration.
โI have guts enough to say his plan doesnโt make sense,โ Biden said of Castroโs plan to decriminalize illegal entry into the United States, a policy backed by most other Democratic candidates. โWhen people cross the border illegally, it is illegal to do it unless theyโre seeking asylum. People should have to get in line. Thatโs the problem. And the only reason this particular part of the law is being abused is because of Donald Trump. We should defeat Donald Trump and end this practice.โ
Biden did have a few moments of weakness. He refused to say whether heโd advised President Obama to stop deportations โ โI keep my recommendation to him in privateโ โ but later touted his private recommendation to Obama against the troop surge in Afghanistan. And just when it looked like Biden was in the clear, he appeared to struggle to read a teleprompter or cue card when he haltingly concluded his closing remarks by telling debate watchers to โgo to joe-3-0-3-3-0 and help me in this fight.โ There was no joe30330.com website to visit. Biden had apparently garbled a message about texting โjoeโ to the number 30330.
But all in all, it was a good night for the septuagenarian front-runner. Whether he can keep it up when all of his serious rivals โ Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders, and Kamala Harris โ are on the same stage is a question to be answered at the next debate, in September.







Comments