Some years ago, a liberal-minded friend of mine complained during lunch that Fox News was โstealingโ his elderly parents. โThey should be enjoying retirement,โ he said, noting that they live in a modest but comfortable style with attentive children and grandchildren to enjoy. โBut instead,โ he sighed, โthey keep this channel on all day, and it makes them anxious and agitated.โ
I thought of this exchange last week when Hillary Clinton gave an interview in which she accused socialist Jill Stein, President Donald Trump, and Congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard of being in various ways compromised or controlled by the Kremlin. That is, I started to wonder whether Hillary Clinton is the victim of a kind of media elder abuse. Is the broader media ecosphere of โthe resistanceโ her daily source of paranoia? The ladies of The View have tried to validate her conspiratorial gibbering โ the hosts this week spoke of Gabbard as a โTrojan horseโ candidate. Is Clinton talking to John Brennan too much?
Just a few years ago, Clintonโs own memoir of her time at the State Department gave the impression that she was a mostly uneducated naรฏf, a historically illiterate New York Times reader trying to understand global politics. There was ignorance to spare, but no hint of conspiratorial madness. Why did the intervention in Libya go so wrong? Back then, she just shrugged. โWould the countryโs future be shaped by the arms of its militias or the aspirations of its people?โ Clinton wrote, with all the insight of a failed opinion columnist for a college newspaper.
But something darker has come upon her imagination lately. โIโm not making any predictions,โ Clinton said in that recent interview.
But I think [the Russians] have got their eye on someone whoโs currently in the Democratic primary and are grooming her to be the third-party candidate. Sheโs the favorite of the Russians. They have a bunch of sites and bots and other ways of supporting her so far. Thatโs assuming Jill Stein will give it up, which she might not, because sheโs also a Russian asset. . . . Yeah, sheโs a Russian asset. I mean, totally. They know [Trump] canโt win without a third-party candidate.
The idea that the Kremlin is getting ready to support a third-party Tulsi Gabbard run is a form of madness, one that is becoming distressingly common among the septuagenarian outpatient group that America knows as its political-leadership class. That Clinton folded together Trump, Gabbard, and Stein this way nearly illustrated the way in which, for a certain kind of establishmentarian, all foreign-policy disagreement is evidence of treason.
Because the performance of our policy elite over the past two decades is so poor, they now must suspect everyone of being a Russian agent these days. Progressive journalist Glenn Greenwald is a โRussian agentโ for these people. Mitch McConnell is โMoscow Mitch.โ Nancy Pelosi says of the American president, โAll roads lead to Putin.โ I suppose the supermajority of Americans who opposed Americaโs changing the Syrian regime in 2013 are Kremlin agents, too. Even your humble scribe has been accused of being on Putinโs payroll by full-time online maniacs who occasionally take side gigs pretending to defend the free world.
My appreciation for Tulsi Gabbard has mostly been played off as a joke. But itโs real enough. Gabbard has occasionally relied on some dodgy materials while making her case against the American intelligence community, but I like that she has an independent streak and a genuinely different, undeniably American background. She served in the military after 9/11 and still serves as a reserve officer. She is consistently skeptical of what she calls regime-change wars. Iโm happy that she pointed out the gap between Donald Trumpโs America First rhetoric about bringing the troops home and the fact that he simply moved them from Syria to Saudi Arabia. Gabbard has tried, unsuccessfully, to moderate her partyโs more paranoiac secularism, the type that sees a judgeโs membership in the Knights of Columbus as a threat.
In fact, that last point is one of the most salient. Gabbard has been to a theater of war, and perhaps she has a more intuitive sense of the difference between real danger and cynical paranoia. Where others imagine Vatican plots when evaluating recent judicial nominee Brian Buescher, she sees an American Catholic with whom she has political differences. (Political differences are not quite yet criminalized in this country.) Where others concoct collusion with Russia, she sees genuine American dissent from Washington orthodoxy.
Perhaps war-skeptical conservatives are to Gabbard what Warren Harding was to Eugene V. Debs. President Harding pardoned Debs; his crime was giving a dovish speech in Chicago opposing President Wilsonโs โwar to end all wars.โ Itโs salutary to remember that war often makes not just the soldiers, but its leaders mean and insane. Clinton pretends to uncover a fifth columnist, thereby revealing that her own judgement, like that of the foreign policy she represents, is paranoid and subject to dementia. But Gabbard is innocent, and only the young can be as idealistic as she is.







Comments