Three years before the novel coronavirus appeared in Wuhan, in a city more than 7,000 miles away, Lawfareโs Quinta Jurecic published an essay titled โDonald Trumpโs State of Exception.โ It hadnโt arrived yet, Jurecic conceded, and perhaps it never would. But our then president-elect had already exhibited warning signs: hedging on whether heโd accept the election result, attacking federal judges, threatening (off-the-cuff) to his 2016 rival that he would โlock her up.โ
Thus Jurecicโs concern. The โstate of exceptionโ is a concept pioneered by Nazi political theorist Carl Schmitt, and means something like an emergency dictatorship โ precipitated by a crisis so big and sudden and scary that it demands the suspension of law itself. This, Schmitt thought, was liberalismโs Achillesโ heel: No constitutional order could predict every possible peril that might befall it, or what exceptional measures would be needed to weather the storm; only a person could do that. The sovereign, then, is not โthe law,โ but he who decides on the exception to the law โ on whether the peril is so great that extreme, extra-constitutional steps are warranted. (Schmitt believed they were warranted in the case of Weimar Germany โ hence his steadfast support for the Third Reich.)
Jurecicโs worry โ and not hers alone โ was that Trump would behave as if there were a crisis when there wasnโt one, suspending the legal order for reasons of paranoia or amusement or for no reason at all. He would be Americaโs โfirst Schmittian presidentโ โ and, Jurecic assumed, a Schmittian without a cause.
That assumption was plausible the year Trump took office. It remained somewhat plausible for the next three, kept afloat through Russiagate by the possibility of self-pardon. But it is less plausible now. Now there is an emergency, there is a crisis, there is an exception, there is COVID-19 in our streets and schools and lungs โ and thus far, Trump has done almost nothing to stop it, much less initiate a state of exception.
Yes, he declared an emergency. Yes, he slashed a few regulations. Yes, he regurgitated CDC โguidelines.โ But this weekend, bars were still packed, parties were still happening, shops were still open. โSOCIAL DISTANCINGโ Trump tweeted Saturday morning. By nightfall, young people had congregated in major cities nationwide, inches apart, celebrating St. Patrickโs Day as though it were their last hurrah. For some, perhaps, it was.
For others, it was something worse. The virus may not kill the young with the same alacrity as the old, but it does infect themโas often or more so than the elderlyโand they infect everyone else in turn. Experts expect hospitals across the country to be overwhelmed within two weeks. An optimistic estimate is 200,000 deaths; a pessimistic one is 2 million. And even if mortality is under 1 percent once all โmildโ cases are identified, I think that it is safe to say the dead donโt care about denominators.
We wonโt โflatten the curveโ via tweet. If the skyrocketing number of cases in Europe is any indication, we must react to COVID-19 as forcefully as Italy, before the Italian scenario is fully upon us. And that means pushing for things that, in any other circumstance, at any other time, would rightly alarm Trumpโs critics: restricting interstate travel, quarantining cities, closing non-essential stores, ordering people to stay in their homes โ and punishing, with fines or worse, everyone who donโt comply.
The president can probably only do the first two things, legally speaking; state governors would have to do the rest. But Trump could tell the governors what to do. He could use all of his presidential powers, never mind his Twitter account, to cajole and coerce states into a de facto nationwide lockdown before itโs too late โ and it is getting very, very late. โIf Italy had strongly acted just 10 days ago,โ a team of Italian doctors wrote, โthere would have been much fewer deaths and economic tumble.โ We are at most two weeks behind Italy on the epidemic curve โ which gives us about three days to take drastic action.
It is possible that enough governors will realize this in the next 72 hours; some, to their credit, already have. It is possible โ desirable โ that a kind of decentralized Schmittianism will emerge, as local officials take unprecedented steps to enforce social distancing without federal direction. (The decision by Ohioโs governor to delay Tuesdayโs primary contests, despite initial roadblocks, was a good example of local exception-making.)
But itโs also possible that none of this will happen, or that it wonโt happen fast enough โ in which case Trump will face a truly existential choice: let the equivalent of multiple 9/11s happen on his watch; or do whatever it takes to stop the virus, from commandeering hotels to military-enforced quarantines.
The president may not have the authority to do those things. A Schmittian president would do them anyway.
And the reason Trump hasnโt (and most likely wonโt) is that he is too narcissistic to flex his muscle when the public good requires it, too obsessed with self-image to override a demos that, until Monday, seemed hell-bent on suicide. If COVID-19 destroys his presidency, it wonโt be because of his authoritarian instincts or contempt for democracy; rather, it will be because he indulged โthe peopleโ against their own best interests, in what has already proved a self-defeating elevation of markets over men.
To be clear: Iโm not suggesting Trump go full authoritarian, or that his doing so would be good, and if anything his incompetence as president speaks against the sagacity of letting him play Caesar.
Iโm just saying that if America were to have a Schmittian president, or even a quasi-Schmittian one, now would be the time. That Trump hasnโt jumped at the chance confirms that the real danger of his presidency was never fascism but fecklessnessโa danger which, with COVID-19, has finally come home to roost.
Editorโs Note: This article has been updated to correct an editing error.







Comments
On โDonald Trump Was Never a Carl Schmitt Acolyteโ