Who Is to Blame for an Abortion?

One need not infantilize mothers to acknowledge that strong societal forces can impair their moral vision, particularly for the very young and vulnerable.

Share this story

lolostock/iStock/Getty Images

As pro-lifers march into a new year with the very real hope of a future without Roe v. Wade, our conversations are beginning to shift. Thereโ€™s a sense in which, if Roe falls, nothing will change. Abortion mills will still run, church groups will still hold prayer vigils outside their doors, and social conservatives will still need to make the pro-life case. Yet because our social context will be different, the way we speak will be different. The way we write books will be different. One question looms especially large for conservatives in this new landscape: How should we think about legal penalties for mothers who have an abortion? And beyond the legal question, how should we think about their moral culpability?

In his latest monthly newsletter, Aaron Renn accuses the pro-life movement of โ€œmoral doublespeakโ€ around this question. He particularly lambastes โ€œChristian white knightsโ€ who primarily blame deadbeat men without holding mothers responsible. โ€œAbortion may be a sin,โ€ he writes, โ€œbut for a wide swath of pro-life conservatives, women who abort their babies arenโ€™t sinners.โ€ He cites their rush to distance the pro-life brand from Donald Trumpโ€™s tentative comments in March 2016 that there should be โ€œsome form of punishmentโ€ for women who have an abortion. Various public statements from pro-lifers referred to both babies and women as โ€œvictims.โ€ Even Doug Wilsonโ€™s more nuanced response leaves Renn dissatisfied. His problem is not simply the hesitancy to penalize women as a matter of legal prudence but the hesitancy to assign any moral blame at all.

Bethel McGrew

About the Author

Bethel McGrew

Bethel McGrew is a widely published essayist and social critic.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement