Bench Memos

A Challenge to Liberal Legal Ethicists

Just wondering: Is there any legal ethics specialist who is willing to opine that Judge Reinhardt is not obligated to disqualify himself from the Prop 8 appeal?

Here’s a high-level review of the two separate grounds for disqualification. (See the linked posts for more detail and documentation.)

1. Reinhardt’s wife is executive director of the ACLU Foundation of Southern California. The ACLU Foundation of Southern California participated as counsel for amicus (and as counsel for proposed plaintiff-intervenors) in the district-court proceedings in this very case.

Canon 3.C of the Code of Conduct for United States Judges provides a non-exhaustive list of circumstances in which a judge must disqualify himself on the ground that his “impartiality might reasonably be questioned.” Subpart (1)(d) states that those circumstances “includ[e] but [are] not limited to instances in which … the judge’s spouse … is (i) a party to the proceeding, or an officer, director, or trustee of a party; or (ii) acting as a lawyer in the proceeding.” Federal statutory law (28 U.S.C. § 455) sets forth virtually identical grounds for disqualification.

In this case, Reinhardt’s wife was an officer of an entity that acted as a lawyer in the proceeding—a trivial variation on the examples given.

Judge Reinhardt properly has an established policy of disqualifying himself in all cases involving the ACLU Foundation of Southern California. He presumably did not apply that policy when the Prop 8 appeal was assigned to him because he was unaware of the ACLU Foundation of Southern California’s involvement. Now that he has become aware, he must disqualify himself.

2. The lawyers for plaintiffs consulted with Reinhardt’s wife in deciding whether to file their lawsuit. In other words, Reinhardt’s wife was actually involved in this case.  

By the way, I’ve seen a lot of fog in the blogosphere about how Reinhardt’s situation is supposedly not distinct from various other situations involving conservative judges. But no one has actually pointed to a case in which a judge’s spouse did anything like (1) head an entity that participated in the very case, or (2) become actually involved in the very case. Indeed, on this latter point, I’ll note that Eugene Volokh, in a post months ago entitled “Justice Thomas and Judge Reinhardt,” distilled this rule: Situations in which a judge should have to recuse himself because of a family relationship “should generally be relatively rare situations, and limited to the family member’s actual involvement in a case and not just the family member’s political or ideological sympathy or alliance with a party.” (Emphasis added.) That “actual involvement” is exactly what we have here.

Most Popular


Holy Week with Saint Paul

Just the other day, I ordered a replacement copy of The Passion of the Christ -- it can be so impactful for Holy Week meditation. In the years since its release, it’s become something of required Lenten viewing for me. But this year, there is a new movie to help with prayer, Paul, Apostle of Christ, released ... Read More

Heckuva Job, Paul and Mitch

As Thursday's editorial makes clear, the omnibus spending bill is a disgrace. That may be why about 40 percent of Republicans (and 40 percent of Democrats) voted against it. Apart from the absence of a DACA/Dream amnesty, the immigration portions represent a comprehensive victory by the anti-enforcement crowd. ... Read More
Politics & Policy

California’s Pro-Nuclear Renegade

If California’s upcoming gubernatorial race gets decided solely by money, Michael Shellenberger doesn’t have a chance. The latest campaign filings show that Shellenberger, an environmentalist from Berkeley, has about $37,000 in cash on hand. The frontrunner in the June 5 California primary, Lieutenant ... Read More

Encouraging Signs in Iraq

Last year, relations between the Iraqi central government and the Kurds reached what was possibly an all-time low when the Kurds held an independence referendum in which 93 percent of voters opted to secede. The timing was no coincidence: Iraqi forces had retreated from Kurdish territory in 2014 as the Islamic ... Read More