Bench Memos

DIGging the Prop 8 Case Would Make No Sense

There is a lot of idle speculation that some justice might try to “DIG”—dismiss as improvidently granted—the cert petition in the Prop 8 case and thus spare themselves the burden of deciding the case. But, as an accomplished Supreme Court advocate has put it in an e-mail to me,

A DIG makes no sense as a matter of principle, of course. It is one thing for the Court to hold off on addressing a novel constitutional issue when the lower federal court ruling was consistent with the constitutional status quo. But when a lower federal court has broken new constitutional ground in striking down a state constitutional provision, that is normally an action-forcing event: the Court has traditionally felt an institutional obligation to have the final word before a state law is constitutionally invalidated.

I gather that it’s extremely rare for the Court to DIG a case in the face of substantial opposition (SCOTUSblog’s Tom Goldstein links to this 5-4 DIG in 1984), and I don’t see what plausible legal basis there is for a DIG here.

Moreover, the simplest way for the Court to continue to stay out of the way of the robust ongoing debate on marriage is to uphold the constitutionality of Prop 8 (and of DOMA) and to affirm that the question whether to redefine marriage to allow a man to marry a man or a woman to marry a woman is one that the Constitution leaves to the democratic processes.

Most Popular

Religion

Understanding the Mind of Modern Atheists

‘Heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will not pass away” (Matthew 24:35). Anthony DeStefano uses this Bible quote toward the end of his new book Inside the Atheist Mind: Unmasking the Religion of Those Who Say There Is No God, pointing to the resiliency and truth of Christianity. “You can hide it, ... Read More
Economy & Business

How the Constitution Limits State Taxes

Must a company have a physical presence in a state for that state to require it to collect taxes? The Supreme Court is considering that question, which has grown more important as online sales have taken off. The Competitive Enterprise Institute has submitted an excellent brief arguing that the answer is yes, at ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Pompeo Deserves Confirmation

Mike Pompeo is qualified to be secretary of state. There is no doubt about that. He is competent — as director of the CIA, he has managed a complex organization deftly, winning the respect of intelligence professionals otherwise not favorably inclined to President Trump. He is experienced — in an ... Read More
Culture

Off the Shelf: Suicide of the West

Editor’s Note: Every week, Michael Brendan Dougherty writes an “Off the Shelf” column sharing casual observations on the books he's reading and the passing scene. Before social media, Jonah Goldberg would respond to obstreperous emails from a much younger version of me with a characteristically light ... Read More