Bench Memos

Elena Kagan vs. Merrick Garland

Today’s Wall Street Journal reports that “Democrats gearing up for a possible Supreme Court vacancy are divided over whether President Barack Obama should appoint a prominent liberal voice while their party still commands a large Senate majority, or go with someone less likely to stoke Republican opposition.”  Oddly, the article lumps together Solicitor General Elena Kagan and D.C. Circuit judge Merrick Garland as leading examples of “less-controversial candidates.”

In my judgment, Kagan would be very likely to arouse significant Republican opposition, far more so than Garland.  For starters, she received 31 Republican “nay” votes and only seven positive votes (with three Republican senators not voting) just last year on her confirmation to be SG.  It’s reasonable to assume that all of the senators who voted against her (except newly minted Democrat Arlen Specter and departed senator Mel Martinez) would start off strongly inclined to vote against her for the Supreme Court, and that, given the much higher bar for the Supreme Court, so would many of the other Republicans.  There’s certainly nothing that’s happened over the past year to dispel any of the concerns that were raised during Kagan’s confirmation process, including by her abject failure to engage in a meaningful discussion of legal issues. 

Kagan earned goodwill among conservatives for her deanship of Harvard Law School.  But her fair treatment of conservatives, and the broader administrative skills that she displayed, signal very little about how she would be as a justice.  At best, she is a wild card.  Most likely, she would be largely indistinguishable from Ruth Bader Ginsburg. 

By contrast, Judge Garland has earned the respect of folks across the political spectrum for his judicial craftsmanship in his 13 years on the D.C. Circuit.  Unlike Kagan, he may well be the best that conservatives could reasonably hope for from a Democratic president.  While he’s certainly no judicial conservative, he would seem to represent what I described in this Washington Post piece last year as the “once-dominant species of liberal proponents of judicial restraint,” and his nomination might well “make great strides toward ending the judicial wars.”

Most Popular

White House

A Justified Pardon

President Trump’s pardon of retired General Michael Flynn, who fleetingly served as his first national-security adviser, was a justified act of clemency. You don’t have to be a fan of how Trump has wielded his pardon power (often recklessly and on behalf of friends and supporters) or believe that Flynn was ... Read More
White House

A Justified Pardon

President Trump’s pardon of retired General Michael Flynn, who fleetingly served as his first national-security adviser, was a justified act of clemency. You don’t have to be a fan of how Trump has wielded his pardon power (often recklessly and on behalf of friends and supporters) or believe that Flynn was ... Read More
Immigration

What Now for Trump’s Border Wall?

The verdict on the U.S.–Mexico border wall President Trump promised to construct is decidedly mixed as the year comes to a close. The “big, beautiful wall,” as Trump referred to it, reached 400 miles in length by the end of October, when the Department of Homeland Security held a ceremony hailing the ... Read More
Immigration

What Now for Trump’s Border Wall?

The verdict on the U.S.–Mexico border wall President Trump promised to construct is decidedly mixed as the year comes to a close. The “big, beautiful wall,” as Trump referred to it, reached 400 miles in length by the end of October, when the Department of Homeland Security held a ceremony hailing the ... Read More
Culture

New England Journal of Medicine Pushes Reparations

Reparations would grant African Americans government benefits not paid to other Americans to rectify the awful sin of slavery and the "peculiar institution's" residual harm. It is a favored policy of hard progressives, so of course, the New England Journal of Medicine -- which regularly promotes left-wing causes ... Read More
Culture

New England Journal of Medicine Pushes Reparations

Reparations would grant African Americans government benefits not paid to other Americans to rectify the awful sin of slavery and the "peculiar institution's" residual harm. It is a favored policy of hard progressives, so of course, the New England Journal of Medicine -- which regularly promotes left-wing causes ... Read More

The Imaginary Trump

Like Andrew Jackson, Donald Trump is man who represents the age in which he lived. Whatever you may think of the age. Jackson embodied a generation of men who had risen and made their mark in a young country. He represented their desire for greater representation, even if it had costs for slaves and Indians. He ... Read More

The Imaginary Trump

Like Andrew Jackson, Donald Trump is man who represents the age in which he lived. Whatever you may think of the age. Jackson embodied a generation of men who had risen and made their mark in a young country. He represented their desire for greater representation, even if it had costs for slaves and Indians. He ... Read More