Bench Memos

Former Judge Vaughn Walker on “Moving the Strike Zone”

Chief Justice Roberts’s analogy of judging to umpiring obviously did not intend to provide a comprehensive account of what judging entails. Rather (as Ramesh Ponnuru explained more fully in this National Review essay), the Chief Justice’s analogy memorably captured the judge’s duty of impartiality.

Anyone who overstates what the Chief Justice’s analogy was intended to convey can find ample ground for disputing the aptness of the hyperextended analogy. So it’s no surprise that former district judge Vaughn R. Walker, whose consistent pattern of malfeasance in the Prop 8 case amounts to what may be the most egregious performance ever by a federal district judge, makes some sound observations in his recently published lecture titled “Moving the Strike Zone: How Judges Sometimes Make Law.” That said, it’s quite telling—and explains a lot about his Prop 8 misconduct—that Walker summarizes his view of what judges “must do” as “take account of the pitcher and the batter in the legal arena, watch the windup, the throw, the curve, and the delivery and then, where they believe appropriate, move the strike zone.” (Page 1223 (emphasis added).)

There’s the basic choice: between a judge who understands his obligation to be to impartially call balls and strikes against a pre-defined strike zone and a judge, like Walker, who considers himself free to “move the strike zone” whenever he believes it “appropriate” to do so.

H/t Josh Blackman.

Most Popular

Law & the Courts

‘Judges for the #Resistance’

At Politico, I wrote today about the judiciary’s activism against Trump on immigration: There is a lawlessness rampant in the land, but it isn’t emanating from the Trump administration. The source is the federal judges who are making a mockery of their profession by twisting the law to block the Trump ... Read More
White House

Trump’s Friendships Are America’s Asset

The stale, clichéd conceptions of Donald Trump held by both Left and Right — a man either utterly useless or only rigidly, transactionally tolerable — conceal the fact that the president does possess redeeming talents that are uniquely his, and deserve praise on their own merit. One is personal friendliness ... Read More
U.S.

Columbia 1968: Another Untold Story

Fifty years ago this week, Columbia students riding the combined wave of the civil-rights and anti-war movements went on strike, occupied buildings across campus, and shut the university down. As you revisit that episode of the larger drama that was the annus horribilis 1968, bear in mind that the past isn’t ... Read More
Culture

Only the Strident Survive

‘I am not prone to anxiety,” historian Niall Ferguson wrote in the Times of London on April 22. “Last week, however, for the first time since I went through the emotional trauma of divorce, I experienced an uncontrollable panic attack.” The cause? “A few intemperate emails, inadvertently forwarded ... Read More