Bench Memos

“I’m sure she would have restated it”

It emerged Wednesday that Judge Sonia Sotomayor’s infamous 2002 La Raza ’wise Latina woman’ comment was not just inartful, off the cuff, or badly stated.

Sotomayor made an almost identical comment — indeed, an almost identical entire speech — in 1994 in Puerto Rico at the National Conference of Law Reviews in a speech entitled “Women in the Judiciary.”

President Obama, questioned by NBC’s Brian Williams about the 2002 comment last week, and other White House officials, have acted like the comment was just inartful or inadvertent.  Obama claimed, ”I’m sure she would have restated it.”  White House spokesman Robert Gibbs said that her “word choice in 2001 was poor.”

Sotomayor “restated” it alright, and her “poor word choice” was not momentary, but extended over more than seven years:  It turns out this was a stump speech that she delivered one at least two occasions, at least seven years apart.

Sotomayor’s well-considered theme, in this stump speech she used over the course of at least seven years, is to disagree with Justice O’Connor and New York federal Judge Miriam Cedarbaum’s views that men and women should not (and that good judges do not) rule based upon their own gender, race, or ethnicity.

Sotomayor repeatedly disagrees with O’Connor and Cedarbaum’s notions.  Sotomayor rejects the idea that ’judges must transcend their personal sympathies and prejudices and aspire to and achieve a greater degree of fairness and integrity based on the reason of the law.’  Sotomayor claims that women make different and ‘better’ decisions than men:  she said in 1994, ‘better will mean a more compassionate, and caring conclusion.’

The White House must now acknowledge that this is a hardened view of Sotomayor’s, rejecting impartiality and neutral judging, that it is now impossible to spin away.

 

Most Popular

White House

Obama Wrote Trump a $73 Million Check

The New York Times’ big exposé on President Trump's tax returns flags some things that may be dodgy but mainly it just confirms what everybody (including Trump) has always said -- there are a lot of loopholes in the tax code that a savvy operator can exploit. Whose fault is that? The system long predates ... Read More
White House

Obama Wrote Trump a $73 Million Check

The New York Times’ big exposé on President Trump's tax returns flags some things that may be dodgy but mainly it just confirms what everybody (including Trump) has always said -- there are a lot of loopholes in the tax code that a savvy operator can exploit. Whose fault is that? The system long predates ... Read More
Sports

It’s Time for a Change in Leadership

A lot of people -- including me -- will tell you he didn’t belong in the top job. We will tell you that nothing in his past performance indicated that he could handle the responsibility or had the right temperament for the pressures of leadership. Some of us opposed him before he stepped through the door and ... Read More
Sports

It’s Time for a Change in Leadership

A lot of people -- including me -- will tell you he didn’t belong in the top job. We will tell you that nothing in his past performance indicated that he could handle the responsibility or had the right temperament for the pressures of leadership. Some of us opposed him before he stepped through the door and ... Read More

Revolution by Shenanigan

Texans are very fond of reminding our fellow Americans that, because of its former status as an independent republic, Texas is the only state in the union permitted by treaty to leave the Union or renegotiate its status. This is a point of pride with Texans. It isn’t true. In fact, nothing you will ever ... Read More

Revolution by Shenanigan

Texans are very fond of reminding our fellow Americans that, because of its former status as an independent republic, Texas is the only state in the union permitted by treaty to leave the Union or renegotiate its status. This is a point of pride with Texans. It isn’t true. In fact, nothing you will ever ... Read More
Media

Three Cheers for Ruth Graham

In her piece in the New York Times today, Ruth Graham captured something quite true: Amy Coney Barrett’s nomination is a cultural moment for conservative women. We don’t like to talk in terms of trailblazing, because these words have ideological implications. But we all remember the “mommy wars” when moms ... Read More
Media

Three Cheers for Ruth Graham

In her piece in the New York Times today, Ruth Graham captured something quite true: Amy Coney Barrett’s nomination is a cultural moment for conservative women. We don’t like to talk in terms of trailblazing, because these words have ideological implications. But we all remember the “mommy wars” when moms ... Read More
Economy & Business

New Evidence of a Major TikTok Lie

On Sunday, the D.C. district court handed down a preliminary injunction that blocks the Trump administration’s TikTok ban order. The decision, which after being pushed back one week was slated to take effect on Sunday evening, has dealt a setback to Trump’s efforts to mitigate the app’s national-security ... Read More
Economy & Business

New Evidence of a Major TikTok Lie

On Sunday, the D.C. district court handed down a preliminary injunction that blocks the Trump administration’s TikTok ban order. The decision, which after being pushed back one week was slated to take effect on Sunday evening, has dealt a setback to Trump’s efforts to mitigate the app’s national-security ... Read More