Bench Memos

Iowa’s Fatally Flawed Judicial Nominating System

The Des Moines Register on Monday criticized Governor Branstad for his appointment of eight Republicans to Iowa’s judicial nominating commission. Iowa is a Missouri Plan state, and the commission, chaired by an Iowa Supreme Court Justice, is made up of eight governor-appointed nominees, and eight nominees elected by lawyers from their respective congressional districts. The Register argues that Iowa’s Senate should consider refusing Governor Branstad’s nominees, for being overly partisan. The Register’s complaints—based on actions that any competent governor would take — are nonsensical; Governor Branstad is, at best, returning bipartisanship to a fatally flawed nominating commission. 

The Register conveniently ignores that Governor Branstad’s appointments do not differ from those of previous governors. For example, in 2010, after twelve years of Democrat appointees, the commission, then 14 members, consisted of one unaffiliated member, eleven Democrats and two Republicans. Even though by any definition, this commission would be unbalanced, I can’t find any evidence that any appointments over the prior twelve years of Democrat control bothered the Register’s editorial board.

The Register also neglects that all Governor Branstad can hope to do is bring a semblance of balance to the commission, because his appointments are matched by the bar’s lawyer-elected appointees. I looked into the background of the remaining eight commissioners, and found that six of them were Democrats. Of the remaining two, one is a Republican, and one is unaffiliated with any political party.   

There are very damaging consequences for handing over a significant portion of the judicial nominating process to left-leaning special interests, and Iowa is exhibit A. Iowa’s Supreme Court is easily one of the most flagrantly activist in the country. In 2009, the court famously invented the right to gay marriage, as allegedly required under the Iowa constitution’s equal-protection clause. The court found that equal protection’s definition changed with each generation, and incomprehensibly cited the judiciary’s ability “to perform its constitutional role free from the influences that tend to make society’s understanding of equal protection resistant to change.”

Thankfully, in 2010, a full 54 percent of Iowa voters voted to deny retention for three of the justices, achieving something that virtually never happens in Missouri Plan states. Those justices were eventually replaced by Governor Branstad, who was forced to choose nominees from the lists forwarded to him by the state’s nominating commission.

The good news is, Governor Branstad’s three most recent appointees seem to have improved the direction of the court. But, so long as Iowa continues to be a member of the Missouri Plan club, allowing the state bar to stack the bench with like-minded (usually left-leaning) judges, don’t expect things to improve. Until substantial reforms are made, the Judicial Crisis Network looks forward to working with friends and allies in the state to begin the process of reforming Iowa’s broken judicial-selection system.

Carrie Severino is chief counsel and policy director to the Judicial Crisis Network.

Most Popular

Film & TV

A Sad Finale

Spoilers Ahead. Look, I share David’s love of Game of Thrones. But I thought the finale was largely a bust, for failings David mostly acknowledges in passing (but does not allow to dampen his ardor). The problems with the finale were largely the problems of this entire season. Characters that had been ... Read More
Politics & Policy

The Great Misdirection

The House Democrats are frustrated, very frustrated. They’ve gotten themselves entangled in procedural disputes with the Trump administration that no one particularly cares about and that might be litigated for a very long time. A Washington Post report over the weekend spelled out how stymied Democrats ... Read More
World

Australia’s Voters Reject Leftist Ideas

Hell hath no fury greater than left-wingers who lose an election in a surprise upset. Think Brexit in 2016. Think Trump’s victory the same year. Now add Australia. Conservative prime minister Scott Morrison shocked pollsters and pundits alike with his victory on Saturday, and the reaction has been brutal ... Read More
NR Webathon

We’ve Had Bill Barr’s Back

One of the more dismaying features of the national political debate lately is how casually and cynically Attorney General Bill Barr has been smeared. He is routinely compared to Roy Cohn on a cable-TV program that prides itself on assembling the most thoughtful and plugged-in political analysts and ... Read More
Film & TV

Game of Thrones: A Father’s Legacy Endures

Warning! If you don't want to read any spoilers from last night's series finale of Game of Thrones, stop reading. Right now. There is a lot to unpack about the Thrones finale, and I fully understand many of the criticisms I read on Twitter and elsewhere. Yes, the show was compressed. Yes, there were moments ... Read More