Bench Memos

Kagan Recusal: What Others Are Saying

For those who are keeping track of the debate over Justice Kagan’s involvement in the Obamacare litigation, here is a collection of notable quotes and statements on the matter.

My Bench Memos colleague Ed Whelan, in an L.A. Times piece by James Oliphant:

“The DOJ documents that have been made public show that Kagan was personally involved in advising how to defend against challenges to” the healthcare law.

Lamar Smith, Chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, in a Washington Post op-ed:

The NFL wouldn’t allow a team to officiate its own game. If, as solicitor general, Kagan did advise administration officials on the constitutionality of the president’s health-care law, she should not officiate when the matter comes before the Supreme Court. The Obama administration has a responsibility to fully disclose any information about what role Kagan played in the review of the Affordable Care Act. The validity of the outcome at the high court depends on the impartiality of the justices.

Senator Sessions, Ranking Member of the Senate Judiciary Committee during Kagan’s confirmation, in a letter to Attorney General Eric Holder:

[E]mails that the Department of Justice was compelled to release in response to lawsuits under the Freedom of Information Act the day after your appearance before the Judiciary Committee and earlier this year seem to contradict your purported lack of cognizance of the House Judiciary Committee’s request and your assertion that at all times in this matter Solicitor General Kagan was excluded from discussions and/or deliberations regarding these matters. I am deeply disturbed by these developments and believe that the Justice Department should have provided these documents to the Senate Judiciary Committee during Justice Kagan’s confirmation hearing.

Senators McConnell, Kyl, Grassley and Lee, in a letter to Attorney General Eric Holder:

Among other involvement in this matter, it appears that she was privy to discussions of legal claims and litigation strategy concerning court challenges to the PPACA. And it is apparent that she herself enthusiastically supported this legislation as a member of the Administration which is now defending it. When a former member of the Administration is in a position to rule on litigation in which she apparently had some involvement and which concerns legislation she herself supports, public confidence in the administration of justice is undermined.

Washington Examiner editorial board:

Considering the vote buying in the Senate – remember the Cornhusker Kickback? – and the warping of House rules to gain Obamacare’s passage, it would be refreshing to see Kagan respect the law by recusing herself when the measure comes before the nation’s highest court.

Liberal law professor Jonathan Turley, on his blog

That effort [by the Obama administration to have “carefully separated Kagan from any discussions of the health care law”] may be successful, though it also increases the appearance of selecting someone in part to help guarantee a vote on the critical legislative measure for the Administration. Given the obvious effort by everyone to separate Kagan from these discussions, she may have avoided a conflict, but the involvement of her office still presents a serious appearance question.

Carrie Severino — Carrie Severino is chief counsel and policy director to the Judicial Crisis Network.

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

It’s the Stock Market, Stupid

Before going any further, I must say that I don’t believe Protectionist Donald really will go all the way with his present attempt to strangle global trade. I believe that the end run will be quite similar to what it was with the steel and aluminum tariffs — which is to say, a photo op in the Oval Office. ... Read More

Ten Things that Caught My Eye Today (March 23, 2018)

I send out a free weekly e-mail newsletter that typically goes out Saturday mornings and includes WFB flashbacks, Firing Line videos, upcoming events, and some of what I’ve been up to. Sign up here. 1. Cardinal Timothy Dolan in the Wall Street Journal: Talking about New York, he noted: 2. The Guardian on the ... Read More
National Review

Palm Sunday with WFB

The wonderful National Review Institute forum in New York City last month, held on the tenth anniversary of Bill Buckley’s death -- but truly a celebration of his life and legacy -- was captured by the good folks at C-SPAN, who now tell us that two panels of the forum will be broadcast this Sunday on C-SAN 3. ... Read More
Politics & Policy

The Sliming of Bari Weiss

If you follow at all the ideological war that’s erupted around the New York Times editorial page, then you know Bari Weiss. It’s too much to call Bari conservative. A better description might be heterodox. On some issues, particularly social issues and immigration, she’s a woman of the Left. On others — ... Read More
Politics & Policy

How the Nazis Used Gun Control

The perennial gun-control debate in America did not begin here. The same arguments for and against were made in the 1920s in the chaos of Germany’s Weimar Republic, which opted for gun registration. Law-abiding persons complied with the law, but the Communists and Nazis committing acts of political violence did ... Read More