Bench Memos

The Marriage Cases: A Quick Initial Observation

It’s a good thing for supporters of traditional marriage that the Court granted review both in the Prop 8 case and in one of the Defense of Marriage Act cases.

For starters, the rulings below were both adverse to traditional marriage, so a denial of review in either case would have left the adverse ruling in place.

More broadly, the challengers to DOMA have been employing a stealth strategy, invoking phony and confused federalism concerns (see point 1 here) and trying to pretend that DOMA can coherently be invalidated on grounds that wouldn’t dictate a broader constitutional right to same-sex marriage. The fact that the Prop 8 case is being considered together with the DOMA challenge ought to expose the stealth: Same-sex marriage advocates can’t plausibly be heard to maintain in their attack on DOMA that marriage is the traditional preserve of the states at the same time that they’re arguing in the Prop 8 case that the federal Constitution compels states to require same-sex marriage. Nor (as I will explain more fully) is there any coherent way to strike down DOMA that wouldn’t also require striking down Prop 8 and other state laws preserving traditional marriage.

To be clear, I am certainly not predicting that supporters of traditional marriage will be victorious in either or both cases (although I strongly believe they should win both). But their prospects of prevailing in both ought to be enhanced by having the cases considered together.

Most Popular

PC Culture

John Oliver’s Micro-Trolling

John Oliver is sometimes classified as a political satirist, but what he really seems to fancy is nonsensical trolling. Remember his big idea for taking down Donald Trump two years ago? It was a lengthy segment making fun of an ancestral name, Drumpf, that might have been changed to Trump as far back as the 17th ... Read More
White House

The Anti-Trump Effort Backfires

No one following the Russian-collusion and related dramas should be in any doubt about the steady flow of the balance of damaging evidence away from Trump and on to his accusers. It is clear that the hierarchy of the FBI and analogues in the Justice Department and intelligence services, horrified at the thought ... Read More
PC Culture

The Confederate Mind

Senator Elizabeth Warren has doubled down on her insistence that she is Native American. The New One-Drop Fixation In her past incarnations, she probably used that yarn in hopes of helping her win a law professorship at Harvard, which touted her as the law school’s first indigenous-American professor (and ... Read More

The Truth Hurts at Penn Law

One of the chief criticisms of affirmative action is that it devalues credentials that minorities could otherwise use to distinguish themselves. If college admissions were purely merit-based, employers would have no reason to discount an impressive degree just because it is held by a black or Hispanic applicant. ... Read More
Science & Tech

The Social-Media Panic

‘Make no mistake: 2016 will never happen again.” Historians are not always reliable predictors of the future, but Niall Ferguson’s analysis of how Silicon Valley and the center-Left would react to the successive and surprise victories of Brexit and Donald Trump is proving correct. Conservatives and ... Read More
White House

The Real Collusion Story

Barack Obama keeps a close watch on his emotions. “I loved Spock,” he wrote in February 2015 in a presidential statement eulogizing Leonard Nimoy. Growing up in Hawaii, the young man who would later be called “No-Drama Obama” felt a special affinity for the Vulcan first officer of the U.S.S. Enterprise. ... Read More