Bench Memos

Law & the Courts

Masterpiece Cakeshop Victory

In this much-watched case, Masterpiece Cakeshop and its owner Jack Phillips challenged the decision of the Colorado Civil Rights Commission that held that he violated state anti-discrimination law in refusing to bake a cake for a same-sex wedding. Today, the Court ruled, by a vote of 7 to 2, that the state commission violated the Free Exercise Clause by failing to provide a “neutral and respectful consideration” of Phillips’s claims. Justice Kennedy wrote the majority opinion, which was joined in full by the Chief Justice and Justices Breyer, Alito, Kagan, and Gorsuch.

As evidence of the state commission’s “clear and impermissible hostility toward the sincere religious beliefs that motivated [Phillips’s] objection,” Justice Kennedy pointed out that “commissioners endorsed the view that religious beliefs cannot legitimately be carried into the public sphere or commercial domain, implying that religious beliefs and persons are less than fully welcome in Colorado’s business community.” He complains that one commissioner “even went so far as to compare Phillips’ invocation of his sincerely held religious beliefs to defenses of slavery and the Holocaust.”

As another “indication of hostility,” Kennedy also points out that Phillips’s conscience-based objection was treated less favorably than the objections of other bakers to creating cakes “with images that conveyed disapproval of same-sex marriage.”

In separate concurring opinions, Kagan (joined by Breyer) and Gorsuch (joined by Alito) sparred over whether the commission could have justified its disparate treatment of those other bakers.

In an opinion concurring in the judgment (joned by Gorsuch), Justice Thomas would have ruled for Masterpiece Cakeshop on both Free Speech and Free Exercise grounds.

Justice Ginsburg, joined by Justice Sotomayor, dissented.

This is an important victory, even as it kicks some bigger issues down the road. I hope to find time later today for some additional comments.

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

We’ll Regret This

Mitch McConnell says the president will sign the budget deal and he will also declare a national emergency to build the wall, as I expected. We’ll see the legal justifications he uses, but as a political and constitutional matter this is a long-term disaster. Oh, it might be good for Trump according to the ... Read More
Culture

Jussie Smollett Changes His Story Again

The actor Jussie Smollett continues to talk about the alleged January 29 attack on him during a frigid night in Chicago, giving Good Morning America his fullest description yet of his claims. It differs substantially from what he told police initially after the alleged assault. Smollett told GMA that the ... Read More
White House

The Failure of the Deal

EDITOR’S NOTE: The following is Jonah Goldberg’s weekly “news”letter, the G-File. Subscribe here to get the G-File delivered to your inbox on Fridays. Dear Reader (But especially Sammie), I had my say on the emergency declaration yesterday, and I’m sure I’ll have to say it all again not very far ... Read More