Bench Memos

Law & the Courts

Posner Self-Immolation Watch

From Above the Law, three excerpts from some recent comments from Seventh Circuit judge Richard Posner:

I think the Supreme Court is awful. I think it’s reached a real nadir. Probably only a couple of the justices, Breyer and Ginsburg, are qualified. They’re okay, they’re not great.

[I]f you look at the Supreme Court, for example, of the nine justices — I’m bringing Scalia back from the dead to have the standard number of justices — of those nine, one had been in a trial courtroom. It’s ridiculous to have an appellate judge who doesn’t have trial experience.

The only two justices who are qualified are Ginsburg and Breyer. Their opinions are readable, and sometimes quite eloquent. The others, I wouldn’t waste my time reading their opinions.

It would seem that Posner’s judgment continues to be demented by a severe case of SCOTUS envy. Just a few quick observations:

1. Who knows what Posner means by “qualified”? If he means to incorporate a justice’s jurisprudence into the assessment, it’s strange that he would select Justice Breyer and Justice Ginsburg as the two best of a motley lot. Justice Kagan, for example, would seem closer to Ginsburg than Breyer is. (In a book eight years ago—which I negatively reviewed here—Posner called Justice Breyer a “bricoleur” and an “intermittent pragmatist whose pragmatism is heavily leavened with liberal political commitments.”)

If you look at qualifications apart from jurisprudence, many of the current justices are, by any ordinary measure, very well qualified.

2. With his characteristic sloppiness, Posner is wrong to say that only one of the current justices “had been in a trial courtroom.” Justice Alito was a United States Attorney for some 2-1/2 years, and Justice Sotomayor was an assistant district attorney for some five years and a federal district judge for six years.

If it’s “ridiculous to have an appellate judge who doesn’t have trial experience,” Posner should never have accepted his seat. Posner evidently imagines that he has compensated for his deficiency by occasionally sitting by designation as a trial judge.

3. I also find it strange that Posner regards only Ginsburg and Breyer opinions as “readable” and “sometimes quite elegant eloquent.” Limiting myself to the liberal side of the Court (lest I be thought to be indulging my ideological preferences), I think that Kagan’s opinions fare quite well compared to Ginsburg’s and Breyer’s

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

Basta La Vista, Baby

Dear Reader (And especially Martha McSally’s dog), As I often note, I increasingly tend to see the political scene as a scripted reality show in which the writers don’t flesh out the dialogue so much as move characters into weird, wacky, confrontational, or embarrassing positions. It’s a lot like The ... Read More
Education

Betsy DeVos Strikes a Blow for the Constitution

The Department of Education has issued its long-awaited proposed regulations reforming sexual-assault adjudications on college campus. Not only will these rules restore basic due process and fairness to college tribunals, but they also — given how basic the changes are — highlight just how ridiculous ... Read More
Politics & Policy

ABC News Makes a Serious Mistake

Today, across Twitter, I began to see a number of people condemning the Trump administration (and Betsy DeVos, specifically) for imposing a new definition of sexual assault on campus so strict that it would force women to prove that they were so harassed that they'd been chased off campus and couldn't return. ... Read More