Bench Memos

Re: Judge Posner’s Weak Mea Culpa

In my post last Friday in which I wondered why anyone should credit Judge Posner’s new position on voter-ID laws, I referred to, but explicitly passed over, some “cross-cutting complications” on whether a judge’s confession of his own judicial errors is welcome. In an excellent column today, the Washington Post’s Charles Lane explores one of those complications and concludes that Posner’s comments violate the Code of Conduct for Federal Judges:

His comments amount to intervention in a live political, and legal, issue, cloaked — whether or not he intends it — in the authority of his judicial office. Indeed, his comments carry the authority of someone who previously considered the matter in court and has now switched sides. It’s as if Harry Blackmun, the author of Roe v. Wade, came out against abortion rights while still a justice.

It doesn’t help matters that Posner’s confession of error contained a gratuitious slap at the losing lawyers or that it hinged on a vague notion of how the Indiana law, and others like it, are now “regarded.” As it happens, opinion polls consistently show that voter ID laws are popular among voters of both parties.

I don’t think that Lane’s analysis applies to comments by a judge that repeat what he has said in his judicial opinions.

(On the dubious merits of Posner’s change of mind, read Hans von Spakovsky’s NRO essay from last Friday, “Right the First Time.”)

Most Popular

White House

A Thought on the Trump-DOJ Scandal

We Americans have a habit of putting fundamental social and political questions out of our minds by turning them into technical legal questions. This tendency is one of the forces at work in the increasingly dramatic showdown between the Department of Justice and the President of the United States. There is ... Read More

School Shootings and the Incentives of Violence

Today’s Morning Jolt discusses school shootings and the common difficulties of the teenage years, and I thought of another aspect that I forgot to include -- the degree to which our society, in its reaction to violence, inadvertently rewards that violence. Every teenager wants attention, to be recognized, to ... Read More
NR Marketing

Down the Home Stretch

Our Spring 2018 Webathon winds up this week. El jefe, Mr. Lowry, makes the case, wonderfully, for your participating, even at this final stage. In case you need some visual inspiration, we’ll use this horse race image from the novel Ben Hur (you'll remember the 1959 movie version starred the late NR ... Read More