Bench Memos

Re: Seventh Circuit Ruling Against HHS Mandate

In her account of the Seventh Circuit’s ruling, the everunreliable Dorothy Samuels of the New York Times asserts:

Among the federal circuit courts that have spoken so far, three – the Seventh, Tenth and D.C. Circuits – have ratified the dangerous view that secular, profit-making private employers can claim a religious exemption from the Affordable Care Act….

If Samuels is using the phrase “private employers” to mean corporations, then she is incompetently misstating the holding of the D.C. Circuit (and she is also overstating the holdings of the Seventh and Tenth Circuits, which are limited to closely held corporations).

If, on the other hand, she is using the phrase “private employers” to include the individual owners of closely held corporations, then she is treating the corporations as the alter egos of those individual owners—in which case it ought to follow very easily that the individual owners can pursue relief in their individual capacities for any burdens imposed on their religious liberty in how they operate their corporations.

As for Samuels’s tendentious phrasing: The plaintiffs in those (and other) cases are seeking to enforce their rights under the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act, not to claim some amorphous “religious exemption” from Obamacare. And, even on the (dubious) assumption that there is a compelling governmental interest in marginally increasing access to contraceptives, there is nothing “dangerous” about vindicating the employers’ rights, as the government has ample alternative means of providing contraceptives to their employees. (See part 3 of my law-review essay on RFRA and the HHS mandate.)

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

The Joys of Heterogeneity

The temporary shutdown of parts of the federal government is a good argument for the permanent shutdown of parts of the federal government. When one of his colleagues voiced frustration with the slow pace of conservative reform in the 1990s, Newt Gingrich replied, “Rome wasn’t burned in a day.” That’s ... Read More
Politics & Policy

The Elite Convergence

EDITOR’S NOTE: The following is Jonah Goldberg’s weekly “news”letter, the G-File. Subscribe here to get the G-File delivered to your inbox on Fridays. Dear Reader (Even those otherwise occupied by their doorbell love), Like Jeffrey Epstein when the new Sears Junior Miss catalogue comes out, I ... Read More

Referenda Delenda Est

"In my country the people can do as they like, although it often happens that they don't like what they have done."      -- Winston Churchill, 1946 London During the Second World War, as U.S. power was eclipsing Britain's, Harold Macmillan, a future prime minister, reportedly said, "These Americans ... Read More