Bench Memos

A Really Harsh Critic of Justice Thurgood Marshall

During the Kagan hearing, Republicans on the Senate Judiciary Committee took a pounding from the usual suspects for daring to suggest that Thurgood Marshall wasn’t a model justice.  Never mind that Kagan herself tried to run away from Marshall’s judicial vision.

Well, it turns out that someone else who didn’t think much of Marshall’s performance on the Court (though for different reasons than those of Republican senators) was Justice William J. Brennan Jr., Marshall’s longtime liberal colleague.  According to a very interesting forthcoming biography of Brennan—Justice Brennan:  Liberal Champion, by Seth Stern and Stephen Wermiel—which draws on more than sixty recorded interviews that Brennan had with one of the authors over a period of five years (and which I have read in advance copy):

Few understood just how much Marshall’s performance on the Court came to disappoint Brennan.  It was a topic Brennan did not like to talk about with anyone.  Brennan believed that Marshall had never gotten his due for all he had achieved as the NAACP LDF’s chief lawyer…. [p. 431 (emphasis added)]

Still, Brennan privately wondered what had come of the skilled lawyer who so dazzled him at oral arguments.  “What the hell happened when he came on the Court, I’m not sure, but he doesn’t seem to have had the same interest,” Brennan said [in a 1988 interview].  “He has some areas where he does and when he really gets involved with a case … he does an absolutely superb job.  But when he’s not interested, whatever I do, that’s all right with him.”  As best as Brennan could tell, Marshall had simply given up, convinced that all he had worked for as a civil rights lawyer was now coming undone.… [p. 431 (emphasis added)]

Brennan did resent Marshall for not carrying his share of the workload as they fought to preserve the gains of the Warren Court.  The death penalty was one of the few areas of the law where Marshall was engaged and displayed some of his old passion.  Yet here, too, Marshall disappointed Brennan.… [p. 433]

Most Popular


Stick a Fork in O’Rourke

If, as I wrote last week here, Joe Biden may save the Democratic party from a horrible debacle at the polls next year, Beto O’Rourke may be doing the whole process a good turn now. Biden, despite his efforts to masquerade as the vanguard of what is now called progressivism, is politically sane and, if ... Read More

In Defense of the Electoral College

Senator Elizabeth Warren has joined a growing chorus within the Democratic party in calling for the abolition of the Electoral College. Speaking at a forum in Mississippi on Monday night, Warren said that she hoped to ensure that “every vote matters” and proposed that “the way we can make that happen is ... Read More

Ivy-League Schools Wither

A  number of liberal bastions are daily being hammered — especially the elite university and Silicon Valley. A Yale and a Stanford, or Facebook and Google, assume — for the most part rightly — that each is so loudly progressive that the public, federal and state regulators, and politicians would of ... Read More
National Security & Defense

In Defense of the Iraq War

Today is the 16th anniversary of the invasion of Iraq, and Twitter is alive with condemnations of the conflict -- countered by precious few defenses. Yet I believed the Iraq War was just and proper in 2003, and I still believe that today. When Donald Trump condemned the war during the 2015 primary campaign and ... Read More