Bench Memos

Law & the Courts

Reinhardt No Longer Votes from the Grave?

A follow-up to this post of mine: Two weeks after a divided Ninth Circuit panel issued a ruling in which Judge Stephen Reinhardt, who died in March, was deemed to have cast the deciding vote, a “reconstituted panel”—with Judge Susan Graber replacing Reinhardt—has withdrawn the ruling so that it can “confer” on how to proceed.

I’m glad to see this step but would be curious as to the reason for the panel’s action. Ninth Circuit chief judge Sidney Thomas, author of the original panel opinion, had previously asserted—implausibly, for the reasons stated in my initial post—that Reinhardt “formally concurred in the majority opinion prior to his death.” Has Thomas now abandoned that assertion? What is the principle that now governs the Ninth Circuit on actions by dead judges? Will the Ninth Circuit also withdraw its en banc ruling in Rizo v. Yovino, in which Reinhardt was credited as the author, and decisive vote in support, of the en banc majority opinion issued eleven days after his death?

Most Popular

White House

Mueller’s Got Nothing

The revelations of the last few days are, though disguised, the crash in ignominy of the Robert Mueller putsch. But they are far from the end of the story. While the sire of the Mueller hit-squad assault, former FBI director James Comey, declared 245 times at last Friday’s House Judiciary Committee hearing that ... Read More
World

The Dangers of Asymmetry

It is strange how suddenly a skeptical Wall Street, CEOs, and even university and think-tank policy analysts are now jumping on the once-taboo Trump bandwagon on China: that if something is not done to stop China’s planned trajectory to global hegemony, based on its repudiation of the entire post-war trade and ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Donald Trump and the Imperial Presidency

As the writer of a weekly political column in the Age of Trump (ugh), I have lately been wondering if, bereft of an idea, I might just write TRUMP over and over again, 750 times, and get people to read it. An idle thought — perhaps. After all, this was the week when my Twitter timeline was full of mainstream ... Read More