Bench Memos

Law & the Courts

Reinhardt No Longer Votes from the Grave?

A follow-up to this post of mine: Two weeks after a divided Ninth Circuit panel issued a ruling in which Judge Stephen Reinhardt, who died in March, was deemed to have cast the deciding vote, a “reconstituted panel”—with Judge Susan Graber replacing Reinhardt—has withdrawn the ruling so that it can “confer” on how to proceed.

I’m glad to see this step but would be curious as to the reason for the panel’s action. Ninth Circuit chief judge Sidney Thomas, author of the original panel opinion, had previously asserted—implausibly, for the reasons stated in my initial post—that Reinhardt “formally concurred in the majority opinion prior to his death.” Has Thomas now abandoned that assertion? What is the principle that now governs the Ninth Circuit on actions by dead judges? Will the Ninth Circuit also withdraw its en banc ruling in Rizo v. Yovino, in which Reinhardt was credited as the author, and decisive vote in support, of the en banc majority opinion issued eleven days after his death?

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

Demagoguery Is Not Leadership

The government of Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern in New Zealand has, with the support of the opposition, decided to enact fundamental changes in the nation’s firearms laws less than a week after the massacre at two Christchurch mosques. This is the opposite of leadership. It is also an example of why ... Read More
White House

The Media’s Disgrace

There will soon enough be an effort to memory-hole it, but the media coverage of the Russia investigation was abysmal and self-discrediting — obsessive and hysterical, often suggesting that the smoking gun was right around the corner, sometimes supporting its hoped-for result with erroneous, too-good-to-check ... Read More
Politics & Policy

What Was Trump So Annoyed About?

One of the stranger arguments that I heard throughout the Mueller saga -- and am hearing today, now that it's turned out to be a dud -- is that Donald Trump's irritation with the process was unreasonable and counterproductive. This tweet, from CNN's Chris Cilizza, is a nice illustration of the genre: Donald ... Read More
White House

Our Long National Hysteria 

Our long national hysteria may not be over, but at least it should — by rights — be diminished. Robert Mueller delivered his long-awaited report on Friday, and Attorney General William Barr just released his summary of the findings. They completely vindicate President Trump regarding the allegation that ... Read More