Bench Memos

Scalia at St Thomas: On Judicial Appointments Politics

I wrote a short piece for The Public Discourse, just posted, entitled “Scalia at St. Thomas: Closing Arguments.”   Last fall, Justice Antonin Scalia visited the University of St. Thomas School of Law, where I teach, and had some extraordinarily interesting things to say – some that now seem poignantly insightful and memorable, and some that were just plain witty and fun. 

An excerpt concerning judicial appointments politics, about Scalia’s response to a student question :

An awkward question at the time that seems positively poignant now: So many of the justices are getting old. What did he think about the likelihood of future appointments to the Court? Scalia responded in stride—and with seemingly prophetic insight. Presidents, when making appointments, tend to ask, “How will this benefit me?” He seemed to call for more serious consideration of the Constitution in making and confirming—or not confirming—nominations to the Supreme Court. (This despite the fact that, in 1986, Scalia successfully dodged all substantive questions—the last nominee to stonewall the senators completely.)

Historically, Scalia grumbled, “Republicans have not cared that much.” In marked contrast, “Democrats care.” They have an explicitly pro-Roe v. Wadel itmus test. Republicans’ litmus test is “‘We do not have a litmus test’! Now who’s going to win that?!” Republicans’ abdication of constitutional principle and debate made absolutely no strategic sense to Scalia.

The story with which I close the piece – a story Scalia told on himself as a young student – is particularly memorable.  

Michael Stokes Paulsen — Mr. Paulsen is a professor of law and distinguished university chairman at the University of St. Thomas, in Minneapolis.

Most Popular

Film & TV

Netflix Debuts Its Obama Manifesto

This week’s widespread media blitz heralding Netflix’s broadcast of its first Obama-endorsed presentation, American Factory, was more than synchronicity. It felt as though U.S. publicists and journalists collectively exhaled their relief at finally regaining the bully pulpit. Reviews of American Factory, a ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Capital versus Tucker Carlson

Advertisers do not advertise on Tucker Carlson’s show to endorse the views of Tucker Carlson. They advertise on his show for the same reason they advertise elsewhere: a captive audience — in Tucker’s case, the second-largest one in cable news — might spare thirty seconds of attention that will, they hope, ... Read More
Natural Law

Are Your Sexual Preferences Transphobic?

Last year, a study exploring “transgender exclusion from the world of dating” was published in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships. Of nearly 1,000 participants, the overwhelming majority, 87.5 percent, irrespective of their sexual preference, said they would not consider dating a trans person, ... Read More