Bench Memos

Seventh Circuit Ruling Against HHS Mandate

Having been out, I’m only now highlighting this important Seventh Circuit ruling (in Korte v. Sebelius) from late last Thursday against the HHS contraception mandate. The ruling comes in two cases consolidated on appeal, each involving a Catholic family and its closely held business corporation.

The Seventh Circuit panel was divided. The impressive majority opinion by Judge Diane Sykes (joined by Judge Joel Flaum) rules that the plaintiff individuals and corporations are entitled to preliminary injunction relief against the HHS mandate. Among other things, Judge Sykes rules that (1) the individuals have standing to challenge the HHS mandate (slip op. at 22-25; the dissenter agrees on this narrow point—see slip op. at 78); (2) closely held, for-profit corporations are “persons” within the meaning of the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act (slip op. at 35-54); (3) the HHS mandate substantially burdens the plaintiffs’ exercise of religion (slip op. at 54-60); and (4) even on the assumption that the HHS mandate furthers a compelling governmental interest, it does not do via the means that is least restrictive of plaintiffs’ religious liberty (slip op. at 60-64).

Judge Ilana Rovner’s 90-page dissent vigorously takes issue with the last three points.

When I have had time to digest the opinions, I may offer some more extensive commentary.

Again, cases involving challenges to the HHS mandate are already pending before the Supreme Court, and review is almost certain to be granted in at least one of those cases (with the others held).

For what it’s worth: Judge Sykes is a Bush 43 appointee; Judge Flaum is a Reagan appointee; and Judge Rovner is a Bush 41 appointee.

Most Popular


Yes We Kanye

Kanye West is unpredictable and not terribly coherent and has generated his share of infamous and insufferably narcissistic behavior -- “Bush doesn’t care about black people” and “Imma let you finish” come to mind. Color me skeptical that it’s a consequential victory for the Right now that West is ... Read More

Poll Finds Nevada Voters Support School-Choice Programs

According to an April poll, a large number of Nevada voters support school-choice programs. The poll, conducted by Nevada Independent/Mellman, found that 70 percent of voters support a proposal for a special-needs Education Savings Account and 59 percent support expanding the funding for the current tax-credit ... Read More

Is Journalism School Worth It?

Clarence Darrow dropped out of law school after just a year, figuring that he would learn what he needed to know about legal practice faster if he were actually doing it than sitting in classrooms. (Today, that wouldn't be possible, thanks to licensing requirements.) The same thing is true in other fields -- ... Read More

Wednesday Links

Today is ANZAC Day, the anniversary of the Battle of Gallipoli: Here's some history, a documentary, and a Lego re-enactment. How DNA Can Lead to Wrongful Convictions: Labs today can identify people with DNA from just a handful of cells, but a handful of cells can easily migrate. The 19th-century art of ... Read More

Microscopic Dots. Let’s Look at Them.

Stuart E. Eizenstat has written a big book on the Carter presidency. (Eizenstat was Carter’s chief domestic-policy adviser. He also had a substantial hand in foreign affairs.) I have reviewed the book for the forthcoming NR. Eizenstat tells the story of a meeting between President Carter and Andrei Gromyko, the ... Read More