Bench Memos

A Solution in Search of a Problem

Over at The Corner, there has been some discussion of Matthew Schmitz’s article from Wednesday titled “Fears of ‘Creeping Sharia.’”  Among those weighing in have been Andrew Bostom, Andy McCarthy (passing on something by David Yerushalmi), and Ramesh Ponnuru, while Mr. Schmitz has ably defended himself. (No, dear reader, I don’t think I can supply you with all the links. You know how to use this interweb thingy.)

I am squarely with Matt Schmitz and Ramesh on this one.  This “creeping Sharia” phenomenon supposedly going on in American courts is not even happening, even according to the “report” most cited by the notion’s proponents.  In May 2011, the Center for Security Policy published a 635-page report titled “Shariah Law and American State Courts.”  Most of the document is devoted to reproducing reported cases.  With much hoopla, the authors announce that at least 50 cases in American state courts demonstrate the “creeping Sharia” problem.

But helpfully–for their critics, not for themselves–the authors give a precis at the front of the report of their “Top 20 Cases” that should alarm us.  The decisions in question range from the late 1970s to the 2000s.  And it turns out that, on their own analysis, we can conclude that just seven–yes, seven–of their “Top 20 Cases” were decisions in which Sharia (or other foreign) principles were enforced in any way whatsoever.

In one 1996 case, “comity” was extended to a Pakistani court’s child custody ruling.  In a 1978 case, a Pakistani divorce was recognized in an American court.  In a third case, in 1984, “Syrian Christian law” principles were recognized in a state court.  In a fourth case in 2004, a contract in which the parties in a business together had agreed to “Islamic arbitration” was honored.  In a fifth, a 1986 California ruling upheld a “Lebanese Sharia” court’s child custody order. In the sixth (my favorite), two American companies were able to take advantage of a Saudi counterpart by employing Saudi legal principles in a Delaware court.  And in the seventh (or maybe this one’s my favorite), a wife who was done wrong was able to take advantage of a Sharia-principle prenuptial agreement when she divorced her husband in America.

That’s all there is to the Center for Security Policy’s “Top 20 Cases.”  Thirty-five years’ worth of American law, and we have a whopping seven cases in which some “foreign law” was honored (not even Sharia in every case), and not enough information even to tell if something truly unjust happened in any of the seven.  In the other thirteen cases, Sharia-law principles were rejected either at trial or on appeal.  Some Top 20.

I can’t get worked up about a problem that is so unproblematic.  I can take alarm at ill-considered attacks on the religious freedom of our Muslim fellow citizens, however.

Most Popular

U.S.

Zoomers and the Constitution

A 2019 study by the Pew Research Center compared generational views on key social and political issues, focusing on the similarities between Millennials and Generation Z. The topics probed include race relations, diversity, climate change, capitalism, socialism, and the role of government. This last item, ... Read More
U.S.

Zoomers and the Constitution

A 2019 study by the Pew Research Center compared generational views on key social and political issues, focusing on the similarities between Millennials and Generation Z. The topics probed include race relations, diversity, climate change, capitalism, socialism, and the role of government. This last item, ... Read More

The Consequences of Biden

If you have decided that another four years of Donald Trump would be intolerable, and the prospect of four more years of the dysfunctional Trump circus in the White House fills you with dread, fine. But approach the prospects of a Joe Biden presidency with clear eyes and no illusions. Electing Biden would move ... Read More

The Consequences of Biden

If you have decided that another four years of Donald Trump would be intolerable, and the prospect of four more years of the dysfunctional Trump circus in the White House fills you with dread, fine. But approach the prospects of a Joe Biden presidency with clear eyes and no illusions. Electing Biden would move ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Enough of ‘Orange Man Bad’

The Trump era has brought its own unique vocabulary: Never Trump, anti-anti-Trump, Deep State, QAnon, “The Resistance,” Podbros, Trump Derangement Syndrome, and of course, MAGA, to name just a few. But by far the most useless phrase to emerge over the last few years is “Orange Man Bad.” If you follow ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Enough of ‘Orange Man Bad’

The Trump era has brought its own unique vocabulary: Never Trump, anti-anti-Trump, Deep State, QAnon, “The Resistance,” Podbros, Trump Derangement Syndrome, and of course, MAGA, to name just a few. But by far the most useless phrase to emerge over the last few years is “Orange Man Bad.” If you follow ... Read More
Media

How American Journalism Died

In 2017, the liberal Shorenstein Center on Media, Politics, and Public Policy at Harvard University found that 93 percent of CNN’s coverage of the Trump administration was negative. The center found similarly negative Trump coverage at other major news outlets. The election year 2020 has only accelerated ... Read More
Media

How American Journalism Died

In 2017, the liberal Shorenstein Center on Media, Politics, and Public Policy at Harvard University found that 93 percent of CNN’s coverage of the Trump administration was negative. The center found similarly negative Trump coverage at other major news outlets. The election year 2020 has only accelerated ... Read More
Elections

Is the Biden Campaign Struggling?

On the menu today: a long, long list of Democrats warning that the Biden campaign may not be as strong as it looks in key states and among key demographics; another former White House staffer comes out and denounces the president, offering a hard lesson about how personnel is policy; and a long look at the ... Read More
Elections

Is the Biden Campaign Struggling?

On the menu today: a long, long list of Democrats warning that the Biden campaign may not be as strong as it looks in key states and among key demographics; another former White House staffer comes out and denounces the president, offering a hard lesson about how personnel is policy; and a long look at the ... Read More