Bench Memos

Sotomayor Hearing—Coburn’s Round 1

Judge Sotomayor repeated that Casey reaffirmed the core holding of Roe, but she was unable and unwilling to say how that holding applies in hypothetical circumstances that Senator Coburn posited.  Isn’t it virtually meaningless to mean to say that Casey is “settled law” if all that it establishes is the amorphous and manipulable “undue burden” test?  Sotomayor asserted, “We don’t make policy choices.”  But doesn’t the “undue burden” test call for a pure policy choice?  Justice Ginsburg sure seems to recognize that fact:  “I’m not a big fan of these tests. I think the court uses them as a label that accommodates the result it wants to reach.”

If I heard her correctly, Sotomayor also failed to recognize the viability line that Casey drew.

Coburn revisited Sotomayor’s views on foreign law.  Sotomayor again gave a thoroughly confusing answer resting on her peculiar and incomprehensible understanding of the word “use.”

Most Popular


The Democrats Made Two Joe Biden Miscalculations

I think it's safe to say that there are many, many progressive Democrats who are more than a little surprised -- and a lot chagrined -- at Joe Biden's polling dominance. Look at FiveThirtyEight's polling roundup. Aside from a few high and low outliers, he leads the race by a solid 20 points (at least). Even ... Read More

Our Modern Satyricon

Sometime around a.d. 60, in the age of Emperor Nero, a Roman court insider named Gaius Petronius wrote a satirical Latin novel, The Satyricon, about moral corruption in Imperial Rome. The novel’s general landscape was Rome’s transition from an agrarian republic to a globalized multicultural ... Read More