Bench Memos

When Is a Recess Not a Recess?

It’s not often that I can come off as more pro-executive than John Yoo, but this morning on Bill Bennett’s radio show, I was taking rather the opposite line from Yoo’s Corner post regarding President Obama’s recess appointments.  I was then under the influence of John Elwood’s very persuasive post at the Volokh Conspiracy.  If you read both Yoo and Elwood, you’ll get the arguments framed pretty nicely on both sides.

The whole business strikes me as illustrative of the way our checks and balances give both branches of government opportunities to behave badly.  Presidents appoint high executive officers with the Senate’s approval.  If presidents behave responsibly, they make timely nominations when the Senate is in session, and take it on the chin manfully if their nominees are defeated fair and square.  The Senate behaves responsibly when it takes up nominations in a timely way, vets the nominees fairly and expeditiously, and proceeds to an up-or-down vote: no holds, no failure to schedule hearings, no filibusters unless the process has been unduly rushed without a chance for decent debate.

Throw a little partisanship in the mix, and we get the mess we’re in.  The president wants people in office whose confirmation is controversial, so (in at least a couple of the current cases) waits until the Senate is on the eve of adjourning its current session.  Other would-be officials may have had their nominations languishing in the Senate thanks to dilatory or obstructive tactics by senators.  So the president invokes the recess appointment power, which was placed in the Constitution in expectation of a congressional calendar that had the Senate out of session more of the year than it was in.  The modern use of the recess appointment was not what the framers had in mind, but so be it: the departure of the Senate at the conclusion of its annual session presents the president’s opportunity.  The latest innovation, apparently dating only from the George W. Bush years, is the “pro forma session” in which the Senate “technically” holds back from adjourning its annual session by sending a lone senator into the chamber once in every three days to pretend it’s still there.  I’m not altogether persuaded by John Yoo that this is kosher.  He argues that it is up to the Senate, not the president, to decide when it is and is not in recess.  But as John Elwood points out, there can be some serious risk to the proper functioning of the executive branch if the president cannot fill offices, and thereby see that agencies perform their duties, because the Senate pretends to be in session but has no quorum present to conduct any business such as considering his nominations.  Neither side’s claims, taken to their logical conclusion, make for a satisfactory outcome where constitutional responsibility is concerned.

As I said, plenty of bad behavior all around.  But this is not abnormal, in a government founded on the insight that “men are not angels,” as James Madison said in the Federalist.  So I can’t get my outrage meter up past about 3 or 4 over what President Obama has done with these appointments.

Matthew J. Franck — Matthew J. Franck is the Director of the William E. and Carol G. Simon Center on Religion and the Constitution at the Witherspoon Institute in Princeton, New Jersey.

Most Popular


If Amy Wax Is Wrong, Let’s See the Data

Regarding the kerfuffle Jason Richwine addressed here earlier, the economist Glenn Loury has posted an impassioned plea to his Facebook page. Loury, you may recall, hosts the video blog where Wax made her controversial claim that black students at Penn Law School rarely graduate in the top half of the ... Read More
Politics & Policy

San Francisco Bans Fur Sales

San Francisco has banned the sale of fur. From the CBS-SF story: San Francisco has become the first major U.S. city to ban the sale of fur clothing and products. Tuesday, the Board of Supervisors unanimously approved a measure that prohibits the sale of fur clothes, accessories, even souvenirs in stores and ... Read More

For the First Time in Weeks, Relief Sweeps over Austin

Making the click-through worthwhile: The Austin bomber is done in by one of his own devices; some new numbers suggest that a small but significant portion of Trump voters are tiring of the chaos and aren’t showing up to support other Republicans in 2018; and the mixed news for conservatives coming out of the ... Read More

The Baleful Effect of #MeToo on Campus

Remember the series of hurricanes that pounded the Caribbean last summer? Something like that has been occurring on college campuses, as they're hit by one destructive mania after another: diversity, Title IX, anti-speech protests. Now it's the #MeToo Movement. In this Martin Center article, British academic ... Read More
Politics & Policy

A Time for Choosing

This year’s Conservative Political Action Conference was controversial. Invitations to European nationalist populists such as Nigel Farage and Marion Maréchal-Le Pen (the niece of Marine Le Pen) caused many longtime conservatives to question whether they still belong to the conservative movement. Vocal critics ... Read More