Bench Memos

Who’s Being Partisan?

ThinkProgress’s Ian Millhiser has a tiresomely tendentious essay lambasting Justice Alito as “The Most Partisan Justice.” Millhiser draws a sensible distinction between someone whose “decisions are driven by a fairly coherent judicial philosophy” (though he attaches the pejorative label “ideologue” to Justice Thomas in crediting him with this approach) and someone who simply reaches partisan results. But rather than try to give an example or two (beyond his wildly mistaken account of Hobby Lobby) of instances in which Alito has supposedly been unfaithful to his judicial philosophy in order to reach partisan results, Millhiser resorts to statistical flim-flam.

For Millhiser, Justice Ginsburg can’t be labeled a partisan because on one occasion in her 22 years on the Court, she “broke with her fellow liberals in a case brought by unions seeking to make it easier for them to collect funds.” Never mind that virtually no one has ever heard of the case, that her vote was unnecessary for the outcome, and that she concurred only in part and in the judgment.

By contrast, Millhiser won’t count to Alito’s credit the “handful of cases where Alito joined a 5 justice majority [sic] that included one other conservative and three liberals.” What Millhiser’s confusing phrasing (“joined a 5 justice majority”) seems designed to obscure is that Alito provided the decisive fifth vote in those cases. Further, in the one case that I quickly found that evidently is supposed to fit Millhiser’s description, the so-called “other conservative” was Justice Kennedy (who is no conservative).

For a vastly more intelligent account of Justice Alito’s decisionmaking—one that emphasizes how distinctive his judicial approach is from that of the “three other conservative justices with whom he is generally lumped​” and how that approach has led him to stand apart from them in major First Amendment cases—see Adam White’s 2011 Weekly Standard essay, “The Burkean Justice.”

Most Popular

Law & the Courts

The Kavanaugh Court

If Justice Barrett votes as her mentor Justice Scalia did, she will be part of an ascendant conservative majority on the Supreme Court. What kinds of decisions can we expect from this majority? Short answer: Ask Brett Kavanaugh. Contrary to how journalists frame each seat change on the Court, comparing the new ... Read More
Law & the Courts

The Kavanaugh Court

If Justice Barrett votes as her mentor Justice Scalia did, she will be part of an ascendant conservative majority on the Supreme Court. What kinds of decisions can we expect from this majority? Short answer: Ask Brett Kavanaugh. Contrary to how journalists frame each seat change on the Court, comparing the new ... Read More

Trump vs. Biden: A Rundown

One week out, the contrasts are worth assessing. Foreign policy Biden so far has issued no substantive critique of Trump’s foreign policy other than banalities that Trump’s comportment and unpredictability have offended allies and tarnished America’s reputation. But who exactly, according to Biden, is ... Read More

Trump vs. Biden: A Rundown

One week out, the contrasts are worth assessing. Foreign policy Biden so far has issued no substantive critique of Trump’s foreign policy other than banalities that Trump’s comportment and unpredictability have offended allies and tarnished America’s reputation. But who exactly, according to Biden, is ... Read More
Elections

The Only Middle Finger Available

If Donald Trump wins a second term, it will be an unmistakable countercultural statement in a year when progressives have otherwise worked their will across the culture. After months and months of statues toppling and riots in American cities and a crime wave and woke virtue-signaling from professional sports ... Read More
Elections

The Only Middle Finger Available

If Donald Trump wins a second term, it will be an unmistakable countercultural statement in a year when progressives have otherwise worked their will across the culture. After months and months of statues toppling and riots in American cities and a crime wave and woke virtue-signaling from professional sports ... Read More

The Pollster Who Thinks Trump Is Ahead

The polling aggregator on the website RealClearPolitics shows the margin in polls led by Joe Biden in a blue font and the ones led by Donald Trump in red. For a while, the battleground states have tended to be uniformly blue, except for polls conducted by the Trafalgar Group. If you are a firm believer only in ... Read More

The Pollster Who Thinks Trump Is Ahead

The polling aggregator on the website RealClearPolitics shows the margin in polls led by Joe Biden in a blue font and the ones led by Donald Trump in red. For a while, the battleground states have tended to be uniformly blue, except for polls conducted by the Trafalgar Group. If you are a firm believer only in ... Read More
Law & the Courts

Some Counterfactual Thinking

Election Day is one week away. Can you believe it? On the menu today: contemplating what would be different, and what would be the same, if Ruth Bader Ginsburg had retired in 2013 instead of staying on the Court until her death earlier this year; a couple of flubbed words on the campaign trail; yes, people really ... Read More
Law & the Courts

Some Counterfactual Thinking

Election Day is one week away. Can you believe it? On the menu today: contemplating what would be different, and what would be the same, if Ruth Bader Ginsburg had retired in 2013 instead of staying on the Court until her death earlier this year; a couple of flubbed words on the campaign trail; yes, people really ... Read More
Law & the Courts

Whose Seat?

Amy Coney Barrett is confirmed. And I think there are two little things to say about it. The first is that we very likely have in Barrett the true successor to Antonin Scalia on the Court. Barrett clerked for Scalia and her articulation of his philosophy is probably the most faithful on the court. Justices ... Read More
Law & the Courts

Whose Seat?

Amy Coney Barrett is confirmed. And I think there are two little things to say about it. The first is that we very likely have in Barrett the true successor to Antonin Scalia on the Court. Barrett clerked for Scalia and her articulation of his philosophy is probably the most faithful on the court. Justices ... Read More