The Eighth Amendment and Sex-Reassignment Surgery

Last Friday, in Kosilek v. Spencer, a divided panel of the First Circuit affirmed a district-court order that holds that the Eighth Amendment’s bar on cruel and unusual punishments requires the Massachusetts prison system to provide sex-reassignment surgery to a prisoner. The particular prisoner, whose legal name is now Michelle Kosilek, “was born and still is anatomically male” but, suffering from gender-identity disorder, has long believed himself to be “a woman cruelly trapped in a man’s body.”

Medical testimony before the district court was divided on the question whether sex-reassignment surgery was medically necessary for Kosilek. Several of Kosilek’s medical experts testified that it was medically necessary, but the state’s expert, Dr. Schmidt, disagreed. The district judge then appointed his own expert, Dr. Levine. Dr. Levine opined that the conflicting medical positions “reflect the current polarities within psychiatry” and that Dr. Schmidt’s view was “within prudent professional community standards.” But he later provided testimony that the district judge construed as less favorable to Dr. Schmidt’s position. The district judge ended up holding that sex-reassignment surgery was necessary for Kosilek and that Dr. Schmidt’s recommended course of treatment did not meet prudent professional standards.

The panel majority (opinion by O. Rogeriee Thompson, joined by William Kayatta—both Obama appointees) and Reagan appointee Juan Torruella’s dissent differ on several points, including the appropriate standard of review of the district court’s conclusion that sex-reassignment surgery was the only appropriate treatment for Kosilek. The panel majority reviewed the conclusion only to determine whether it was “clearly erroneous” and, given the “diametrically opposed opinions,” found that it was not. Judge Torruella, by contrast, undertook a “more searching” and “holistic” review, credited the initial report by the court-appointed expert, Dr. Levine, and faulted the district judge’s assertion that Dr. Levine had later changed his opinion. (Please note that I’m summarizing 118 pages of opinions in three paragraphs.)

If the bottom-line ruling strikes you (as it strikes me) as crazy, there are multiple possible sources of the craziness. It might, indeed, come from the district judge’s failure to accord enough deference to the prison officials, together with the panel majority’s according too much deference to the district judge. Or it might come from current medical opinion’s apparent acceptance of sex-reassignment surgery as a legitimate treatment. (According to this Boston Globe article, though, “no surgeon in Massachusetts [has] expressed a willingness to take on the task.”). Or it might come from the Supreme Court’s broader Eighth Amendment standards for medical care for prisoners. Or perhaps a mix of all of the above.

Most Popular

U.S.

The Gun-Control Debate Could Break America

Last night, the nation witnessed what looked a lot like an extended version of the famous “two minutes hate” from George Orwell’s novel 1984. During a CNN town hall on gun control, a furious crowd of Americans jeered at two conservatives, Marco Rubio and Dana Loesch, who stood in defense of the Second ... Read More
Film & TV

Why We Can’t Have Wakanda

SPOILERS AHEAD Black Panther is a really good movie that lives up to the hype in just about every way. Surely someone at Marvel Studios had an early doubt, reading the script and thinking: “Wait, we’re going to have hundreds of African warriors in brightly colored tribal garb, using ancient weapons, ... Read More
Law & the Courts

Obstruction Confusions

In his Lawfare critique of one of my several columns about the purported obstruction case against President Trump, Gabriel Schoenfeld loses me — as I suspect he will lose others — when he says of himself, “I do not think I am Trump-deranged.” Gabe graciously expresses fondness for me, and the feeling is ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Students’ Anti-Gun Views

Are children innocents or are they leaders? Are teenagers fully autonomous decision-makers, or are they lumps of mental clay, still being molded by unfolding brain development? The Left seems to have a particularly hard time deciding these days. Take, for example, the high-school students from Parkland, ... Read More