The Propriety of the Preemptive-Strike Book Review

Jason Lee Steorts, NR’s managing editor, posted a long discussion on the Corner, early this morning, of the forthcoming book What Is Marriage? Man and Woman: A Defense, by Sherif Girgis, Ryan T. Anderson, and Robert P. George.  Steorts read proofs of the book over the weekend, and reiterates criticisms of the authors’ previously published arguments that he made twice here months ago at NRO, with a bit of new criticism thrown in.

I think there is something improper about publishing what amounts to an extended critique of a book, three weeks before its publication date (and therefore still presumably under some embargo, stated or implied), when readers cannot readily consult the book for themselves.  (I couldn’t even find the book on the publisher’s website this morning, but Amazon will let you pre-order it.)  I hope NR’s book review editor, Mike Potemra, will still assign it for an appropriately timed review in the magazine.  This pre-review is regrettable.

Steorts directs readers to his two past writings on this subject (here and here), but he does not direct them to Sherif Girgis’s response, which came between his two (and to which Steorts’s second effort, in my opinion, does not effectively respond). This too would have been a proper thing to do, and Steorts’s lapse here as well is regrettable.

Finally, while I urge NRO’s readers to read What Is Marriage? as soon as they can, I urge them to consider in the meantime what to make of these lines by Steorts in his latest:

I think any claim that something is valuable—as distinct from the most precise possible description of what is valued—is nothing more than a say-so. So I don’t begrudge Girgis his say-so, at least on meta-ethical grounds. But I do think mine is more plausible.

If every claim that “something is valuable” is “nothing more than a say-so,” how can one view be held out as “more plausible” than another?  Steorts might want to reconsider whether relativism can be embraced and repelled at the same time.

Matthew J. Franck — Matthew J. Franck is the Director of the William E. and Carol G. Simon Center on Religion and the Constitution at the Witherspoon Institute in Princeton, New Jersey.

Most Popular


Courage: The Greatest of Virtues

EDITOR’S NOTE: The following is Jonah Goldberg’s weekly “news”letter, the G-File. Subscribe here to get the G-File delivered to your inbox on Fridays. Dear Reader (Or Listener), As the reporter assigned the job of writing the article about all of Sidney Blumenthal’s friends and supporters told his ... Read More

My American Dream

This morning, at 8 a.m., I did something I’ve wanted to do for as long as I can remember: I became an American. I first applied for a visa in early 2011, and since then I have slowly worked my way through the system — first as a visa-holder, then as a permanent resident (green card), and, finally, as a ... Read More

The Gun-Control Debate Could Break America

Last night, the nation witnessed what looked a lot like an extended version of the famous “two minutes hate” from George Orwell’s novel 1984. During a CNN town hall on gun control, a furious crowd of Americans jeered at two conservatives, Marco Rubio and Dana Loesch, who stood in defense of the Second ... Read More