The Corner

An Argument from the Hobby Lobby Hearings You Probably Haven’t Heard: There’s No Mandate

Liberal justices reportedly argued at several points today that one element of Hobby Lobby’s case against the HHS mandate that health insurance must cover contraception and certain controversial drugs doesn’t add up because . . . Hobby Lobby doesn’t have to provide health insurance. Thus, the ACA and the mandate don’t burden employers. But wait, doesn’t the ACA require that large employers provide health insurance? In the eyes of the Supreme Court, the individual mandate was a tax you could choose to pay in lieu of buying health insurance — and Justice Kagan argued today, essentially, that the same idea applies here.

Former solicitor general Paul Clement, who’s representing Hobby Lobby against the government, explained that the HHS mandate is a substantial burden on the firm’s religious liberty because providing coverage — sans all the contraception HHS requires — could cost them $500 million a year in fines. Here was Kagan’s response (via Dan Diamond of the Advisory Board):

Under this argument, the effect of the ACA is still that Hobby Lobby cannot provide health insurance without violating its conscience or paying $500 million a year in fines (whether it wants to do so by buying health insurance for them or providing self-insurance). The fact that it can pay $2,000 per employee per year instead of providing health insurance, and that some justices see this as a choice rather than a penalty, is absolutely not dispositive on whether the government is imposing a burden on their religious liberty. They can enter the market without a substantial burden, Kagan’s argument goes — but they can’t enter the market for health insurance. It’s an interesting point nonetheless.

This isn’t an entirely new argument — the New York Times’ recent editorial about the issue raised the idea, pointing to Georgetown law professor Martin Lederman’s use of it. ​ Ed Whelan, our ace legal blogger, has debated the topic with Lederman here, here, and here. In part Whelan offers the “modest proposition that people have religious-liberty rights under RFRA in how they carry out all the activities that they freely choose to engage in [i.e., including purchasing health insurance], not just in how they do the tasks that the federal government places substantial pressure on them to do.”

Patrick Brennan — Patrick Brennan is a writer and policy analyst based in Washington, D.C. He was Director of Digital Content for Marco Rubio's presidential campaign, writing op-eds, policy content, and leading the ...

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

Students’ Anti-Gun Views

Are children innocents or are they leaders? Are teenagers fully autonomous decision-makers, or are they lumps of mental clay, still being molded by unfolding brain development? The Left seems to have a particularly hard time deciding these days. Take, for example, the high-school students from Parkland, ... Read More
PC Culture

Kill Chic

We live in a society in which gratuitous violence is the trademark of video games, movies, and popular music. Kill this, shoot that in repugnant detail becomes a race to the visual and spoken bottom. We have gone from Sam Peckinpah’s realistic portrayal of violent death to a gory ritual of metal ripping ... Read More

Romney Is a Misfit for America

Mitt’s back. The former governor of Massachusetts and occasional native son of Michigan has a new persona: Mr. Utah. He’s going to bring Utah conservatism to the whole Republican party and to the country at large. Wholesome, efficient, industrious, faithful. “Utah has a lot to teach the politicians in ... Read More
Law & the Courts

What the Second Amendment Means Today

The horrifying school massacre in Parkland, Fla., has prompted another national debate about guns. Unfortunately, it seems that these conversations are never terribly constructive — they are too often dominated by screeching extremists on both sides of the aisle and armchair pundits who offer sweeping opinions ... Read More

Fire the FBI Chief

American government is supposed to look and sound like George Washington. What it actually looks and sounds like is Henry Hill from Goodfellas: bad suit, hand out, intoning the eternal mantra: “F*** you, pay me.” American government mostly works by interposition, standing between us, the free people at ... Read More
Film & TV

Black Panther’s Circle of Hype

The Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) first infantilizes its audience, then banalizes it, and, finally, controls it through marketing. This commercial strategy, geared toward adolescents of all ages, resembles the Democratic party’s political manipulation of black Americans, targeting that audience through its ... Read More