Hysteria Alert — ‘Trump’s Cabinet Is a Coup Waiting to Happen’

Here we go again — another article talking about how the retired generals in Trump’s cabinet, civilians who are nominated by a civilian and confirmed by a civilian senate, represent the erosion of the principle of civilian control over the military. But this time, there’s a hysterical twist. The nomination of James Mattis for secretary of defense and John Kelly for secretary of homeland security and the selection of Michael Flynn for national security adviser is worse than a real-life coup. No, really. Here’s William Astore, writing in The Nation:

Collectively, the team of Mattis, Flynn, and Kelly could not be more symbolic of the ongoing process of subversion of civilian control of the military. With Trump holding their reins, these self-styled warriors will soon take charge of the highest civilian positions overseeing the military of the world’s sole superpower. Don’t think of this, however, as a “Seven Days in May” scenario in which a hard-headed general mounts a coup against an allegedly soft-hearted president. It’s far worse. Who needs a coup, when generals are essentially to be given free rein by a president-elect who fancies himself a military expert because, as a teenager, he spent a few years at a military-themed boarding school? [Emphasis added.]

Lots of people read this nonsense. Lots of people believe this nonsense. I’ve been arguing for some time that the prime threat to our national unity isn’t action but reaction. Activists and pundits take normal politics (retired generals have a long history of serving this nation in civilian offices, beginning with George Washington) and respond with an overreaction that pushes their fellow citizens into believing that the sky is falling.

The easy response is to say, “This just helps Trump.” It’s true, to an extent, but political crackups hurt America more than they help any given political party. They breed the “win at all costs” mentality that leads us to shed principle for victory and to view our political opponents as not just wrong but dangerous, even evil. We’re hating each other more, and that by necessity means we’re more susceptible to hysterical stupidity — so long as it’s directed at the other side.

David French — David French is a senior writer for National Review, a senior fellow at the National Review Institute, and an attorney.