Human Exceptionalism

Baby Emilio: Court Orders Treatment to Continue–For Now

Under the terms of Texas law, hospital ethics committees have the right to unilaterally vote to refuse wanted life-sustaining treatment. Known as “futile care theory” or “medical futility” or “inappropriate care,” such refusals are permitted to be made on quality of life judgments, not just whether the desired treatment would work.

Because of this statute, Texas has become ground zero for futile care theory. Happily, several attempts to impose the law have been thwarted by public pressure. Now, a court has issued a temporary restraining order preventing Children’s Hospital of Austin from removing Baby Emilio from life support. Doctors claim the boy is suffering, but note from the following quote in the story, they also say he has lost all higher brain functions:

Doctors and a hospital ethics panel determined the treatment is causing the boy to suffer without providing any medical benefit, said Michael Regier, general counsel for the Seton Family of Hospitals, which includes the children’s hospital.
Emilio is believed to have Leigh’s Disease, a progressive illness difficult to diagnose. He cannot breathe on his own, must have nutrition and water pumped into him, and can’t swallow or make purposeful movements, Regier said. He said Emilio’s higher order brain functions are destroyed.

Consider the lines I italicized: Life is what doctors assert is without “medical benefit.” But to state that helping a patient continue to live when that is what the patient/family wants is not a proper purpose of medicine when the patient/family wants it to be extended, is to turn medicine literally on its head.

I might not have made the same decision as Emilio’s mother has, but that is irrelevant. This is a value judgment. Members of ethics committees should have no right to impose their values over those of patients and families.

Let us hope the Texas Legislature revokes Texas’s misbegotten futile care law.

Wesley J. Smith — Wesley J. Smith is a senior fellow at the Discovery Institute’s Center on Human Exceptionalism.

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

The Coming Shellacking

Two years ago Donald Trump hijacked the Republican party. Now it’s time to think about what steps might have to be taken to regain control of it. The tocsin of doom that sounded this week in Pennsylvania’s 18th Congressional District could hardly have been more clear in its meaning: This November the GOP ... Read More

The Anthropology of Manhood

A friend once told me that being a man meant two things: taking care of your loved ones and burying your dead. Everything else flows from that. If only it were that simple. Always hard to define but easy to flunk, manhood has become even more fraught in recent years. A slew of sexual-assault and -harassment ... Read More
White House

The Real Collusion Story

Barack Obama keeps a close watch on his emotions. “I loved Spock,” he wrote in February 2015 in a presidential statement eulogizing Leonard Nimoy. Growing up in Hawaii, the young man who would later be called “No-Drama Obama” felt a special affinity for the Vulcan first officer of the U.S.S. Enterprise. ... Read More