The Corner

Politics & Policy

Dylan, Never Trump, and Mike Maturen

Bob Dylan really deserves the Nobel Prize for Literature. You can find anything you want in his lyrics, and he’s right, time and again, to have cautioned us not to make more of his tunes than is really there. Here’s what’s there: all kinds of seeking, searching, and experimenting And very little politics or fashionable causes. There’s no one else remotely like him, and everyone at most every level of our culture samples him. A great victory for American music and artistic integrity.

So much for good news.

I’ve gotten an invitation to sign, along with other conservative and libertarian scholars, a “Never Trump” manifesto, based on the proposition that he’s easily the most dangerous of the candidates to our Constitution and our beliefs.

It would obviously be a good idea to sign, insofar as I would be publicly aligned with the decent conservatives. And I really admire and respect the scholarly integrity of everyone on the distinguished list.

I have no plans whatsoever to vote for Trump. I will almost surely vote, in case you’re wondering, for Mike Maturen, the candidate of the American Solidarity Party. I will explain why soon.

Still, I can’t bring myself to sign. My reasons are doubtless vain and perverse. And they amount to this: Trump doesn’t need my help to lose.

Trump would be dangerous if he had any chance of being president. He doesn’t. He never did. But now he’s collapsing. His campaign has been reduced to vengeance and resentment, a disgusting display of a hugely disordered soul. Even making America great again is no longer on the agenda, because even Trump’s supporters no longer believe that their man will be a winner.

I think most Republicans haven’t quite faced up to what’s happening. Lots of Trump voters think themselves betrayed by the elite of the Republican party and won’t vote Republican down ballot. Trump never cared about and now is positively hostile to other Republicans’ winning. Lots of other moderately Republican Americans — including women and the college-educated in general — are so repulsed by the party elite that humored Trump for so long that they’re pulling the plug on all their party’s candidates. How bad can it get? My only answer is, Really bad.

So “Never Trump” isn’t going to be very effective at this point in saving the rest of the ticket. The reason that Paul Ryan wasn’t “Never Trump” was that he could see that the Republicans at all levels couldn’t win without the support of Trump and his supporters. So he gambled that Trump could hold it together enough to lose respectably in November. Well, it turns out he couldn’t, and Ryan compromised his soul and his brand as a result. (Let’s admit that Ryan is a man of fine character and typically bad public judgment, and now even his character is being questioned.)

As it turned out, the Democrats, in the context of the American “cognitive elite” that they represent (see Clinton’s secret teaching in her speeches to said elite and in her e-mails), were stunningly astute in exploiting Trump’s huge weaknesses a little bit at a time. I don’t regret that their hardball couldn’t be played by the whiny loser Trump.

Still, that’s the elite of course that has contempt for the whiny losers who voted for Bernie and for the deplorable losers who support Trump, for the backward Catholics who still have beliefs on the wrong side of history, for the rednecks with whom Bill Clinton grew up and whom he outgrew, for those who don’t believe that the point of America is to outgrow our borders in the direction of the unmediated cosmpolitanism of the free market — for those, in general, who are uncomprehendingly envious of the complicated lives of the Clintons and the folks at Goldman Sachs.

It’s easy to regret, in the wake of the huge impact of the populist insurgencies of Sanders and Trump, that the establishment candidate of our allegedly coldly uncaring elite will win easily and in some ways undeservedly. I can say that without saying one bleepin’ good thing about the character or competence of the contemptibly pathetic man Trump.

If you’re gong to vote for candidate who might win, you’re going to vote for Hillary Clinton.

Otherwise, even if you vote for Trump, your choice is going to be some kind of protest against the inevitable.

So, as it turns out, Trump really is a uniquely terrible president candidate. It also turns out that his main damage to our democracy and our Constitution is to have deprived decent Americans of real discussion of alternative approaches to issues and principles during this campaign cycle.

When it comes to my vote: Never Trump. But let be more positive: Now I get to vote for solidarity and subsidiarity and indulge my nostalgia for the northern Democratic party dominated by the unions of the 1950s. That is very selective nostalgia, of course. And it is, in many respects, self-indulgently reactionary. Still, a little more solidarity and subsidiarity could really help us now.

Finally, don’t forget that Maturen is a semi-professional magician. Maybe he can make ISIS and the national debt disappear.

Peter Augustine Lawler — Peter Augustine Lawler is Dana Professor of Government at Berry College. He is executive editor of the acclaimed scholarly quarterly Perspectives on Political Science and served on President George ...

Most Popular

Elections

The State of the Race for the House

Way back in January, I went through the then-34 seats where a Republican incumbent was retiring and concluded that most were in deeply red districts and not likely to flip to Democrats. Pollsters and media organizations are less inclined to conduct surveys of House races, both because there’s less public ... Read More