Adam Serwer at The American Propsect:
Republicans have been struggling to reconcile crazed right-winger James von Brunnโs assault on the Holocaust Museum with their Manichean worldview in which people on the right represent everything that is decent and good about the world, and liberals represent only the purest of evil. Jonah Goldberg, who has made something of a career out of trying to convince people that discredited right wing movements are actually products of the left, takes a stab at doing the same with Von Brunn. Dave Weigel reports:
โFrom what I can tell,โ explained Jonah Goldberg, the author of the 2008 bestseller โLiberal Fascismโ and a writer for National Review, โhis hatreds echoed the kind of stuff we hear from the Kos crowd, Chris Matthews, Andrew Sullivan et al.โ Goldberg called Von Brunn โobjectively crazy,โ but argued that โhis hatreds would be easier to find at an ANSWER rally than at CPAC.โ
Thatโs right. A neo-nazi who hates blacks, Jews, and thinks Obama wasnโt born in the United States is going to be more at home with a group called โACT NOW TO STOP WAR AND END RACISMโ rather than the political convention where theyโre selling Obama Waffles and conservative figures get applause for questioning Obamaโs citizenship. Look, the desperation here speaks for itself. No one would mistake von Brunn for the average conservative. But their breathless attempts to distance themselves only draw more attention to the fact that many conservatives have come to embrace the kind of conspiratorial fantasies that von Brunn believed in.
And the always comically inept David Neiwart at Crooks and Liars:
Last night, Glenn Beck and Jonah Goldberg tried an exercise similar to Rush Limbaughโs, in which they tried to construct a plausible argument that James von Brunn, the Holocaust Museum shooter, was actually a โfigure of the left.โ
They ran through the same list: He hated Bush, he hated โneocons,โ may have targeted the neocon Weekly Standard too, and most of all, he hated Jews.
Somehow omitted: He also hated black people, and he especially hated Obama because he believed he was controlled by Jews. (See the note he left behind.) He also hated the Federal Reserve, taxes, the United Nations, the federal government generically, admired Hitler, urged the reciminalization [sic] of miscegenation laws, and promoted The Protocols of the Seven Elders of Zion as fact. He worked at one time for Willis Cartoโs right-wing publishing house, Noontide Press, and used to sell copies of Cartoโs house organ The Spotlight.
Letโs see if I can deal succinctly with both of these. First, I should say that my e-mail to David Weigel was in haste as I was on a deadline and had just made a train to New York with my daughter in tow. If you read my column, you can see what I was trying to get at.
Anyway, I do love that Adam Serwer takes at face value that ANSWER is truly dedicated to fighting racism and war because, by golly, the Stalinist front organization that has defended terrorists, tyrants, and warmongers, says so in their title. I guess all those Cold War lawyersโ committees for peace and justice were simply dedicated to peace and justice, too. I also suppose the signs at ANSWER rallies reading โSmash the Jewish State, Smash the Jewish Raceโ were expressions of love and hope. I also suppose the ADL is hallucinating when it writes:
In addition to claims that Israel is guilty of โwar crimesโ against Palestinians and that Israel is a โracist state,โ ANSWER events, which often attract protestors by the tens of thousands, have openly supported terror groups targeting Israelis, as well as the โresistanceโ fighting American forces in Iraq. This environment has led to displays of anti-Semitic sentiments, such as signs comparing Israeli leaders to Nazis or equating the Jewish Star of David with the Nazi swastika.
ANSWER, which considers Israel a capitalist outpost for Western powers, has supported anyone that counters the spread of capitalism around the world, including genocidal dictators such as Saddam Hussein and Slobodan Milosovic. ANSWER sees Hezbollah and the Palestinian terror organizations as being at the forefront of the war against capitalism and American imperialism. During a July 31, 2006 interview with FOX News ANSWERโs national coordinator, Brian Becker, said: โDo I consider Hezbollah a terrorist organization? The answer is no.โ
I donโt know anything about โObama wafflesโ other than whatโs yielded from a quick Google search, but whether the product is simply in very poor taste or whether itโs racist, it is hardly the stuff of the Klan. And, as fruitless and overheated as the Obama birth certificate thing has become, Iโm at a loss as to how it is racist (and I reject liberalismโs relentless insistence that racism = right-wing). I can assure you that youโd be hearing the same arguments about Obamaโs eligibility for office if all the facts were same, except that he was white. Was the discussion of McCainโs birth in Panama racist too?
As for Neiwert, as usual, he is so beholden to his cartoonish version of fascism that heโs being intellectually dishonest. If you watch the video provided (around 4:20 or so) youโll see that neither Beck nor I say von Brunn is left-wing. We say we donโt think heโs left-wing. Admittedly thereโs a lot of crosstalk, but that sentiment is very clear to a fair-minded viewer. But if Neiwart had a hard time hearing it, he could have consulted my column in which I wrote:
Never mind that von Brunn isnโt a member of the far right. Nor is he a member of the far left, as some on the right are claiming. Heโs not a member of anything other than the crazy caucus. Von Brunnโs True North is conspiratorial anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism. Heโs not a member of the Christian Right. In fact, he denounces Christianity โ just as Hitler did โ as a Jewish plot against paganism and Western vigor. Nor is he a capitalist. Again, just as Hitler did, he hails socialism as the solution to the Westโs problems.
I did not know the stuff about the Noontide press and, contrary to all of my instincts, I will take Neiwert at his word that thatโs all true and fairly presented. But, Iโm still hard-pressed to know what the point is. Mainstream conservatism has nothing whatsoever to do with white-supremacist nuts (and miscegenation laws are hardly uniquely conservative or of right-wing provenance). Neiwert lists some things that have a conservative connotation โ hating the U.N. for example โ and takes no account of the fact that von Brunn believed socialism is the future and shared a hatred of neocons, Bush, and The Jews that, I will say again, is more apt to be found at an ANSWER rally than at CPAC. Many members or heroes of the ANSWER coalition believe the Protocols of the Elders of Zion are real, or at least useful. Some of them believe a Jewish conspiracy took over the U.S. government under Bush. And, if you consider Jeremiah Wright part of that constellation in some sense, they continue to believe it. I have no problem condemning โright-wingโ organizations that traffic in such hateful nonsense. The amusing thing is that Mr. Serwer makes no effort here to do likewise about a far more influential left-wing organization that traffics in the same hateful nonsense. I guess he feels no need since, after all, ANSWERโs motives are right there in the title.
Update: Heh. A couple readers inform me that Noam Chomskyโs been published by the Noontide Press. Make of that what you will.






Comments