The Corner

GOP Consensus on Trump SCOTUS Pick: Sykes or Pryor

In conversations with a host of conservative legal experts at this week’s Federalist Society convention in Washington, what emerged was a striking consensus of a two-horse race to replace the late Justice Antonin Scalia on the Supreme Court. According to these sources — many of whom have had discussions with President-Elect Donald Trump’s transition team and therefore requested anonymity — it will come down to either Diane Sykes or William “Bill” Pryor.

Both are federal appellate judges: Sykes, a Wisconsinite, serves on the Seventh Circuit Court, while Pryor, an Alabama native, serves on the Eleventh Circuit Court. Both were appointed by former President George W. Bush. And both are viewed by conservatives as strict originalists who carry no risk of a David Souter-like transformation once appointed to the high court.

It’s no coincidence that these are the two jurists Trump mentioned by name during a February primary debate in South Carolina. “We could have a Diane Sykes or you could have a Bill Pryor,” Trump said when asked about making Supreme Court appointments. “We have some fantastic people.”

It’s a win-win for Republicans if Trump does ultimately choose between these two, as both are immensely popular in the conservative legal community. That said, Sykes and Pryor — both of whom spoke on panels at the Federalist Society gathering — each have supporters currently making arguments on their behalf (and against the other) behind the scenes in Washington. The short versions:

– Pryor isn’t just regarded as a brilliant legal mind; he is viewed as the most rock-ribbed conservative of any potential Supreme Court appointee. His ideological mooring makes him hugely appealing to elements of the conservative movement who have felt betrayed by Chief Justice John Roberts and are looking for the next Republican nominee to be an absolute slam-dunk. Pryor would certainly be that: He famously once ended a prayer by saying, “Please, God, no more Souters.” But there’s a downside to Pryor’s staunch conservatism: He could prove exceedingly difficult to confirm. There’s a reason Bush used a recess appointment to get Pryor on the appellate court back in 2004: Senate Democrats initially refused to confirm him, horrified that he had, in their view, equated same-sex relations with bestiality (a charge disputed by some on the right, Ramesh included) and had separately called the Roe v. Wade decision “the worst abomination of constitutional law in our history.” Pryor stood by those comments during his hearings and was eventually confirmed in 2005. That unflinching approach, while attractive to conservatives, could make for an unnecessarily messy confirmation.

– Sykes is considered to be every bit as conservative as Pryor, but is less controversial and would therefore offer a much smoother confirmation process. She also is — quite obviously – a woman, and Republicans have been eager for decades to appoint a female Supreme Court justice. (The Harriet Miers fiasco still haunts many GOP establishment types.) Allies of Sykes say it would prove especially difficult for Democrats to oppose her: She’s a 58-year-old single mother who hails from the heartland. (She attended Marquette Law School, which, for Republicans, would represent a refreshing break from the procession of Ivy League-educated nominees for the high court.) While Sykes is widely viewed as the safer bet for breezy Senate confirmation, there are slight concerns about her divorce from conservative radio personality Charlie Sykes. The two are said to be on very good terms, but any marital difficulty — and the accompanying public records – can invite unwanted gossip and rumor-mongering.

As Trump continues to meet with conservative legal experts — including the Federalist Society’s Leonard Leo — we’ll update this space with any additional information we come across.

EDITOR’S NOTE: This post has been updated to clarify the year of Pryor’s recess appointment and confirmation.

Most Popular

White House

The Damning Inspector General’s Report

It is hard to believe that the run-up to the presidential-election year has plumbed such a depth of farcical degradation. It must be that Trump’s influence has contributed to unserious responses, but he can’t be blamed for the unutterable nonsense of his opponents and the straight men of the political class ... Read More
White House

The Damning Inspector General’s Report

It is hard to believe that the run-up to the presidential-election year has plumbed such a depth of farcical degradation. It must be that Trump’s influence has contributed to unserious responses, but he can’t be blamed for the unutterable nonsense of his opponents and the straight men of the political class ... Read More
Elections

Diversity Panic Hits the Democratic Field

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before. An Asian guy, two black guys, three white women (one of whom spent much of her life claiming to be Native American), a Pacific Islander woman, a gay guy, a Hispanic guy, two elderly Caucasian Jews (one a billionaire, the other a socialist), a self-styled Irishman, and a ... Read More
Elections

Diversity Panic Hits the Democratic Field

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before. An Asian guy, two black guys, three white women (one of whom spent much of her life claiming to be Native American), a Pacific Islander woman, a gay guy, a Hispanic guy, two elderly Caucasian Jews (one a billionaire, the other a socialist), a self-styled Irishman, and a ... Read More
World

Present at the Demolition

Economists at the World Bank and International Monetary Fund must feel pretty lucky these days. They work for just about the only institutions set up in the aftermath of World War II that aren't in the middle of an identity crisis. From Turtle Bay to Brussels, from Washington to Vienna, the decay of the economic ... Read More
World

Present at the Demolition

Economists at the World Bank and International Monetary Fund must feel pretty lucky these days. They work for just about the only institutions set up in the aftermath of World War II that aren't in the middle of an identity crisis. From Turtle Bay to Brussels, from Washington to Vienna, the decay of the economic ... Read More
World

Well . . . .

So much for my prophecies of doom. Britain's Conservatives won, and they won with a very healthy parliamentary majority, breaking through Labour’s “red wall” across the industrial (and post-industrial) Midlands and the North. The BBC: Leave-voting former mining towns like Workington, which was seen as ... Read More
World

Well . . . .

So much for my prophecies of doom. Britain's Conservatives won, and they won with a very healthy parliamentary majority, breaking through Labour’s “red wall” across the industrial (and post-industrial) Midlands and the North. The BBC: Leave-voting former mining towns like Workington, which was seen as ... Read More
White House

The Costs of Trivializing Impeachment

Resorting to a vague “abuse of power” theory, the House Judiciary Committee Friday morning referred two articles of impeachment to the full House on the inevitable party-line vote. The full House will impeach the president next week, perhaps Wednesday, also on the inevitable party-line vote. The scarlet ... Read More
White House

The Costs of Trivializing Impeachment

Resorting to a vague “abuse of power” theory, the House Judiciary Committee Friday morning referred two articles of impeachment to the full House on the inevitable party-line vote. The full House will impeach the president next week, perhaps Wednesday, also on the inevitable party-line vote. The scarlet ... Read More
World

The U.K. Elections Were the Real Second Referendum

In the end, it wasn’t close at all. Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour party met a fate to which it has been accustomed for most of the last half-century. Once again, the British roundly rejected socialism. Boris Johnson and his conservatives will form the next British government. This was no slight rejection. Labour ... Read More
World

The U.K. Elections Were the Real Second Referendum

In the end, it wasn’t close at all. Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour party met a fate to which it has been accustomed for most of the last half-century. Once again, the British roundly rejected socialism. Boris Johnson and his conservatives will form the next British government. This was no slight rejection. Labour ... Read More